Broner-Maidana -'s Staff Predictions

By Jake Donovan

From Mr. HBO to Mr. Showtime, it’s been a wild and crazy year for unbeaten rising star Adrien Broner.

The former lightweight titlist moved up in weight, capturing a welterweight belt with a strangely scored split decision win over Paul Malignaggi in June. The bout took trash talking to new heights, but also solidified Broner’s status as a ratings magnet, the only fighter in 2013 to score Top 10 TV-rated bouts on both HBO and Showtime.

The road to superstardom isn’t free and clear, however. Standing in his way is bubble contender Marcos Maidana, whom he faces on a loaded card at the Alamodome in San Antonio.

The power punching Argentine resurfaced on the contender stage with knockout wins over Jesus Soto Karass last September and Josesito Lopez this past June.

Social media taunts served as the primer for this matchup being made, though aggressively pursued and finalized after their ringside altercation in September during Fight Week for Floyd Mayweather’s lucrative points win over Saul ‘Canelo’ Alvarez.

With all of the nonsense now in the rearview mirror, all that’s left to do is fight.

Who will let their fists talk the loudest once the opening bell rings? Read on to see how the staff at believes tonight’s Showtime-televised main event plays out.


“Broner will dominate from the opening bell, but Maidana will hear the final bell.”

- Ryan Burton (Broner UD)

“I thought he looked good-not-great against Paulie Malignaggi in his welterweight debut. I expect him to deliver a showcase performance versus Marcos Maidana, but also reminded of the power difference between the two. Maidana's toughness is overstated, but his punching power is for real. Broner will get tagged enough to know not to get too careless, but at the same time "get down" enough to keep the crowd entertained and a steady lead on the scorecards throughout.”

 - Jake Donovan (Broner UD)

“Broner... all day long.  The same thing that typically happens when a good tough guy meets a high-end skills guy will happen here.  The skills guy will win and look good doing it.”

- Lyle Fitzsimmons (Broner TKO10)

“While a gifted offensive fighter, Adrien Broner is flawed enough defensively to consider the heavy-handed Marcos Maidana a live underdog. We'll learn how complete of a welterweight Broner is in this fight because Maidana will test his chin, something Broner didn't need to worry about when he fought Paulie Malignaggi in his welterweight debut. If he takes Maidana's power well, Broner's boxing ability.”

- Keith Idec (Broner UD)

“Adrien Broner still has yet to prove his power has carried over from the lightweight division, and he certainly has his work cut for him with a brick wall like Marcos Maidana. However, Maidana struggles with swift guys who can box, and I see Broner flustering him with his hand speed and movement the same way Devon Alexander did last year.”

- Ryan Maquinana (Broner by decision)

“Maidana will have his moments.  Specifically, about 3 moments.  Outside of that, it will be a Broner display of speed, power he's building into at 147, and plenty of flash.”

- Richard Najdowski (Broner UD)

“I expect Marcos Maidana to give a spirited effort and really test Adrien Broner on Saturday night. Maidana's sheer will and power make him dangerous, yet I see Broner being a little more talented and have a feeling he will be on his game. I also think Broner will have filled out a little better at 147 pounds compared to his welterweight debut against Paulie Malignaggi. I would have to pick Broner to win an entertaining decision in this one. ”

- Chris Robinson (Broner UD)

“Adrien Broner, betraying the hype, isn't the defensive wizard some think he is. He gets hit in most fights, and Marcos Maidana can hit with the best of them. Unfortunately, he still gets hit much more than Broner, and the fledgling porn star knows how to use his feet for space. Devon Alexander multiplied the offense on Maidana and had him looking weary. Broner has more firepower than Devon and, while Maidana may have some fun moments, Broner breaks him down before it’s over.”

- Cliff Rold (Broner by KO)

“Broner hasn’t proven to be a strong welterweight. Maliggnaggi showed that Broner lacks the power to settle at 147 pounds. If Maidana can break his defense, he can give us a big surprise this Saturday. Despite this, I thin Broner edges him.”

- Reynaldo Sanchez (Broner SD)

“This could be a tremendous bout between two of the best welterweights in boxing on paper. Could Broner be able to box his way to win or will he go for the KO? If he does the latter, that could play into Maidana's hands. Broner has been susceptible to getting hit in his last two fights. Maidana has gotten better at timing his opponents and cutting off the ring. I like Maidana to pull off the upset.”

