Bute Wins, Kirkland Overshadows: Review, Ratings News

by Cliff Rold

It’s enough to feel a little sorry for Lucian Bute.  The long reigning IBF titlist at 168 lbs. got the marquee name his record lacked, turned in the dominant performance he needed, and by Sunday morning almost no one outside Canada cared.

Such is the way of great fights and their ability to make everything else forgettable. 

James Kirkland-Alfredo Angulo was a great fight. 

There will be snide, cynical types who point out the fight was really only ‘great’ for three minutes; who will point out Kirkland ran roughshod over Angulo after getting off the floor and almost stopping Angulo in the very first, wild round.

Even if it’s true, if it’s fair to say rounds 2-6 were a sustained violent epilogue of round one, it is also still fair to say a great fight took place.  Both men gave everything they had, left it in the ring, and the fans were the better for it.

Bute, in the ring, is superior in a technical sense to both Kirkland and Angulo.  He is immensely popular up north and a credit to the game as a sportsman.  What he does not have, yet, is the sort of time capsule moment Kirkland and Angulo participated in last weekend.

Bute will have more chances. 

Let’s got to the report cards.

Pre-Fight: Speed – Bute B+; Johnson B/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Power – Bute A; Johnson B+/Post: A; B
Pre-Fight: Defense – Bute B+; Johnson B+/Post: Bute B+; Johnson B-
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Bute B+; Johnson A/Post: A; B

His relatively easy decision over Glen Johnson is going to be open to critique.  Johnson is 42 and did not put on the sort of relentless, subtle pressure clinic he’s known for.  Was he showing his age?


Bute had a lot to do with it.  The Romanian born titlist showed off a ton of upper body movement, intelligent and varied punch selection, and never had his feet out of place, all while keeping Johnson largely on the outside.  To Bute’s credit, he also showed some beard.  It’s not like Johnson never landed.  His right found a home on Bute’s face and his left jab was effective all night. Late, there were left hooks.

Bute took it and dished better.  Missing for too much of the night was Bute’s excellent uppercut but, given the zone the titlist was otherwise in, it was of little matter.

Johnson, who has been robbed more than once, understandably might not be able to accept defeat on the road anymore.  However, Saturday he simply didn’t do enough to win and never seemed to notice how far behind he was.  There was never the sort of late push he made last year against Tavoris Cloud in another losing effort.

It’s fair to ask if Johnson has run out of wars but, for now, it is more fair to ask how much better Bute might be before he’s done.  Sometime next year, the Super Middleweight division will be abuzz about Bute versus the Super Six winner.  Whether it happens or not, it will be the fight everyone wants to see.

Bute will have his chance to cast his own shadow then.          

Report Card Picks 2011: 38-14

Ratings Update

Super Middleweight: Clearly now competing at Middleweight, Peter Quillin exits the top ten.  He is not yet rated at Middleweight as there simply is not room for him there yet.  Johnson does not slip at 168 and shows off how top heavy the field is.

Jr. Middleweight: Huge shakeup with the Kirkland win.  There’s no way to let Kirkland back in the top ten without also factoring in a first round loss to Nobuhiro Ishida earlier this year.  So...they are both in.  Angulo exits the top ten as does undefeated Vanes Martirosyan.  The latter did nothing wrong but the field is crowded in the bottom few slots and, upon deeper consideration, Martirosyan is the odd man out.  Fighting some more intriguing competition will help to bring him back. 

Lightweight: Ricky Burns crashes the top ten with his compelling win over veteran banger Michael Katsidis.

The weekend results and more are reflected a page away.

>>>>>>Click Here To View BoxingScene's Full Divisional Ratings<<<<<<

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by crold1 on 11-08-2011

[QUOTE=Lorily;11388735]Yeah, but Ishida over Vanes based on what many perceived as a "fluke" win over Kirkland?? Really, what else has Ishida done? Not trying to be critical but I don't understand the reasoning of Ishida over Martrosiyan (sp?) based on…

Comment by Lorily on 11-08-2011

Yeah, but Ishida over Vanes based on what many perceived as a "fluke" win over Kirkland?? Really, what else has Ishida done? Not trying to be critical but I don't understand the reasoning of Ishida over Martrosiyan (sp?) based on…

Comment by ShoulderRoll on 11-08-2011

Vanes could have been fighting Angulo last Saturday but found every excuse not to. His demotion in the ratings is deserved despite the undefeated record.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (3)
Top Headlines News: Payano vs. Plania, Braulio Rodriguez, Vicente Eyes Dogboe Photos: Dillian Whyte, Lucas Browne, Frank Buglioni - Workouts Ramirez-Imam Tripleheader Averaged Only 488K Viewers for ESPN Anthony Joshua Won’t Discuss What He'll Weigh for Parker Fight News: Klara Svennson Update, Rocco Wadell Back on April 21 Billy Joe Saunders vs. Martin Murray Moves To June 23rd Parker on Joshua: Somebody is Getting KO'd - It Won't Be Me! Prograis Sees 'Lots of Holes' in Jose Ramirez, Respects His Chin Mikey Garcia Explains Why He'd Want Spence Bout Over Crawford Jose Ramirez vs. Amir Imam: Afterthoughts Liam Smith: I Think Ali Might Be Tougher Fight Than Miguel Cotto Hughie Fury: I'll Be World Champion, I'm a World Level Fighter! Kudratillo Abdukakhorov Rising in Ranks After Malaysia Win Whyte Shakes Head: Joshua is Not Going To Fight Wilder Next Sanchez: If Canelo Dominates Golovkin, I'll Admit GGG Got Old Ismael Salas Denies Rumors of Split With Jorge Linares March Madness shocker yields memories of giant ring surprises Ellerbe Concerned, Would Advise Mayweather To Avoid MMA McGregor Opens as 10-1 Favorite in Mayweather MMA Fight Wilder: I'm Convinced Joshua, Hearn Are Definitely Scared of Me! Buitrago Pulled From Hard Rock Card Over Murder For Hire Beef Frampton Slams Quigg, Not Buying His Excuse For Missing Weight Golden Boy Matchmaker Reacts to 'Neno' Calling Out Ryan Garcia Kautondokwa is Ready For War on Namibian Independence Card Roach Impressed With Jose Ramirez, Wants to Improve Defense Lolenga Mock, Mogens Palle Part Ways Over Money Isaac Ekpo, Rafael Mensah Train With McKinley, Praise Don King Povetkin's Manager: Drug Tests in Order, No Worries For Price Alberto Melian Drills Countryman Julian Aristule in Two Rounds Felix Verdejo's Trainer Expects His Fighter To Return Stronger Michael Dutchover Continues Winning Run at Doubletree Joshua vs. Parker - Giuseppe Quartarone Confirmed as Referee Sadam Ali vs. Liam Smith Finalized For May 12, Turning Stone Anthony Crolla vs. Edson Ramirez Set For Joshua-Parker Card Photos: Whyte, Browne - Get Very Heated on 'Gloves Are Off' News: Sven Fornling, Brian Ceballo, Nikolai Potapov, More Daniel Jacobs vs. Maciej Sulecki - Undercard Information Arthur Abraham: I'm Not Ready To Retire, I Want World Title Again Joseph Parker: I'm Going To Come in Light and Fast vs. Joshua Gvozdyk: Stevenson is 40 & Inactive; Not Sure He'll Beat Jack

Latest Active Forum Threads