Advertisement: IBO Boxing
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com
Advertisement

Examining the Badou Jack-Lucian Bute Scorecards

by David P. Greisman

On one hand, no harm, no foul. Badou Jack still left with his world title after a majority draw against Lucian Bute in a fight that looked as if it should’ve been a victory for Jack.

On the other hand, there’s still a draw on Jack’s record now, even if he didn’t suffer a second loss.

Two judges — Omar Mintun of Mexico and Glen Crocker of Texas — had it even at 114-114, while D.C. area judge Stephen Rados had Jack winning 117-111, or nine rounds to three.

jack-bute-fight (5)_1

Although Mintun and Crocker ended up with the same score, they only agreed on 8 of the 12 rounds.

In comparison, Mintun and Rados agreed on seven of the 12. It was Crocker who was the outlier, agreeding with Radios on only five of the 12 rounds.

All three judges had Jack winning rounds 1 and 2.

Mintun and Rados had Jack winning Round 3, while Crocker gave the edge to Bute.

All three judges had Jack winning Round 4 and had Bute winning round 5.

Mintun and Crocker felt Round 6 belonged to Bute, while Rados had it for Jack.

After six, Mintun had it 4-2 for Jack, Crocker had it 3-3, and Rados had it 5-1 for Jack.

Mintun and Crocker felt Round 7 belonged to Jack, while Rados had it for Bute.

Round 8 went to Jack on Mintun and Rados’ cards, while Crocker felt it was Bute’s.

There was plenty of disagreement in the final third of the fight.

Each of the last four rounds went to Bute on Mintun’s scorecard. Crocker agreed with him in Round 10 and 11, otherwise giving Jack rounds 9 and 12. Rados gave Jack rounds 9, 10 and 11 and had Bute winning the 12th.

There were only four rounds in which all three judges agreed.

If we were to take a score from “majority rules” — in which a fighter gets the edge from at least 2 of the 3 judges for that round — then Jack would’ve won seven rounds (1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8 and 9) while Bute would’ve won five rounds (5, 6, 10, 11 and 12). That would’ve given Jack a 115-113 victory.

Pick up a copy of David’s book, “Fighting Words: The Heart and Heartbreak of Boxing,” at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsamazon or internationally at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsworldwide. Send questions/comments via email at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by WallabeeKing on 05-03-2016

This sh1t was a draw and what ensued after was embarrassing.

Comment by kennethjohn on 05-02-2016

this was a pretty close fight that jack should have won. 8, 10,11,12 were pretty clear bute rounds. the rest of the fight could have went to jack. It's pretty easy to find one more round for bute too so…

Comment by The D3vil on 05-02-2016

Don't try to justify this bull****. Jack beat Bute fair and square

Comment by aboutfkntime on 05-02-2016

[QUOTE=knockoutkid;16666556]I dont wana know about that judge who lost his marbles and lost his competency or how many or if any bets he screwed up for me. Any of these guys got alziemers? can they dress themselves? lol[/QUOTE] Steve Plunger…

Comment by knockoutkid on 05-02-2016

I dont wana know about that judge who lost his marbles and lost his competency or how many or if any bets he screwed up for me. Any of these guys got alziemers? can they dress themselves? lol

ADD COMMENT VIEW COMMENTS (13)
Advertisement
Top Headlines
Arum Says Whyte Should Be Next For Wilder-Fury Winner Parker: I Want Wilder-Fury Winner To Challenge Joshua Wilder-Fury Rematch: Nevada Commission Assigns Judges, Referee Wilder Looks To Break Ali Record With 'Devastating' KO Win Murat Gassiev Delays Return, Andrey Klimov Shocked in Moscow Shane Mosley Jr. Inks Co-Promotional With Golden Boy Rau'Shee Warren: I Want Rigondeaux Before End Of The Year, Get That Belt Wilder: Once I Knock Fury Out, You Won't Hear Nothing About Lineal Champion Fury: Rematch With Wilder Biggest Heavyweight Fight In 50 Years, Since Ali-Frazier Eddie Hearn: We Must See Joshua vs. Wilder-Fury Winner Mickey Bey Now a Free Agent, Aims For Big Fights Like Gervonta MTK Golden Contract: Leigh Wood Is Making Up For Lost Time Foreman: Fury Will Beat Wilder - Likely By Controversial Decision Fury Warns: I'm Going To Rip Wilder's Heart Out, Feed it To Him! Charlie Edwards, Liam Walsh, Michael McKinson Back on April 18 Amateur Champion's Arrest Creates Big Scandal in Russia First Encounters With Tyson Fury Tyson Fury: No British Judges For Wilder Rematch? Fantastic! Tyson Fury Media Interview on Deontay Wilder Rematch Deontay Wilder Media Interview on Tyson Fury Rematch Wilder: Tyson Fury Can't Punch - My Two-Year-Old Hits Harder! Navarrete-Santisima, Fundora-Lewis - Face-Offs at Grand Arrivals Charles Martin, Gerald Washington - Face-Off at Grand Arrival Tyson Fury Makes His Grand Arrival in Las Vegas Deontay Wilder Makes His Grand Arrival in Las Vegas Fury Slams Wilder's Record: Former NFL Players, Has-Beens, Bums! LIVE STREAM: Wilder vs. Fury II - Grand Arrivals in Las Vegas Catterall Will Not Step Aside To Allow Josh Taylor vs. Jose Ramirez Tyson Fury: Changing Trainer Was Best Decision I Ever Made Wilder vs. Fury Rematch: Predictions From Fighters, Trainers Fury, Arum Fire Back at Eddie Hearn Over Training Camp Rumors Steward: I Don't Want a Decision, Fury Doesn't Want a Decision Fury: I Wouldn't Have Switched To Trainer I Didn't Already Know Canelo vs. Saunders Very Likely To Get Done, Says MTK Exec MTK Golden Contract: Fights Now Set After Semi-Final Draw Boxeo Telemundo Returns To Its Roots For Season Premiere Tyson Fury: Money is Too Big Not Have Trilogy Clause in Contract Ramos: Just Goes To Prove That Fights Are Never Over Till It's Over Fury: Wilder Doesn't Hit Harder Than Klitschko; Can't Be Biggest Puncher Ever Tyson Fury: Steve Cunningham, Not Wilder, Was My Toughest Opponent
Advertisement
Advertisement
Latest Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement