Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Andrew Moloney Legal Battle Continues Over Franco Rematch Outcome

Efforts by Andrew Moloney and his legal team for swift and resolute justice have so far been met with resistance. 

The outcome of Moloney’s recent rematch with lone conqueror Joshua Franco on November 14 has been officially appealed by his team, formally protesting the No-Decision verdict that came of their ESPN-televised contest at MGM Grand Conference Center in Las Vegas. The bout ended prior to the start of round three, when it was determined that San Antonio’s Franco was unable to continue due to a swollen shut right eye.

Moloney’s in-ring celebration was an organic reaction to the belief that he avenged his lone career defeat, when Franco claimed a 12-round decision and a secondary junior bantamweight title on June 23 in the very same venue. That moment was quickly disrupted upon learning that referee Russell Mora determined that the injury was caused by a headbutt.


Extensive replay strongly suggested that a Moloney left jab in the opening round initiated the damage, although a review process which took more than 26:00 minutes ultimately resulted with the Nevada State Athletic Commission (NSAC) honoring the in-ring ruling. As such, Franco (17-1-2, 8KOs; 1NC) left the ring—and the room entirely—with his title still intact, while Moloney (21-1, 14KOs; 1NC) will have to wait for a third fight in order to reclaim the title that should have come from the aftermath of their rematch.

From there has come contact between the commission and Moloney’s legal team, which as previously reported by is headed by renowned boxing attorney Josh Dubin. Hopes of having the matter appear on the next NSAC monthly agenda hearing—currently scheduled for December 2—was instead met with the insistence that the matter will have to wait until the first quarter of 2021.

More troubling is the suggestion that the Nevada Attorney General’s Office (NVAGO) claims the matter to be officially under review, which contradicts state law.

“Andrew Moloney has a right to a hearing under Section 467.682(1) [of the Nevada Athletic Commission rules], which directs that the referee’s decision(s) declaring fouls during a bout may be overturned after a hearing before the Commission,” Dubin told on Wednesday after having received the news from Nevada AG Mike Detmer. “The referee's decision to declare an accidental headbutt has received international media attention. Needless to say, it is critical that this process is transparent and that Mr. Moloney is afforded the due process to which he is entitled consistent with Nevada law.

“Any review that is currently taking place, prior to a hearing, is improper and premature. We are in the process of obtaining additional camera angles from ESPN that will play a critical role (at a hearing) in demonstrating that in fact no headbutt of any kind occurred during the bout. Any analysis of the bout without the benefit of those additional camera angles and my advocacy on behalf of Mr. Moloney defeats the purpose of conducting a hearing.”

The appeal filed by Team Moloney was acknowledged both by Bob Bennett, executive director of the NSAC, and the state’s Attorney General’s Office. The suggestion from Mr. Detmer was that the matter would not be heard before the commission’s five-person panel any earlier than the NSAC agenda hearing in January, if not February. It was alleged that no such room existed on the December docket, which currently only has a handful of requests for state venue usage by the UFC, along with temporary suspension reviews for a total of 10 combat sports athletes.

Among those whose cases are budgeted to be heard is disgraced former heavyweight contender Jarrell Miller, who remains suspended after having tested positive for a banned substance this past June. Miller’s case has appeared on new fewer than four monthly agenda hearing budgets, with each previous occasion merely resulting in an extension of his current suspension while the review process continues.

The remaining items—all of which cover athletes currently awaiting disciplinary action for having submitted positive drug tests surrounding bouts which have taken place in Las Vegas—are normally ruled upon in no more than three minutes per case.

The purpose of scheduling a case such as the one Moloney has filed would be to begin the official review process as soon as possible. In addition to the official appeal, Moloney’s legal team plans to provide video evidence to visually support their case.

For the commission to claim that the review process has begun without any such evidence or even a hearing to authorize such steps is in violation of their very laws in place.

“I thought it was a strange e-mail to get,” Dubin said of his exchange with the NVAGO. “Even stranger was the message contained within. This kid [Moloney] is sitting in quarantine in Australia (which requires mandatory two-way 14-day isolation when traveling to and from the country). He’s basically locked in a room. He’s sacrificed so much, yet the commission in a very cavalier way is saying, ‘Oh, we’ll see if we can get to it in January or February.

“The cavalier way in which they’re approaching this should be infuriating to the public, as much as it is to me and to Andrew.”

A misrepresentation by the NVAGO suggested that Moloney’s team is seeking an emergency meeting, which they in turn rejected in claiming it does not constitute such a process under Chapter 241.020 of the Nevada Revised Statutes (NRS) covering meetings of state and local agencies.

It has also been suggested that such a delay is necessary due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic—which has forced state officials to meet monthly via conference call in lieu of in-person gatherings at state headquarters in Las Vegas—and the timing of the appeal.

Given the season, it’s fair to argue that the move is little more than political football.

“There’s no reason for this case to not be heard at the next meeting,” insists Dubin. “This whole issue over whether or not it’s doable due to COVID—as I’ve pointed out to (Attorney Detmer), I’ve been conducting court hearings and arguments, and video is not a problem to show over Zoom or any other conference call. 

