Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Examining the Badou Jack-Lucian Bute Scorecards

by David P. Greisman

On one hand, no harm, no foul. Badou Jack still left with his world title after a majority draw against Lucian Bute in a fight that looked as if it should’ve been a victory for Jack.

On the other hand, there’s still a draw on Jack’s record now, even if he didn’t suffer a second loss.

Two judges — Omar Mintun of Mexico and Glen Crocker of Texas — had it even at 114-114, while D.C. area judge Stephen Rados had Jack winning 117-111, or nine rounds to three.

jack-bute-fight (5)_1

Although Mintun and Crocker ended up with the same score, they only agreed on 8 of the 12 rounds.

In comparison, Mintun and Rados agreed on seven of the 12. It was Crocker who was the outlier, agreeding with Radios on only five of the 12 rounds.

All three judges had Jack winning rounds 1 and 2.

Mintun and Rados had Jack winning Round 3, while Crocker gave the edge to Bute.

All three judges had Jack winning Round 4 and had Bute winning round 5.

Mintun and Crocker felt Round 6 belonged to Bute, while Rados had it for Jack.

After six, Mintun had it 4-2 for Jack, Crocker had it 3-3, and Rados had it 5-1 for Jack.

Mintun and Crocker felt Round 7 belonged to Jack, while Rados had it for Bute.

Round 8 went to Jack on Mintun and Rados’ cards, while Crocker felt it was Bute’s.

There was plenty of disagreement in the final third of the fight.

Each of the last four rounds went to Bute on Mintun’s scorecard. Crocker agreed with him in Round 10 and 11, otherwise giving Jack rounds 9 and 12. Rados gave Jack rounds 9, 10 and 11 and had Bute winning the 12th.

There were only four rounds in which all three judges agreed.

If we were to take a score from “majority rules” — in which a fighter gets the edge from at least 2 of the 3 judges for that round — then Jack would’ve won seven rounds (1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8 and 9) while Bute would’ve won five rounds (5, 6, 10, 11 and 12). That would’ve given Jack a 115-113 victory.

Pick up a copy of David’s book, “Fighting Words: The Heart and Heartbreak of Boxing,” at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsamazon or internationally at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsworldwide. Send questions/comments via email at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by WallabeeKing on 05-03-2016

This sh1t was a draw and what ensued after was embarrassing.

Comment by kennethjohn on 05-02-2016

this was a pretty close fight that jack should have won. 8, 10,11,12 were pretty clear bute rounds. the rest of the fight could have went to jack. It's pretty easy to find one more round for bute too so…

Comment by The D3vil on 05-02-2016

Don't try to justify this bull****. Jack beat Bute fair and square

Comment by aboutfkntime on 05-02-2016

[QUOTE=knockoutkid;16666556]I dont wana know about that judge who lost his marbles and lost his competency or how many or if any bets he screwed up for me. Any of these guys got alziemers? can they dress themselves? lol[/QUOTE] Steve Plunger…

Comment by knockoutkid on 05-02-2016

I dont wana know about that judge who lost his marbles and lost his competency or how many or if any bets he screwed up for me. Any of these guys got alziemers? can they dress themselves? lol

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (13)
Top Headlines Teofimo Lopez To Undergo Surgery on Right Hand on Friday Rey Vargas Already Back To Work, Hopes For Quick Return Photos: Jean Pascal, Steve Bosse - Face To Face at Final Presser Anthony Joshua: I'd Rather Lose Than Use PEDs To Win Toka Kahn Clary vs. Kid Galahad - IBF Eliminator Ordered Jazza Dickens vs. Martin Ward Rematch Off Due To Injury Dmitry Bivol: Fight Against Kovalev 'Most Likely' Will Happen Kalle Sauerland Talks WBSS Season 2 Draft, Usyk vs. Gassiev Photos: Mario Barrios Putting in Work For Jose Roman Jean Carlos Torres Headlines Return of PRBBP Series, August 10 Promoter: I Really Believed Munguai Would Knock Golovkin Out Lucas Matthysse Blasts Critics Who Claim He Quit With Pacquiao Abner Mares Joins Announce Team of Boxeo Telemundo Saunders vs. Andrade Purse Bid is Set By WBO For July 25 Anthony Joshua: This is Chapter 2 For Me - All Comers Welcome! Photos: Anthony Joshua, Alexander Povetkin - Face To Face in UK Ryan Martin, Terry Flanagan Aim To Shake Up WBSS Tourney Top Rank President is Very High on Teofimo Lopez Demetrius Andrade Not Expected To Face Billy Joe Saunders Next Miller: I Knew Joshua's a Punk; Wanted to Push His Buttons Manny Pacquiao vs. Lucas Matthysse: Afterthoughts Carl Frampton Getting Annoyed By Trash Talk of Luke Jackson Kamil Delighted After Winning The Right To Remain in Scotland Jermaine Franklin Decisions Craig Lewis at Motor City Casino Bellew: I Prefer Usyk-Gassiev Winner - But Fury Easier, Pays More Joshua: Wilder is Definitely Going To Happen - Confident I'll Win! Zeuge's Coach, Braehmer, Went Bonkers After Upset Loss Shakhram Giyasov Picks Up Stoppage Win in First Round Usyk, Gassiev Could Be One Step Away Before Heavyweight Leap Nacho: Canelo Needs The "Perfect Fight" To Beat Golovkin Subriel Matias vs. Breidis Prescott Set For August 18 Photos: Andrade, Vargas, Hooker, Roman Join Hearn, DAZN Photos: Anthony Joshua, Jarrell Miller - Confrontation in NYC Jarrell Miller-Artur Szpilka in Play For October 6 in Chicago Photos: Anthony Joshua, Alexander Povetkin - Go Face To Face Cindy Serrano Confident That She Will Shock Katie Taylor Chocolatito Solves Visa Issue, Hopes For September Return Joshua Warns Miller: Anyone is Welcome To Come Get The Smoke! Hearn: Greatest Thing To Happen To U.S. Boxing in a Long Time! Anthony Joshua, Jarrell Miller Erupt in Heated Confrontation
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement