Does Marciano Beat The 1950 Versions of Charles & Walcott?

[Ivich]

Does Rocky prevail over fresher versions of these 2 champs?Say the 1950 editions?
Charles fought Rocky in1954.
Walcott fought him in1952 and 53.
What do you think?

[The Old LefHook]

Wouldn't do them any good.

[Marchegiano]

Marciano only loses in a fantasy.

[Willow The Wisp]

Marciano beats them both I believe.

[Anthony342]

Two of the few fantasy matchups he wins.

[The Old LefHook]

Marciano conquers all.

[Willie Pep 229]

Marciano gains from earlier fights; it makes him two to four years younger as well. It's not as if he gained in skill during those years. He would have been younger and hungrier had they met in 1950 and KOs both anyway, maybe faster.

[QueensburyRules]

- - 1950 near prime peak for Jersey Joe and Ez, but could they beat is prime, peak Rocky is the only question worth asking, ie in the middle of his title reign.

I'm not smart enough to know other than they'd be among the greatest of fights.

[Ivich]

Marciano gains from earlier fights; it makes him two to four years younger as well. It's not as if he gained in skill during those years. He would have been younger and hungrier had they met in 1950 and KOs both anyway, maybe faster.

I''m using the Marciano that actually fought those men,but replacing them with fresher less shopworn versions
of themselves.For what its worth the 1950 version of Rocky likely loses to both imo.
He was **** in his prime when he actually faced them which cannot be said for them.

[The Old LefHook]

Prove to me that Walcott was better in 1950.