Fernando Vargas: Hall Of Fame?

[!! AI-Holmes!!]

He should be inducted into the HOP....House of Pancakes.

[-Antonio-]

If his win against Wright were convincing then I'd say yes, but it wasnt. I actually thought Winky won clearly.

Winky, Castillejo, Marquez, Quartey, Campas, competes in the best 154 fight of all time, stays very competitive with Oscar. Yeah that's enough to make it eventually IF the Winky win were legit, but it's not.

[moy22487]

If his win against Wright were convincing then I'd say yes, but it wasnt. I actually thought Winky won clearly.

Winky, Castillejo, Marquez, Quartey, Campas, competes in the best 154 fight of all time, stays very competitive with Oscar. Yeah that's enough to make it eventually IF the Winky win were legit, but it's not.

remember what counts is what goes on the record books. oscar will always be remembered for loseing to tito when many people think he won

[passdabutter]

If his win against Wright were convincing then I'd say yes, but it wasnt. I actually thought Winky won clearly.

Winky, Castillejo, Marquez, Quartey, Campas, competes in the best 154 fight of all time, stays very competitive with Oscar. Yeah that's enough to make it eventually IF the Winky win were legit, but it's not.

ya that fight was given to vargas

[Darkstar]

I dont think he should be in the HOF. But I due give credit for his win over winky. It was close but I thought he won, Winky completely gave away the 12th round of a close fight. Thats what you get.

[Rane-Ex54]

i always go off my first instincts and those are no for vargas, dude was rioding verse de la hoya and still lost. You can't get in with 2 decent wins & get KTFO by the rest of the best.

youngest middlewight champ is a good accomplishment but still not enough.

[Silencers]

I don't think he should be in the HOF. Lost when he stepped up his oppsition, got a gift decision against Wright.

[ELPacman]

**** no! This guy was owned by his best opponents. Then he gets finished off by one of the worst boxers to grace this ring in Ricardo Mayorga. The man can't even hit a speed bag properly for god's sake and he beat **** outta Vargas. Plz don't think people like Vargas can get in HoF.

[passdabutter]

**** no! This guy was owned by his best opponents. Then he gets finished off by one of the worst boxers to grace this ring in Ricardo Mayorga. The man can't even hit a speed bag properly for god's sake and he beat **** outta Vargas. Plz don't think people like Vargas can get in HoF.

dont hate too much on mayorga at least he beat forrest twice

forrest is a hell of a fighter and very overlooked

[-Hyperion-]

he lost to all the great fightersd he faced and got 2 gift decisions over ike, winky

tehres something seriously wrong with your scoring if you really think vargas didnt beat quartey........and i dont like him at all(though i do respect him)....

also even though im a big fan of winky i thought vargas gave him his second closest fight(although wink had some fault in that but w/e.........wink still won clearly)


if pipino cuevas can be there, why cant Fernando???......