Broner-Taylor: BoxingScene Staff Predictions

By Jake Donovan

All week long, Adrien Broner and Emmanuel Taylor have threatened to inflict massive amounts of harm upon each other. They finally get to let their fists do the talking when they meet Saturday evening at the U.S. Bank Arena in Broner's hometown of Cincinnati, Ohio.

The bout airs live on Showtime, topping a televised tripleheader (9:30PM ET).

Broner (28-1, 22KOs) won his first major title at home, stopping Vicente Rodriguez in three rounds to claim a super featherweight belt in Nov. '11. The title reign also ended at home, as Broner was stripped of the belt at the scales after failing to make weight prior to his July '12 bout with Vicente Escobedo.

The fight was nearly canceled before Escobedo agreed to move forward - following a considerable increase in pay - hours before the event. Broner went on to win by 5th round knockout, but his lack of professionalism rubbed many the wrong way.

So went his last home trip. He's since added title wins at 135 and 147, racking up title fight wins over Antonio DeMarco, Gavin Rees and Paul Malignaggi while developing into one of the sport's best TV draws. His unbeaten run came to a crashing halt last December, as he was battered over 12 rounds by Marcos Maidana in San Antonio.

A comeback win over Carlos Molina this past May saw Broner drop down to 140 lb., a division he skipped over in pursuit of welterweight glory. It's a division in which he has now planted the proverbial flag, pining for a showdown with Lucas Matthysse, who faces Roberto Ortiz in the evening's co-feature.

Taylor (18-2, 12KOs) was all too willing to accept assignment to face Broner in his hometown. In fact, the Maryland-based super lightweight was waiting on his higher-profile opponent to finally sign the contracts before making the bout official.

The fight marks the third time this year that Taylor performs in front of the television cameras. A win over Chris Algieri would have put him in line for a shot at Ruslan Provodnikov. Instead, it was Algieri who prevailed in their Valentine's Day (night) bout on ESPN2, moving on to face and beat Provodnikov in June and now having landed a coveted welterweight title fight versus Manny Pacquiao later this year.

Meanwhile, Taylor punched his way back into relevance with a decision win over Karim Mayfield. Taylor overcame a knockdown to take a convincing points win in their ESPN2-televised headliner in July.

Can Taylor once again upset the odds, this time overcoming a partisan crowd against one of the sport's most notable stars? Will Broner continue strong on the comeback trail, turning away his visiting challenger while remaining in pursuit of a title in a fourth weight class?

Read on to see how the staff at believes tonight's action goes down.


Ryan Burton (Broner MD): “Broner forced to sweat out decision at home."

Jake Donovan (Broner UD): “"Extending the house fighter the full 12 rounds can be considered a moral victory for Taylor, who - while solid - appears to be overmatched in every other category. Still unsure of Broner's power above 135, but - when (if?) disciplined - still boasts the skills to run with the best. Taylor figures out a way to hear the final bell, but dropping a wide decision in the process as Broner gives a statement performance while awaiting Matthysse (should he beat Ortiz).""

Ernest Gabion (Broner UD): “Taylor hears the final bell, but Broner prevails.”

Ryan Maquiñana (Broner TKO5): "I think Adrien Broner bounces back from his previous subpar outings in an impactful manner. Emmanuel Taylor is coming off a close win over Karim Mayfield, but I think this time, "The Problem" will put his speed advantage on display en route to a stoppage win."

Cliff Rold (Broner Dec.): "This is no Danny Garcia-Rod Salka but it's not - on paper - a particularly worthy Showtime main event, either. If Taylor had a notable punch, his chances would be better. He is live in this fight anyways but the harder hitting, more dynamic Broner should have enough to earn the decision."

Reynaldo Sanchez (Broner TKO in 10 or less): “Broner chose a dangerous fighter like Taylor.. But I think Broner won this fight, Broner has more experience, better opponents and perhaps more power in both hands."

Alexey Sukachev (Broner TKO8): “I'm still far from thinking Broner is finished. This fight is a great chance to prove his assets against durable but otherwise limited fighter. He will not blow it.”

