Who more deserving to get the nod? Johnson over Dawson or Marquez over Pac II

[warp1432]

Discuss. I think it's pretty hard to choose as I felt even though it wasn't a robbery, both the losers clearly won.

I'll vote Marquez to piss off the pinoys

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I thought Marquez won 8 rounds to 4. It was a close action fight but I couldnt see how Pacquiao won.

I thought Johnson won 7-5 but Ive only watched it once and could maybe see Dawson winning

[Silencers]

Marquez over Pacquiao for me.

[KESSLER]

Pacquiao-Marquez II was not as close as Dawson-Johnson.

[sylvestersweet]

That's not really a fair question they're both wholly deserving

[egreezy]

I had Marquez and Dawson winning. I believe I had it 8-4 Marquez. Chad landed the most punches with combos, him getting hurt in 2 rounds doesn't negate that. I had 8-4 Dawson but 7-5 is acceptable.

[2501]

Dawson edged out Johnson. Being hurt a couple of times shouldn't be the reason for a loss when the fighter controlled most of the fight. close, but Dawson won

[ßringer]

Both were bad scoring at it's finest.

Though you can make more of a case for Pac deserving the nod over Juan, than you can Chad deserving it over Glen.

My vote goes to Johnson/Dawson.

[ßringer]

I thought Marquez won 8 rounds to 4. It was a close action fight but I couldnt see how Pacquiao won.

I thought Johnson won 7-5 but Ive only watched it once and could maybe see Dawson winning

Took the words right out of my mouth, son.

[egreezy]

Pacquiao-Marquez II was not as close as Dawson-Johnson.

how when there was more back and forth action in that fight