“They have an opportunity here to just admit that they made a mistake. Why they’re not doing that here, I don’t know. But I won’t let Andrew get screwed any more so than has already been the case.”

Jake Donovan is a senior writer for Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Ajvar on 11-27-2020

It's like trumptards. Their leader shouts for nonexistent stuff but because he shouts so loud his idiots believe there got to be something and try making it "tricky" and "inconclusive". There is an old joke about such stuff: - Marry,…

Comment by Eff Pandas on 11-27-2020

This is turning into the Zapruder film of boxing ffs.

Comment by Toffee on 11-27-2020

[QUOTE=ShoulderRoll;20910332]They didn't see anything conclusive enough that night to overturn the ref's call. That was the appropriate action in my opinion. Here we are weeks later and people STILL aren't certain. So that shows you how tricky this was.[/QUOTE] I…

Comment by theface07 on 11-26-2020

[QUOTE=Cobratu;20909576]This guy is looking more and more like a fool. The commission already released the videos and still images of where the butt acured and it was pretty damn obvious.[/QUOTE] No he didn't. You sound like a guy looking for…

Comment by tritium_arma on 11-26-2020

[QUOTE=ShoulderRoll;20910334]Not for a legal punch. For the thumb to the eye.[/QUOTE] With the type of gloves he was wearing that’s considered a legal punch. Did you even listen to the broadcast?

Top Headlines
Josh Warrington May Vacate IBF Title, Fight Gary Russell Jr. Bruno Tarimo Cracks IBF's Top Ten, Inches Closer To Title Shot Terri Harper's Manager Hopes To Achieve Undisputed Goal in Two Fights Teofimo Lopez: If No Kambosos - Then I Want Haney, Garcia, Davis Chris Eubank Jr. Has Golovkin as #1 Target on List, Says Promoter Carlos Ocampo Destroys Abraham Juarez in One Round Gervonta Davis on Sparring Teofimo, Haney - Pushing For Fight With Ryan Garcia Robeisy Ramirez: If Not This Year - By 2022 I'll Be Fighting For a World Title David Morrell Aims To Fight Four Times By The End of 2021 Bjornsson Drops Ward, Who Rallies in Third: Both React To Exhibition Hearn: If Both Win Their Fights, Expect Josh Kelly vs. Conor Benn in 2021 Berchelt: Valdez Motivated By Those That Say He Has No Chance; It's Going To Be A War Ryan Garcia: Can Only Become Greater Learning From Reynoso, Canelo Joseph Diaz Eager To End 130-Pound Title Unification Drought Daily Bread Mailbag: Sonny Liston, Ryan Garcia, Heavyweights, More David Benavidez Demands Caleb Plant Fight, Eyes Canelo Alvarez Demetrius Andrade: I Never Ducked Charlo, That's Crazy! Povetkin-Whyte Rematch Could Go To Gibraltar, Monaco or Middle East Victor Pasillas Grinding Hard For Ra'eese Aleem Clash Chantelle Cameron: Let's See if Melissa Hernandez Backs Up Her Talk McGregor's Boxing Coach: 85-90% Chance Pacquiao Fight Happens Whyte: I Want To Smash Povetkin's Face In, He Pretends To Be Nice Guy - He Will Pay! Hafthor Bjornsson Pumped To Face Ward, Then 'Biggest Enemy' Eddie Hall Shane McGuigan Rates The Top Five Lightweights Josh Taylor: Teofimo Lopez's Ego Has Exploded, I'd Like To Cut Him Down To Size! Fury vs. Joshua: Hearn Receiving Offers From Several Countries To Host Ryan Garcia Aims To Retire Early, Open To a Future Run in MMA McGuigan: Eubank Jr. Has a Good Chance Against Golovkin, Charlo, Murata Ra'eese Aleem Putting in Work For Victor Pasillas Showtime Clash Demetrius Andrade-Liam Williams Middleweight Title Fight Re-Ordered By WBO Kovalev vs. Melikuziev Officially Canceled After Failed Drug Test Charr-Bryan, Shumenov-Murphy Announced By King as PPV Stream, Jan. 29 Povetkin-Whyte PPV Card: Wardley-Molina, Cheeseman-Metcalf, Campbell Hatton Povetkin-Whyte, Warrington-Lara, Okolie-Glowacki Among Matchroom Fights Announced Rey Vargas Moves Up To Featherweight, Named WBC Mandatory Challenger To Gary Russell Jr. Euro News: Faust, EC Boxing, Kraft, Patera vs. Boschiero, More Inoue, Dasmarinas Reach Terms For Mandatory Title Fight, Purse Bid Cancelled Angelo Leo: Wasn't My Best Performance Last Fight, Fans Didn't Get To See Best Of Me Yet Billy Joe Saunders Rules Out Caleb Plant Fight, Citing Politics: It's A Waste of Breath Haney: If Garcia Don't Want It, We'll Keep Going Down The Line To Teofimo or Fortuna
Latest Forum Threads