Which ATG doesn't have any controversial decision win(s)?

[joseph5620]

Did Carlos Zarate win any controversial decisions?

[Scott9945]

Did Carlos Zarate win any controversial decisions?

Well he only won three decisions in his 66 wins, lol. But his first fight back after a 7 year layoff was a majority decision. Good luck finding any video of that.

[kiDynamite92]

How about joe Frazier?
Rid**** Bowe I think could be mentioned, i saw both his Holyfield victories as fair

[Build That Wall]

Mike Tyson

Aaron Pryor

Rid**** Bowe

Bernard Hopkins was never on the end of a win from a contreversial decision but he was on the end of draws, and losses that were contreversial.

Same with Marquez, he never had a contreversial decision win but had lots of contreversial losses. His losses to Chris John and Manny Pacquiao were Contreversial and that draw.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Bernard Hopkins
Ricardo Lopez
Winky Wright
Marlon Starling
Carlos Monzon

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Mike Tyson

Aaron Pryor

Rid**** Bowe

Bernard Hopkins was never on the end of a win from a contreversial decision but he was on the end of draws, and losses that were contreversial.

Same with Marquez, he never had a contreversial decision win but had lots of contreversial losses. His losses to Chris John and Manny Pacquiao were Contreversial and that draw.

I thought jmm win over barrera was contrversial since the ref blew the knockdown call and deducted a point from MAB,, it was a MAB round 10-8 and instead it was JMM 10-8...... cost mab the fight i believe,,, i dont remember the exact scorecards

[Bolo Punch]

Quite a few people seem to be forgetting that the thread title includes 'ATG'.

[IronDanHamza]

Unless I've forgotten, I don't think Harold Johnson was on the winning end of a controversial decision.

Most ATG's have though.

[greeh]

I consider Gilberto Roman to be an all-time great, and I've never seen a win of his that was controversial.

X2. I can't remember that Carlos Zarate got any either.

/greeh

[Scott9945]

How about joe Frazier?
Rid**** Bowe I think could be mentioned, i saw both his Holyfield victories as fair

Nobody ever talks about this fight, but Frazier was very fortunate to get a draw with Jumbo Cummings in his final fight when he was just a shell of his old self.

Bowe won a close decision against Tony Tubbs that some thought he deserved to lose. But I've never seen that fight.