Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

BoxingScene.com's Pound For Pound Update - October 1

By Cliff Rold

While there hasn’t been any movement in the top three spots, there has been plenty below them.

Saul Alvarez and Oleksandr Usyk picked up career best victories since the last update and move up accordingly. Which one should be higher?

The cruiserweight champion Usyk completed a full unification of one of boxing’s most competitive weight classes on the way to winning the World Boxing Super Series tournament. He did it the hardest way possible, going on the road in all three of his fights and saving his best for last with a dominant victory over Murat Gassiev.

terence-crawford (2)_14

Alvarez defended the lineal middleweight crown and picked up the biggest win of his career in becoming the first man to defeat Gennady Golovkin after a controversial draw in their first fight. This time around, the outcome didn’t earn the ‘controversy’ label but it’s damn sure still being debated. Debates after Alvarez fights are nothing new. There are still those who thought he was a little lucky against Austin Trout and Erislandy Lara even before the first Golovkin fight.

To his credit, none of those were easy outs and boxing’s biggest active star, like his promoter Oscar De La Hoya before him, is making the fights he should (if sometimes at the moment that is best for him).

So what gets the edge? Decisive form or the larger body of work?   

The full update is a click away: https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound
 
Last Update: June 3, 2018

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

Tags: boxing image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Sledgeweather17 on 10-03-2018

[QUOTE=The Big Dunn;19158757]Homie you already know the answer is no for me. Wilder would have to beat Fury and AJ for me to consider him. I would have to see where he is after each fight but to be completely…

Comment by BoxingIsGreat on 10-02-2018

[QUOTE=Boxing Goat;19159050]There's no excuse good enough. I apologize, you took me by surprise.[/QUOTE] No worries. Difference of opinion.

Comment by Boxing Goat on 10-02-2018

[QUOTE=BoxingIsGreat;19158918]I explained my reasons in this very thread. I can see you just jumped in now. No name calling necessary![/QUOTE] There's no excuse good enough. I apologize, you took me by surprise.

Comment by NearHypnos on 10-02-2018

[QUOTE=Fists_of_Fury;19158965]Solid post. There was no eye test doe before this hype job era. People ranked high p4p actually put in the work and fought elite competition. Tons have looked good against bums but get exposed when they fight better competition.[/QUOTE]…

Comment by Fists_of_Fury on 10-02-2018

[QUOTE=NearHypnos;19158832]Bud the worst resume in the top 5. He’s also never climbed in the ring against a p4p talent. Also not the best fighter in his division until he proves it Hell, GGG has shown more skill than Bud as…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (110)
Top Headlines Hearn: WBC Has NOT Ordered Rematch, Wilder Can Face Joshua Dirrell Motivated, 'Ready For Challenge' of Yildirim Title Fight Shields Training Charlo, Ajagba, Apochi For Barclays Card Photos: Navarrete Stuns, Punishes Dogboe For WBO Title Wilder-Fury Rematch Talks To Begin Next Week, Says Warren Photos: Lomachenko Drops, Decisions Pedraza To Unify Belts Photos: Kell Brook Looks Flat in Decision Win Over Zerafa Photos: Carroll, Frenois Ends in Draw - No Mandatory For Farmer Teofimo Lopez: Im 2019, I Will Be Champion - I Guarantee It! Brook: I Want To Shut Khan Up, Then Move On To Spence, Porter Rene Alvarado Beats Carlos Morales, Targets Machado Shot Euro News: Spike O'Sullivan, Oliver Meng, Jordy Weiss, More Video: Andre Ward Talks Loma, Spence-Garcia, Pacquiao, More Filip Hrgovic Decisions Kevin Johnson Over Eight Rounds Lomachenko Wants More Belts, Hopes For Mikey Garcia in 2019 Mchunu Gets Revenge on Oosthuizen, Mbenge Stops Vazquez Pat Manuel, Transgender Boxer, Makes History With Win Lomachenko vs. Pedraza - CompuBox Punch Stats Cecilia Braekhus Retains Titles, Lopsided Decision over Lopes Lomachenko Drops Pedraza Twice, Wins Decision To Unify Titles Juan Francisco Estrada Breaks Down, Stops Mendez in Seven Lomachenko vs. Pedraza - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Claressa Shields Easily Boxes Past Hermans, Hammer Up Next Emanuel Navarrete Shocks Isaac Dogboe, Captures WBO Title Dogboe vs. Navarrete - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Teofimo Lopez Destroys Mason Menard - One Punch in One Besputin Drops Abreu Twice, Wins 10-Round Unanimous Decision Dogboe vs. Navarrete - CompuBox Historical Review Lomachenko: Getting Dropped Was Me Not Being Focused HBO Tripleheader - LIVE Results From Carson, California Lopez: Everyone Says I'm Overrated; I Haven't Shown Anything Yet Lomachenko-Pedraza Undercard Results From Theater at MSG Kell Brook Goes The Distance, Beats Zerafa in WBA Eliminator Kell Brook vs. Michael Zerafa - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Alvarez vs. Kovalev Rematch Official For 2/2 in Frisco, Texas Carroll, Frenois Battle To a Split Draw, Neither Lands Farmer Shot Shields' Manager: Braekhus Won't Fight Her; Says She's Too Big Lomachenko vs. Pedraza - CompuBox Historical Review Carlos Sanchez Ready For Stiffest Test To Date in Los Angeles Braekhus: I'm Honored To Headline HBO's Final Boxing Night
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement