If Dela Hoya beats Mayweather, will Oscar be automatically P4P#1???

[Mishra100]

Under some of these rational, Taylor should be #1 P4P by a mile.

[loui_ludwig]

Under some of these rational, Taylor should be #1 P4P by a mile.

R u serious? JT as 1 at P4P. Controversial win against BHOP. The rematch wasn't exactly exciting. A draw that many believed that Winky should have won. His win against Ouma is alright. But his not #1.

[loui_ludwig]

If Oscar beats PBF, i will rank him at #8. If he fights and win against Winky, then he will be #1 but depending on the competitions of the other P4P fighters.

[GattiFan]

Very near the top.

Lots of guys deserve it. But if an old DLH beats what a lot of you call "The best fighter of our generation" then yea....Very near the top.

Cases can be made for Pac, Wright, Etc..

[Super_Lightweight]

P4P rankings are not all that anyway. What matters is, if Oscar wins, boxing will be in a buzz and Oscar will be glowing.

If Oscar wins a decision, which no one expects, then that would be just as big as a KO if the decision is convincing. A KO is kind of expected of Oscar if he is to win at all. Whatever way Oscar wins, if he does, it will be fair to put him top 5 p4p afterwards.

My uncle, ref Tommy Kimmons, who is reffing the upcoming Toney-Peter fight, has picked Floyd to win a decision. He says Oscar will be very dangerous in the first 4 rounds though.

[Njord777]

P4P rankings are not all that anyway. What matters is, if Oscar wins, boxing will be in a buzz and Oscar will be glowing.

If Oscar wins a decision, which no one expects, then that would be just as big as a KO if the decision is convincing. A KO is kind of expected of Oscar if he is to win at all. Whatever way Oscar wins, if he does, it will be fair to put him top 5 p4p afterwards.

My uncle, ref Tommy Kimmons, who is reffing the upcoming Toney-Peter fight, has picked Floyd to win a decision. He says Oscar will be very dangerous in the first 4 rounds though.

Wouldn't Floyd look like a beast if he took Oscar's left hook, got dropped, and brushed himself off to dominate the rest of the fight?

[tonedabone]

i cant believe anyone would consider winky anything other than boring let alone pfp

[Super_Lightweight]

Wouldn't Floyd look like a beast if he took Oscar's left hook, got dropped, and brushed himself off to dominate the rest of the fight?

That would be pretty big, because if he gets dropped, Oscar will go for the kill and it will be very hard for Floyd to deal with that.

[Super_Lightweight]

i cant believe anyone would consider winky anything other than boring let alone pfp

You have a lot to learn about boxing.

Sweet Pea Whittaker was one of the most boring fighters of all time, and also one of the greatest.

Ali was very boring at times.

[Mishra100]

R u serious? JT as 1 at P4P. Controversial win against BHOP. The rematch wasn't exactly exciting. A draw that many believed that Winky should have won. His win against Ouma is alright. But his not #1.

Yeah... Is Oscar can be #1 by beating the #1 guy... Then Taylor is #1 now. Taylor beat the p4p #1 twice and drew against the #2 guy.