Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Chavez-Vera Rematch - Examining The Scorecards

by David P. Greisman

Unlike the first fight between Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. and Bryan Vera, the rematch produced a clear victor, not just in the judges’ decision, but also in the eyes of the observers.

Let’s talk about the scorecards.

Two of the judges had Chavez winning widely. Ruben Carrion scored the bout 117-110 for Chavez, only giving Vera rounds 1, 2 and 12. Max DeLuca scored the bout the same way, 117-110, only giving Vera rounds 2, 9 and 12.

David Sutherland had it much closer, at 114-113 for Chavez, giving each man six rounds apiece. Vera had a point taken from him in the eighth round, which is why Sutherland’s card also had Chavez winning. He gave Vera rounds 2, 3, 5, 9, 11 and 12.

We’ll come back to Sutherland in a second. If we take him away, Carrion and DeLuca largely saw the fight the same way, agreeing on the winner of 10 of the 12 rounds, only differing on Round 1 (which Carrion saw for Vera while DeLuca saw it for Chavez) and Round 9 (which Carrion saw for Chavez while DeLuca saw it for Vera).

Let’s bring Sutherland back into the picture again. Carrion was the only one of the three judges to see Round 1 for Vera, and the only one of the three judges to see Round 9 for Chavez. Deluca was in the “majority,” agreeing with at least one of the other judges, for every single one of the 12 rounds.

Sutherland was in the “majority” for nine rounds, agreeing with at least one of the other judges in rounds 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 12. He was in the minority in rounds 3, 5 and 11 — all rounds he gave Vera, which is how his card ended up at 114-111.

Halfway through the fight, Carrion had Chavez ahead 4 rounds to 2, DeLuca had Chavez ahead 5 rounds to 1, and Sutherland had it a draw at three rounds apiece. Carrion would only find one more round for Vera, DeLuca would find two more, and Sutherland awarded three more to him.

There were only two rounds in which all three judges agreed that Vera won: 2, 12.  One judge gave him Round 1. One judge gave him Round 3. One judge gave him Round 5. Two judges gave him Round 9. And one judge gave him Round 11.

That means that Vera got the edge on at least one judge’s scorecard in seven of the 12 rounds. Then again, Chavez got an edge on at least one judge’s scorecard in 10 of the 12 rounds. There were five rounds in which all three judges agreed that Chavez won: 4, 6, 7, 8 and 10.

If we were to take a score from “majority rules” — in which a fighter gets the edge from at least 2 of the 3 judges for that round — then Chavez would’ve won nine rounds and Vera would’ve won three rounds, and the final card would’ve been the 117-110 card that both Carrion and DeLuca turned in.

Pick up a copy of David’s new book, “Fighting Words: The Heart and Heartbreak of Boxing,” at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsamazon or internationally at http://bit.ly/fightingwordsworldwide. Send questions/comments via email at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by nycsmooth on 03-02-2014

Sutherland, from OK, is a poor, inconsistent judge, that would fit well in Vegas w/all the butt he kisses there...

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (1)
Top Headlines Nacho: Pacquiao Should Think Twice Before Crawford, Loma Peter Quillin: I Want To Make it a Dog Fight With J'Leon Love Golden Boy Prez Reacts To Arum: Canelo Will Beat GGG Easier Photos: Lamont Roach, Deivis Julio Bassa Ready For ESPN Battle Photos: Michael Dutchover is Ready For Battle With Ramirez Ryan Garcia vs. Mercito Gesta Showdown in The Works Photos: Alberto Machado, Rafael Mensah - Go Face To Face Photos: Jaime Munguia, Liam Smith - Go Face To Face in Vegas Photos: Jaron Ennis vs. Armando Alvarez - ShoBox Triple Weights Photos: Robert Easter is Grinding Hard For Mikey Garcia Fight Mikey Garcia: I May Go To 147 By Year's End, I Want Spence! Danny Roman Deal With Hearn is Five Fight Co-Promotion Sanchez: Gassiev Can’t Afford to Give Away Rounds Against Usyk Joshua: It's My Career, It's Not Determined By What People Want Hearn: If Deontay Wilder is Man of His Word - He'll Sign Contract! UK News: Hughes, Turner, Donnelly, McFadden, McComb Photos: Usyk, Gassiev - Go Face To Face at Final Press Conference Jaime Munguia: I Want To Unify - I Prefer Jarrett Hurd! Sam Eggington Replaces Kell Brook, Will Face Brandon Cook Arum: Canelo Will Pay Price For Being Off Juice, Triple-G KOs Him Promoter: If Joshua Had Choice, He Wouldn't Fight Povetkin Trainer: Pacquiao is Unbeatable When He Trains Like That! Hearn: 12 More Fighters To Sign, They Won't Be Able To Stop Us Frank Warren Warns That Liam Smith is Live Dog With Munguia Research Suggests Non-Contact Boxing Can Combat Parkinson's Joshua: Dillian Whyte Will Beat Joseph Parker - By Knockout Wilder: Eddie Hearn is Not a Guy That You Can Trust Liam Williams: Jaime Munguia vs. Liam Smith is Difficult To Call Abel Sanchez: If Usyk Fights Like Before, He's On His Back in 9! Dec Spelman Makes a Successful Ring Return, Back on 9/7 The WBSS at Cruiserweight Worked (and That’s No Small Feat) Hearn: No One Knows Who Wilder is - 50-50 Will Never Happen! Povetkin: I've Always Been Clean, Failed Tests Were Suspicious Christian "Macho Time" Camacho on Boxeo Telemuno Card Crawford Tops Lomachenko, Wins ESPY For 'Fighter of the Year' Teofimo Lopez To Undergo Surgery on Right Hand on Friday Rey Vargas Already Back To Work, Hopes For Quick Return Photos: Jean Pascal, Steve Bosse - Face To Face at Final Presser Anthony Joshua: I'd Rather Lose Than Use PEDs To Win Toka Kahn Clary vs. Kid Galahad - IBF Eliminator Ordered
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement