BoxingScene's Year End Awards: Comeback of the Year

By Cliff Rold

It can be one of the sport’s hardest terms to define: the comeback.

A fighter away from the game for years who returns at high form can be said to have made a comeback.  Eder Jofre, Sugar Ray Leonard, and Vitali Klitschko all came out of lengthy time out of the ring to post big wins and pick up extra titles.

A fighter picking himself off the floor, dusting himself off, and coming back like nothing happened can also be celebrated.  Joe Louis did it and wouldn’t lose again for over a decade.  Terry Norris made a habit of it.  Today, Amir Khan is already beyond his first round of comebacks.

Then there are the veterans who regroup, who slip out of what appears to be the tightening grip of Father Time to re-assert themselves on the elite of the game.  It is from this pool of the comeback warrior that BoxingScene’s staff voting draws upon.

Let’s make that “Road Warrior.” 

Comeback of the Year: Glen Johnson

As 2009 came to a close, it appeared one of the feel-good stories of the decade would be closing with it.  Glen Johnson had bounced back from some bad losses, and some bad decisions, to win the Light Heavyweight title and post wins over Roy Jones, Antonio Tarver and Clinton Woods through the years.  In 2008, many felt he’d done enough to erase the “0” on the record of Chad Dawson but their 2009 rematch was so one-sided as to suggest that 40 years of age would be a bridge too far.

2010 dispelled that notion. As staff writer Ryan Songalia put it in casting his vote, “I think you have to give it to Glen Johnson - twice. After the one-sided loss to Chad Dawson last year, he comes back and destroys a decent contender Yusaf Mack; then he loses a close decision to (undefeated IBF Light Heavyweight titlist Tavoris) Cloud in a fight some saw for (Johnson).  He follows that up by reinventing himself as a super middleweight and knocking out Allen Green. Oh yeah, and he did this at 41.” 

The where of the Green fight matters greatly.  As contributor Luis Sandoval noted in his voting, “Just when you think the Road Warrior may have got too old he proves his still the same Glen and is right in the mix in the Super Six.”  A late replacement to the tournament field, Johnson will ride the win into a semi-final clash with once-beaten WBC titlist Carl Froch in an early candidate for 2011 Fight of the Year.

Yes, Glen Johnson is still that good and plenty good enough to merit recognition for the finest comeback of 2010.

Runner-Up: Pongsaklek Wonjongkam

Not too far behind Johnson, Thailand’s Pongsaklek Wonjongkam picked up a win that, some day, could be the difference in entry into the hallowed halls at Canastota.  Despite a WBC and lineal Flyweight title reign from 2001-07 that saw Wonjongkam surpass the consecutive title defense record at Flyweight once held by the great Miguel Canto, too many fights against woeful challengers left some wondering if Wonjongkam was as good as his numbers.  A shocking title loss to a Daisuke Naito he’d beaten twice before, followed by a 2008 draw in their fourth fight, left the questions in the air.  A 2009 win over the tough Julio Cesar Miranda earned him another title shot and Wonjongkam delivered a master class with the opportunity.  In March of this year, Wonjongkam dethroned Naito’s conqueror and Japan’s biggest draw, Koki Kameda, on a majority decision nowhere near as close as the cards had it and showed, at 32, he remained one of the best in the world and still the leader at 112 lbs.    

