Pacquiao the greatest southpaw of all time ?

[Mast]

"While it is never been my habit to include a fighter who is still fighting, because I can not judge his entire career and/or where his prime was (his prime is where I judge) I think Manny Pacquiao is making one helluva case to be included. He's not only the greatest Asian fighter of all time, but the greatest lefthanded fighter of all time." - Bert Sugar

[JAB5239]

"While it is never been my habit to include a fighter who is still fighting, because I can not judge his entire career and/or where his prime was (his prime is where I judge) I think Manny Pacquiao is making one helluva case to be included. He's not only the greatest Asian fighter of all time, but the greatest lefthanded fighter of all time." - Bert Sugar

I'd take Whitaker over him and possibly Hagler, but he's up there for sure.

[Canelo Phresh]

no. hagler.

[Barn]

Whitaker
Hagler
Pacquiao

[BigStereotype]

Whitaker
Pacquiao
Hagler

[Barn]

Whitaker
Pacquiao
Hagler

Domination > Alphabet soup.

[BigStereotype]

Domination > Alphabet soup.

Maybe, but I look at Pacquiao and see a better fighter than Hagler.

[joseph5620]

"While it is never been my habit to include a fighter who is still fighting, because I can not judge his entire career and/or where his prime was (his prime is where I judge) I think Manny Pacquiao is making one helluva case to be included. He's not only the greatest Asian fighter of all time, but the greatest lefthanded fighter of all time." - Bert Sugar

No. I would rank Whitaker and Hagler higher.

[IronDanHamza]

I have Whitaker and Hagler both ahead of him.

It's an arguable subject but never in my life will I ever say Manny Pacqiauo is better or greater than Pernell Whitaker, I know that much.

[joseph5620]

Domination > Alphabet soup.

My thoughts exactly.