box rec P4P list

[D-MiZe]

How you can have Langford & Charles so low is strange.

Can you at least explain who they're below and why?

[raskat]

I believe it's based on;

- Wins over high ranked fighters
- Wins over fighters who are undefeated
- Wins via stoppage

if that was the case, both Klitschkos would be in the top 2.

[IronDanHamza]

if that was the case, both Klitschkos would be in the top 2.

How would Vitali Klitshcko be in the top 2 based on that criteria?

[andrewanubis]

so, this is boxrec's p4p list (top 20 at least)

1.archie Moore
2.sugar ray robinson
3.muhhaamad ali
4.ezzard charles
5.joe louis
6.sam langford
7.carlos monzon
8.carlos ortiz
9.**** tiger
10.tony canzoneri
11.henry armstrong
12.harry greb
13.jimmy mclarin
14.jimmy bivins
15.floyd patterson
16.emile griffith
17.rocky marciano
18.young corbett III
19.jose napoles
20.jack britton


what do you make of it? i know they "calibrate" these rankings through numbers, whatever numbers those are, so where do you agree disagree?

i dont get patterson above marciano wow, and wheres benny leonard, sandy saddler, willie pep, ted kid lewis, jimmy wilde, gene tunney