- Francisco Salazar (Maidana by TKO or late stoppage)

This a true test for Broner who’s been touted as the next best thing and now it’s time to prove it. Maidana’s hard punching and resiliency will pose real threats to him but I see Broner winning on points over 12 rounds. He won’t walk away from this unscathed and will taste Maidana’s power but he’ll overcome it and register the first successful defense of his title.”

- Luis Sandoval (Broner UD)

“Maidana is too tough to be stopped, and Broner isn't a puncher any more at welterweight. Yet, his sturdy chin and skills set will prove too much for the dangerous but limited Argentinean.”

- Alexey Sukachev (Broner UD)


Adrien Broner 11

Marcos Maidana 1

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of the Transnational Boxing Ratings Board, Yahoo Boxing Ratings Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by budfr on 12-16-2013

The staff just wanted a US citizen to win. Envy of Latinos.

Comment by nacho daddy on 12-15-2013

looks like the "experts" aint that good and fell for the ghetto con job. the media just loves lowlife hood gangstas and really don't like the Klitshkos being they are white and long for the days of the rapist cannibal…

Comment by BuckToothed on 12-15-2013

Broner was the favorite for a reason, but still rooted for Maidana regardless which makes the win/beating even more satisfying.

Comment by SouthPawHitman on 12-15-2013

Good God...I saw Maidana winning from a mile away. Easy,easy fight to call.

Comment by Bushidō on 12-15-2013

[QUOTE=ARREZOLA;14031650]I dont understand how staff would pick overwhelmingly Broner over Maidana and how showtime had it close in the scorecards. I think the judges got it right this time (for once). Broner really thought he was the next Mayweather. He…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (13)
Top Headlines CompuBox: Jose Ramirez's Pressure, Power Shots Was Difference Robert Helenius Wins Split Decision Over Yury Bykhautsou Gvozdyk: I Want The Stevenson vs. Jack Winner in My Next Fight! Giovanni Cabrera Mioletti Shocks Ray Lampkin With KO in Two Lozada: I Knew I Would KO Felix Verdejo, I Went For it in Tenth Cristian Mijares Gets Stoppage Win Over Fernando Saucedo Jaime Munguia Knocks Out Johnny Navarrete in The Third Roach: Ramirez Won Every Round, 2 Judges Should Be Investigated! Don King: Imam Didn't Throw Enough, Ramirez Was Relentless Michael Conlan Demolishes David Berna in Two Rounds Jose Ramirez Lands Gold, Decisions Amir Imam For WBC Title Jose Ramirez vs. Amir Imam - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Gvozdyk Wins Tough Decision Over Amar, in Line For WBC Shot Ramirez: I'm Ready To Fight Best, No Matter What Critics Think Yeison Cohen Passes Away After KO Loss Earlier This Month Antonio Lozada Drops, Stops Felix Verdejo in Tenth Round Joe Joyce Destroys Donnie Palmer With Big Knockout in One Christopher Diaz Wins by TKO, Rodriguez Suffers Hand Injury Jose Pedraza Sheds Rust, Pounds Out Decision Over Rodriguez Whittom Dies After Being in 10 Month Coma Following KO Loss McKinley: Ramirez Doesn't Have Power, Imam By Far Best Opponent Danny O'Connor, Steve Claggett To Collide at House of Blues Roach: Imam Isn't Anything Special; Ramirez Should Stop Him Virgil Hunter Hospitalized Due To Health Scare, Recovering Jose Ramirez: I Learned So Much Working With Pacquiao, Cotto Sam Maxwell Moves To 6-0, Returns In Belfast Next Month Jose Ramirez vs. Amir Imam: Stats & Stakes Prograis Leaning Toward Ramirez Over Imam in '50-50 Fight' Don King: Imam Will Knock Out Ramirez; Give Us Pacquiao Next Luis Ortiz Coach Talks Loss, Confident Wilder is KO'd in Rematch Daily Bread Mailbag: Canelo, Mikey Garcia, PEDs in Boxing, More Frank Warren Talks Sadam Ali vs. Liam Smith Showdown Kal Yafai Wants The Chocolatito Showodwn, Then Sor Rungvisai Linares: Lomachenko is Fast - But He Does Not Have My Punch! Jeff Horn Warns Crawford: I'll Expose That Lack of Toughness! Roberto Arriaza Crushes Sammy Valentin With Knockout in One Kemahl Russell Drills Michi Munoz in The Second Round The Real Reason Why Floyd Mayweather Is Training MMA Antonio Orozco Wins Return, Estrada and Durate Shine in LA Chavez Sr. Gives Canelo The Edge, Picks Him To Beat Golovkin

Latest Active Forum Threads