Daniel Jacobs-Peter Quillin: Post-Fight Report Card

by Cliff Rold

Immediately after referee Harvey Dock called a halt to Saturday’s anticipated middleweight showdown between Daniel Jacobs-Peter Quillin, the call looked like one sure to be debated.

Anyone who has watched the slow motion replays, who was able to get a good look at what prompted Dock’s call, should come to one conclusion:

Dock got it right.

And Jacobs got it done.      

Let’s go the report card.


Pre-Fight: Speed – Jacobs B; Quillin B+/Post: B+; B+
Pre-Fight: Power – Jacobs B; Quillin B/Post: A; B
Pre-Fight: Defense – Jacobs B; Quillin B/Post: B; D
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Jacobs B; Quillin B+/Post: B+; C

There isn’t a ton to break down from the fight. It lasted six seconds shorter than Mike Tyson-Michael Spinks. That doesn’t mean it wasn’t exciting. It was the sort of fight that hits the adrenaline like an electric charge, the instinct to stand up there for fans in the arena or watching at home. 

Jacobs blinded Quillin with a blocked left hook, Quillin closed his eyes to brace, and Jacobs landed a right hand he never saw coming.

That’s what got Quillin in trouble and Jacobs never let him get out of it. Quillin tried to hold, tried to throw back. Quillin kept getting tagged. Sometimes a fighter gets caught cold and it happened Saturday. Jacobs was the fighter with better technique going in. He applied it quite efficiently.

The closing sequence saw Quillin’s legs weaving wildly even if he never went down. Replay viewings showed Dock taking a critical look. What he saw was a fighter whose eyes were as blank as his legs were rubbery. Quillin wasn’t looking at him, he wasn’t looking at Jacobs; he was staring into the abyss.

It stared back.

Jacobs still has question marks about his chin and durability but neither of those was tested Saturday. One question mark that is answered is on his power. He came in with a high knockout percentage but his opposition was just okay. Saturday he knocked a fighter silly who had seen pretty good foes and been sturdy. He is a serious knockout threat to anyone in the class.

Anyone probably won’t mean Gennady Golovkin. Boxing’s politics are what they are. Both men hold WBA titles. Golovkin’s is the ‘higher’ title in that silly organization’s pecking order. They only occasionally force showdowns between ‘super’ and ‘not super’ champs. It’s idiocy before we even get to the split between HBO and PBC/Showtime.

There are other good fights they can make for Jacobs. There could be a bidding war between factions for the winner of Andy Lee-Billy Joe Saunders. Erislandy Lara has talked about moving to 160 lbs. and a fight with Jacobs would be solid in-house matchmaking.

There is also a rematch with Quillin. There is often a feeling that a first-round ending can be a bit of a fluke. Quillin will probably need to rebuild with a win or two to make it the most sellable fight he can.

The best thing can be said is we saw it, along with several other clashes of top ten middleweights this year. Where it all leads will continue to play out in two weeks at Lee-Billy Joe Saunders and into 2016.

Report Card and Staff Picks 2015: 86-25

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Post a Comment - View More User Comments (0)
Top Headlines Danny Garcia on Thurman Loss: They Didn't Want Me To Win Sor Rungvisai is Pumped To Defend WBC Belt on October 6 Card Usyk, Bellew, Joshua, Ward, WBSS: Everyone's a Winner Arum: I Have To Sit With Pacquiao, Talk Face To Face on Future Mikey Garcia: I'm at More of a Disadvantage at 140 Video: Jaime Munguia Talks Smith Win, Plans For The Future Jaime Munguia vs. Liam Smith - CompuBox Punch Stats WBC Prez: Uysk, Gassiev Will Both Find Success at Heavyweight Naoya Inoue: The WBSS Presents a Real Challenge For Me Denis Lebedev May Push For Mandatory Shot at Usyk Cecilia Braekhus Very Pleased With Dominant Win in Moscow British Boxers Arrested in Connection To Alleged Gang Rape Gassiev: Usyk Showed I Need More Work, I'll Return Stronger Photos: Jean Pascal Dominates, Batters, Stops Steve Bosse Eddie Hearn: Talks For Bellew-Usyk Fight to Start This Week Mykquan Williams, Hurshidbek Normatov, Lennox Allen Win Munguia: Smith Can Take a Punch, I Gained A lot of Experience Alberto Machado: I Want Francisco Vargas Next! Photos: Jaime Munguia Powers Past Liam Smith- MEGA Gallery Photos: Usyk Schools Gassiev To Unify Cruiserweight Division Photos: Alberto Machado Decks, Dominates Mensah To Retain Liam Smith: Munguia is Not a Much Better Fighter Than Me Vivian Harris Gets Revenge on DeMarcus Corley in Rematch Floyd Mayweather Snaps - Goes Bonkers on 50 Cent Amir Khan: I Respect Pacquiao - But I Know I Can Beat Him! Nathan Gorman: I'm The One To Beat Daniel Dubois! Boxing is Still in Doubt For 2020 Olympic Games Jaime Munguia Drops, Punishes Liam Smith For Decision Win Jaime Munguia vs. Liam Smith - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Alberto Machado Drops, Decisions Mensah To Retain Title Gassiev Has No Excuses, Gives Full Praise To Usyk Machado vs. Mensah - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Munguia: High Possibility Smith Fight Ends in a Knockout Usyk vs. Gassiev - CompuBox Punch Stats Jaime Munguia vs. Liam Smith - LIVE Results From Las Vegas Usyk: If Bellew Won't Come Down - I'll Face Him at Heavyweight Usyk Dominates Gassiev To Unify WBC, WBA, WBO, IBF Titles Usyk vs. Gassiev - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Video: Freddie Roach on Pacquiao-Loma, Canelo-GGG, More Video: Liam Smith Talks Pacquiao-Khan, Canelo, Khan-Brook

Latest Active Forum Threads