would you consider pacquiao the best 140 pounder if he beats hatton?

[gopi11]

course not.hatton wont be p4p no.1 if he beats the best p4p fighter so manny wont be no.1 at 140lbs if he beats the best 140lber

Stop making fun of yourself here...

[The_Demon]

Stop making fun of yourself here...

wot,u saying im wrong?

[gopi11]

wot,u saying im wrong?

The criteria for the P4P list is way different from the divisional standings. You've been here for quite a while and you should know that by now. There's a dozen threads here popping everyday that tackles that subject.

The P4P throne is a different animal, not unlike being a lineal champ were getting there has very defined road map, you beat the man, you're the man...

[The_Demon]

The criteria for the P4P list is way different from the divisional standings. You've been here for quite a while and you should know that by now. There's a dozen threads here popping everyday that tackles that subject.

The P4P throne is a different animal, not unlike being a lineal champ were getting there has very defined road map, you beat the man, you're the man...

so u think if manny wins hes the king at 140?

[silip03]

Nope. He will be the division Champ, because he beated Hatton. he will need to beat atleast the next 2 inline at 140 to be consider as such. Styles makes fights and He could quckly dispose hatton and then have lots of touble with a guy like Badley, fo Example,ect,ect,ect!!!!!!!!

manny time is running out he have 1 or 2 fights and will retired. i dont want to see pac fight this bums in LW waste of time

[nujabes77]

I'd like to see him KTFO of Bradley after he KOs Hatton. Then he would be undisputed at 140 and P4P #1.

who is bradley?

[hookoutofhell]

yeah id consider him to be the man at that weight division if he beat hatton

[gopi11]

so u think if manny wins hes the king at 140?

If you think your man is the reigning king at 140, then Manny will be the newly crowned king if he wins. If a challenger defeats a champion, he's the new champion, unless the belt/crown wasn't on the line, or it was just a non-title fight...

[The_Demon]

If you think your man is the reigning king at 140, then Manny will be the newly crowned king if he wins. If a challenger defeats a champion, he's the new champion, unless the belt/crown wasn't on the line, or it was just a non-title fight...

well hatton is the man,and im sure manny would be classed as the man if he wins.but id need to see another fight before i said that,just my opinion

[Ray*]

No, It wouldnt make pacman the best 140 without beating the top 1 or 2 140 Ib, I dont really think Hatton is the best 140 Ib anyway.

This would be like Mayweather beating Baldomir at 147 even though their were better fighters at 147 than baldomir.