Boxingscenes P4P ATG list. Grade a fighter day 34. What grade do you give Manny Pacquiao?

[HitmanTommy]

With Pacquiao's career very likely over, how do you grade him?

Vote accordingly. Once this list reaches 150 fighters, these votes, rankings and threads WILL be mailed to the fighters addresses in a giant sized neon colored envelope and they will see these votes and rankings. If you would like to give a reasoning for your vote, leave a comment as I am sure they would love to read it. After 150 fighters have been graded and ranked by the public here, everything will be mailed out to the fighters and they will have an opportunity to respond to their grades and rankings by replying to an email address I will provide them with. If they decide to leave a message, I will post it for everyone to see.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

* Votes above = All votes above their majority grade totaled up

*Overall grade = Majority grade percentage + all percentage votes above majority grade totaled.

Rankings are determined by adding the fighters majority grade percentage + all vote percentages above their majority grade.


HOW THE RANKING SYSTEM WORKS.

Lets take Lomachenko as an example. 44.64% voted him an A which is his majority grade.

23.21% voted him above an A so his total is 67.85%


A fighters majority grade does NOT change. Whatever the fighters majority grade is showing after the poll closes will be the class he is permanently in. A fighter in the B class CANNOT outrank an A fighter even if his percentage total is higher. He can only outrank other fighters in his class and below. Never above.


Majority Grade A+ Class All Time Great

Ranked #1 Roy Jones Jr. 92.00% A+ votes

Ranked #2 Julio Cesar Chavez Sr. 63.16% A+ votes

Ranked #3 Bernard Hopkins. 60.00% A+ votes

Ranked #4 Oscar De La Hoya. 54.76% A+ votes

Ranked #5 Marco Antonio Barrera. 43.75% A+ votes

Ranked #6 Michael Spinks. 39.29% A+ votes
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

*************Overall grades are totaled up for each individual class.****************

A Class (fighters that were voted A by the majority of the public)
Ranked #7 Juan Manuel Marquez 44.19% A votes/37.21% A+ votes = Overall grade 81.40%
Ranked #8 Andre Ward 37.84% A votes/35.14% A+ votes = Overall grade 72.98%
Ranked #9 Vasyl Lomachenko 44.64% A votes /23.21% A+ votes = Overall grade 67.85%
Ranked #10 Naseem Hamed 48.28% A votes/ 13.79% A+ votes = Overall grade 62.07%
Ranked #11 Shane Mosley 43.40% A votes /15.09% A+ votes = Overall grade 58.49%
Ranked #12 Mike Tyson 38.89% A votes/ 19.44% A+ votes- Overall grade 58.33
Ranked #13 Gennady Golovkin 30.16% A votes/23.81% A+ votes = Overall grade 53.97%
Ranked #14 Joe Calzaghe 28.21% A votes/25.64% A+ votes= Overall grade 53.84%
Ranked #15 Miguel Cotto 37.50% A votes/15.00% A+ votes = Overall grade 52.50%
Ranked #16 Felix Trinidad 37.93% A votes/13.79% A+ votes = Overall grade 51.72%
Ranked #17 Guillermo Rigondeaux 36.36% A votes/ 9.09% A+ votes = Overall grade 45.45%

A- Class (fighters that were voted A- by the majority of the public)
Ranked #18 David Haye 30.00% A- votes/0.00% votes above A- = Overall grade 30.00%

B+ Class (fighters that were voted B+ by the majority of the public)
Ranked #19 Terence Crawford 41.67% B+ votes/ 45.83% votes above B+ = Overall grade 87.50%
Ranked #20 Rid**** Bowe 29.41% B+ votes / 41.17% votes above B+ = Overall grade 70.58%
Ranked #21 David Tua 43.33% B+ votes/10.00% votes above B+ = Overall grade 53.33%

B Class (fighters that were voted B by the majority of the public)
Ranked #22 Ricky Hatton 28.21% B votes/53.84% votes above B = Overall grade 82.05%
Ranked #23 Frank Bruno 42.86% B votes/33.33% votes above B = Overall grade 76.19%
Ranked #24 Fernando Vargas 33.33% B votes/ 38.90% votes above B = Overall grade 72.23%
Ranked #25 Antonio Margarito 33.33% B votes/37.04% votes above B = Overall grade 70.37%
Ranked #26 Zab Judah 30.95% B votes/33.33% votes above B = Overall grade 64.28%
Ranked #27 Hasim Rahman 47.62% B votes/9.52% votes above B = Overall grade 57.14%
Ranked #28 Adrien Broner 30.30% B votes/9.09% votes above B = Overall grade 39.39%

B- Class (fighters that were voted B- by the majority of the public)
Ranked #29 Amir Kahn 22.73% B- votes/ 47.73% votes above B- = Overall grade 70.46%

C+ Class (fighters that were voted C+ by the majority of the pubic)
Ranked #30 Deontay Wilder 30.30% C+ votes/42.42% votes Above C+ = Overall grade 72.72%
Ranked #31 Paulie Malignaggi 31.58% C+ votes/28.95% votes Above C+ = Overall grade 60.53

C Class (fighters that were voted C by the majority of the public)
Ranked #32 Shannon Briggs 31.71% C votes/ 46.34% votes Above C = Overall grade 78.05%

D-F Class (fighters that were voted D-F by the majority of the public)
Ranked #33 Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. 38.10% D-F votes/ 61.89% votes Above D-F

5c3f9e73240000d9009f9f71.jpg

[HitmanTommy]

lets get it.

[Richie_R]

Easily GOAT

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

A+ without question for me.

[hugh grant]

If he's unarguably best of era is it a A+?

[HitmanTommy]

If he's unarguably best of era is it a A+?

Should be a good one.

[IronDanHamza]

A+.

Not debatable in any way.

[HitmanTommy]

A+.

Not debatable in any way.

Well there is one poster who has been here for years gave him a B+. His name is Johnny2x2x

Would like to hear his reasoning if he is willing to share.

[clmags12]

A+. Thankful to see a legend be born.

[Dodger07]

A+ without a doubt. One of the absolute greats.