Originally posted by Brassangel

Okay, picks on Round 2 (even though they've already been "decided"

Ali vs Schmeling....This one I see as a tactical battle for 15 rounds. Schmeling was a well schooled technician; but would be at a huge disadvantage from a size and speed perspective, which would ultimately be the difference in the fight.....Ali by UD.
Johnson vs Dempsey....Great style match up; offense personified vs defensive personified. Surely no one was better at fending off punches and countering than Jack Johnson; but it's hard for me to imagine him fending off a blizzard like Dempsey would be throwing early on without getting tagged a few times at least. The way I see it, there are two determining factors in this bout. 1.)Dempsey was the first fighter that I know of that used the kind of head movement and ferocity that is still being used...he, essentially, was the first "modern" fighter. Jack Johnson, great as he was, to me knowledge, never faced a fighter as hard to hit as Dempsey and Johnson wasn't known for his activity anyway...so, he would have trouble connecting solidly on Dempsey and while he could punch, Dempsey could take a shot, so this fight's going the distance from Johnson's perspective. The second factor #2...is Dempsey's oft underrated boxing ability. He is remembered primarily as a slugger; but he was far more than that. He proved against the crafty Tommy Gibbons that he could box when the occasion called for it....and it surely would against Johnson..........Dempsey by SD.
Marciano vs Holyfield....Call it two crusierweights going to war...or hell, you pick. Tyson said Holyfield was the best counterpuncher he ever faced and it's reasonable to presume Evander would try to fight a similar fight against Rocky that he did against Tyson who is about the same height. This fight would look like an amalgom of Holyfield-Tyson, Holyfield-Qawi, and Marciano-Charles, IMO. There are several differences, of course; Marciano's deceptive defense where he leaned back and away from the right hand and Holy punching harder than Charles; but while I see a few potential knockdowns for Holy in this affair, I can't see him stopping Marciano unless it's on a cut. Conversely, Rocky gets no one puncher against Evander; but I can see his constant pressure wearing on Evander over the 15 round course.........Marciano by TKO in 13.
Baer vs Tyson....Damn! Don't leave your seat for any reason! Baer showed against Louis that he could be stopped by a hard puncher with fast hands and a good left hook. Granted, Tyson wasn't the technician that Louis was; but neither was Baer. This one would be a wild affair for as long as it went.....Tyson by KO in 4.
Louis vs Bowe....TIMBER!!! Louis, IMO, was too well schooled and hit too hard for the bigger Bowe. Rid**** showed against Holyfield, who is not a knock-out puncher, that he could be hurt. Now, that's not to say Bowe wouldn't get Louis on the canvas, for I can see that as well; but when it come time to dig deep, Joe's got the edge..........Louis by TKO in 9.
Lewis vs Foreman....Two things; Foreman showed he could battle back through adversity as he did against Lyle, while Lewis showed he could be stopped with one shot against mediocre competition with above average power. If one were to describe George's power, "above average" are not the words that come to mind. True, Lewis was a far superior boxer and had pop of his own; but his chin vs Forman's power is the difference here, IMO.......Foreman by KO in 3.
Holmes vs Charles....No doubt Charles speed and ability would give Holmes some trouble; but, once again, Holmes jab is no cupcake and he would use it to great effect to keep the smaller man where he wanted him. Talk about a chess match.....Holmes by UD.
Jeffries vs Liston......Liston was the better boxer and faster of hand while both men hit incredibly hard and both could take a tremendous shot. I think the issue here could be stamina. I can see Liston building up an early lead; but Jeff's punches to the ribs as well as Sonny's head wearing on him down the stretch. Liston's jab would undoubtedly bust Jeff's mug up by the time the fight reached the final stanzas; but by that point I can see Sonny fighting with his mouth open and either quitting on his stool or being stopped. There was no quit in Jeff, while we know Liston quit at least once. This fight comes down to mentality.........Jeffries comes from behind to win.......Jeffires by TKO in 11.
Least...that's how I see 'em.

Comment