Honorable Mention: Cristian Mijares, a pair of 115 lb. belts in tow, looked like a rising pound-for-pound titan is some corners until a 2008 blitzing at the hands of Vic Darchinyan left him in need of regrouping.  Two more losses in a row, decisions against Nehomar Cermeno at Bantamweight (the first controversial, the second not so much) and Mijares looked ready for the scrap heap.  A 3-0 2010 was capped by a title belt win back at 115 in December…Knockout losses in 2006 and 2008 suggested Jr. Lightweight Jason Litzau might peak out as an entertaining T.V. fighter just outside the scope of serious contention.  2010 upset wins over former title challenger Rocky Juarez and, more impressively, former unified Jr. Featherweight champ Celestino Caballero made Litzau a prime candidate for title opportunity at 130 lbs. in 2011…A 2009 stoppage loss to Vic Darchinyan didn’t knock Mexican favorite Jorge Arce off track, the little battler going 4-0-1 in 2010 with a first round stop of former titlist Martin Castillo and a draw versus former titlist Lorenzo Parra...An even bigger Mexican icon, Erik Morales, bounced back from almost three years out of the ring to go 3-0 in 2010.  If a showdown with Juan Manuel Marquez comes off in 2011, Morales could have a chance to seize this category next year… Kassim Ouma might have gone 1-1 in 2010 on paper but he was the victim of a highly questionable decision versus undefeated Vanes Martirosyan and came off the floor to stop Joey Gilbert later in the year.  There is still life in the 32-year old former Jr. Middleweight champ.

For more Year End Awards 2010:

Round, Robbery, & Event

Prospect: TBA
Knockout: TBA
Fighter: TBA
Fight: TBA

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Post a Comment - View More User Comments (0)
Top Headlines Byfield Confident of Stopping Cheeseman in One-Sided Fight Canelo: Fielding Will Be Bigger, Stronger Than Me - This is a Risk Pacquiao Says Broner Fight is "90%" Likely To Push Through Canelo: If the People Want Third Golovkin Fight, We'll Make It Photos: Scott Quigg, Kid Galahad, Daniyar Yeleussinov - Workouts Photos: Katie Taylor Putting in Work For Serrano Defense Canelo To Mayweather: Stop Hurting Boxing - Fight Me! Photos: Tevin Farmer, James Tennyson - Putting in Work Photos: Demetrius Andrade Grinds For Kautondokwa Clash Photos: Jason Quigley, Freddy Hernandez - Ready For Battle Chocolatito, Cecilia Braekhus To Return on HBO, December 8 Photos: Rob Brant Showing Off His Moves at Top Rank Gym Photos: Ryota Murata Putting in Work For Rob Brant Video: Bob Arum Reacts To Canelo's Deal With DAZN Golovkin Promoter Will Be Ringside For Murata vs. Brant Clash Hearn on Canelo-DAZN: The Whole Game is About To Change Canelo-Fielding Contracts: Rehydration Clause, 2nd-Day Weigh-In Video: Rocky Fielding Discusses Showdown With Canelo Video: Canelo Talks Fielding Fight at 168, MSG, DAZN, More Video: Eddie Hearn Talks Canelo/DAZN, Joshua, DAZN Future DAZN Exec: De La Hoya The Most Important Figure in PPV History Badou Jack's Ripper Nutrition is Expanding Out To Asian Market Photos: Canelo, Golden Boy Announce Major Deal With DAZN Photos: Canelo, Rocky Fielding - Go Face To Face in NYC Andrey Fedosov Now Looking For Much Bigger Fights Golden Boy Prez: We Signed With The Leader of Sports Streaming! Josh Taylor: There is No Way That Anyone Beats Me at The Hydro Hearn: Canelo/DAZN Deal Will End PPV Boxing In the United States Dorticos on Masternak: I See a Man With KO Written on His Face Dogboe vs. Navarrete Set Down For Lomachenko-Pedraza Manny Pacquiao: Adrien Broner Fight is Next, January 12 or 19 Mayweather Believes He Can Get $200M Guarantee For Khabib Scott Harrison Begins His Comeback on December 8 Canelo, Oscar De La Hoya, DAZN Discuss New Mega-Deal Jessie Vargas Hopes To Return To The Ring By March Tevin Farmer: The Gervonta Davis Fight Won't Make Or Break Me Luis Ortiz Manager on Possible Hearn Deal, Status of Return Kautondokwa Warns: Andrade is Facing a Real Executioner! Sugar Ray Leonard: Joshua-Wilder is a Fight Made in Heaven Bradley Skeete Reacts To Talk of Gary Corcoran Clash

Latest Active Forum Threads