Anson Wainwright (Broner TKO8): “It will be interesting to see how Broner looks against a solid guy. Taylor comes in on the back of a nice win over Karim Mayfield and is looking to parlay that into something even bigger. Broner struggled and was poor last time out. I expect him to deliver an impressive performance this time. I see Broner starting well having the better of things and slowly but surely pushing Taylor back hurting him around eight and stopping Taylor on his feet.”

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Scott9945 on 09-07-2014

[QUOTE=Scott9945;14919233]I think Broner will have to work hard and go the distance in this fight.[/QUOTE] [I][B][FONT=Arial]Told ya so...:D[/FONT][/B][/I]

Comment by Hougigo on 09-07-2014

[QUOTE=_Gatti_;14919254]Broner is gonna starch this guy out. He got beat by Algieri.[/QUOTE] Startched pretty bad

Comment by _Gatti_ on 09-06-2014

Broner is gonna starch this guy out. He got beat by Algieri.

Comment by Scott9945 on 09-06-2014

I think Broner will have to work hard and go the distance in this fight.

Comment by Nomadic on 09-06-2014

Broner better shine on this fight, he needs it.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (5)
Top Headlines Carlos Takam Feels Time is Right For Dereck Chisora Rematch Roach: Pacquiao, With Two Hands, Does Much Better With Floyd Reymart Gaballo, Romero Duno Get Opponents For February 9 Canelo: Beating Jacobs I'll Be One Step Away From Undisputed Brian Ceballo Staying Level-Headed, Taking Things Step By Step Ellerbe: Pacquiao Has Many Options at 147 - But Not Mayweather David Lemieux vs. John Ryder Possible For Canelo-Jacobs Card Crawford-Khan: Madison Square Garden Chosen as Site Francisco Vargas Vows Revenge: I'm Not Impressed By Berchelt Josesito Lopez Values Improvements To His Game Under Garcia Arum: Joshua Damaged His Credibility, Fury Viewed as #1 in U.S. Keith Thurman vs. Josesito Lopez - Added Undercard Fights Badou Jack: I'm a Fighter, So I Ain't Gonna Quit Pacquiao vs. Broner Replay: January 26th on Showtime Harrison-Charlo Rematch Ordered, New Final Eliminator Too Demetrius Andrade vs. Billy Joe Saunders Ordered By WBO Pacquiao: If Mayweather Can't Fight at My Level - Stay Retired News: Luis Lebron, Benson, Hamza, O'Donnell, Srour, Barlow Hearn Cautions 'Now or Never' For Whyte To Accept Joshua Offer Scardina-Kekalainen Tops Matchroom Italy Card on March 8 DiBella: After Commey Beats Chaniev, We Want Lomachenko Fury: Wilder's The One Who Has To Redeem Himself, Not Me! Khan: The Offers for Crawford and Brook Were Literally The Same Frank Warren To Wait Out Warrington vs. Galahad Purse Bid Charr Wins Appeal, Reinstated As WBA Titlist; Box-Off To Follow Miles Shinkwin Back In March, Defends English Title Frank Warren: Joshua Made Massive Mistake in Snubbing Wilder Canelo-Jacobs: NSAC To Review Venue Request at 1/29 Hearing Eubank Jr. Very Pleased With Camp Ahead of Degale Clash Caleb Plant: I'm The Big Dog at 168, They've Got To Come See Me Hearn: Wilder, His Handlers Don't Have Decency To Answer Back Chris Algieri Confident He Can Raise His Level Against Hooker Kovalev Asks Fans 'Not To Make Hasty Conclusions On Situation' Cano in Line For a Big Fight, Linares Heading Back To 135 Curtis Stevens Heading To 154: Eyes Hurd, Lara, Harrison, Munguia Pulev vs. Helenius Clash Still Be Worked Out For Crawford-Khan Broner: I'll Be Back; All You Motherf***ers Will Still Tune In! Manny Pacquiao vs. Adrien Broner: CompuBox By The Numbers Gvozdyk To Take Voluntary Before Mandatory Versus Browne Pacquiao To Have Scratched Cornea Re-Examined Monday In L.A.

Latest Active Forum Threads