Analyzing The Kazuto Ioka-Juan C. Reveco Scorecards

By Jake Donovan

Kazuto Ioka picked up a belt in a third weight class (one full reign, two secondary reigns) following a 12-round win over Argentina’s Juan Carlos Reveco in their flyweight title fight Wednesday evening in Osaka, Japan.

Judges Carlos Sucre (Venezuela) and Silvestre Aibainza (Philippines) both had Ioka winning by scores of 116-113 and 115-113, respectively. Judge Raul Caiz Sr. (Unites States) scored the contest 114-114 even.

(Click HERE for the official master scorecard)

The concern over the course of the night was the potential for a wide disparity in scores given the number of close rounds. There was also the matter of style preference in the absence of definitive rounds, whether you liked Reveco’s aggression or Ioka’s technical superiority
Fans watching and commenting through social media leaned towards Ioka. The broadcast team for TyC Sports in Reveco’s native Argentina had their countryman winning handily, going as far as to calling the fight a horrific injustice to the sport.

If there’s a conspiracy theory to be found not as ridiculous as the claims made by the TyC crew, it’s that Ioka already had the fight won before the 12th and final round began. The action in the ring dictated otherwise, that the 26-year old from Japan needed a strong three minutes to seal the deal.

Despite what the eye test suggested, Ioka was up 106-103 and 107-103 on the cards of Aibainza and Sucre, while Caiz Sr. had Reveco winning 105-104 heading into the final round.

In the eyes of the three judges, six of the 12 rounds were clear-cut. The three ringside officials all scored unanimously in favor of Reveco (35-2, 19KOs) in rounds three and seven, while Ioka swept the cards in rounds one (surprising, given it was a very close round), five, eight and nine.

Round four saw judges Caiz and Abainza score in favor of Reveco, while Sucre scored the bout 10-10, the only even round scored among the combined 36 from the three judges’ scorecards.

Abainza was in agreement with at least one other judge for all 12 rounds. The veteran official was in line with Caiz for the most part; the two agreed on nine of the 12 rounds, giving Ioka rounds 1, 2, 5, 8 and 9, while both awarding Reveco rounds 3, 4, 7 and 10.

Caiz also agreed on nine of the 12 rounds with Sucre. The two judges scored rounds 1, 5, 6, 8, 9 and 11 in favor of Ioka; and rounds 3, 7 and 12 in favor of Reveco.

Sucre and Caiz did not agree on any of the six rounds (2, 4, 6, 10, 11 and 12) that weren’t scored unanimously for either fighter.

Had majority scoring been in place to determine the winner, Ioka (17-1, 10KOs) still would have come out ahead in the end by a score of 115-113, which matches the total turned in by Aibanaza. Ioka won on at least two scorecards in rounds 1, 2, 5, 6, 8, 9 and 11, with Reveco granted rounds 3, 4, 7, 10 and 12 on two or more cards.

The loss ends Reveco’s title reign, having held a regular or interim title since 2010. It also snaps an 18-fight win streak stretched out over eight years. His lone other loss came in Dec. ’07, dropping a 12-round decision to Brahim Asloum in France in their 108 lb. title fight.

With the win, Ioka has now claimed titles at strawweight, junior flyweight and flyweight. He joins Koki Kameda as just the second fighter ever from Japan to accomplish the feat, doing so in seven fewer fights.

Kameda won belts at junior flyweight, flyweight (World championship) and bantamweight (secondary title) by his 25th pro fight. Ioka collected his three belts in 18 fights, although at age 26 was two years older than Kameda (24) at the time of the achievement.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Twitter: @JakeNDaBox
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Dindu_Nuffin on 04-22-2015

I saw the fight - it was close. It was a great contrast of styles. I didn't score it myself, but either man nicking it would be fair. 116-112 sounds wide, but in reality, it's just two rounds that separates…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (1)
Top Headlines Photos: Terence Crawford, Amir Khan - Go Face To Face in NYC Ellerbe: Broner Beating Pacquiao is No Upset, This is 50-50 Fight Canelo Alvarez vs. Daniel Jacobs Finalized For May 4 Photos: Serrano vs. Voraberger, Doheny vs. Takahashi - Weigh-In Photos: Jorge Linares, Pable Cesar Cano - Ready For War Photos: Chris Algieri, Danny Gonzalez - On Point To Fight Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Artur Akavov - Ready For Battle Erislandy Lara vs. Brian Castano Tops Showtime Triple, March 2 Ricardo Quiroz To Face Jamaine Ortiz on February 23 Photos: Keith Thurman Putting in Work For Josesito Lopez Weights From New York City: Andrade 159.8, Akavov 160 Hearn Prepared To Win Purse Bid For Wilder-Fury Rematch Broner: Arum Offered Me $2 Million To Fight Pacquiao; F*** Him! Liam Smith vs. Sam Eggington Set Down March 30th Shohjahon Ergashev vs. Mykal Fox on February 15, ShoBox Anthony Yarde vs. Mehdi Amar Set For February 23 Khan: I Think a Brook Fight Is Still There, A Fight I'd Love To Have Malignaggi Feels Garcia is 'Going Too Far' in Facing Spence Broner: If I Win That Maidana Fight, I'd Probably Be Dead Now Hearn, Golden Boy Keen on Linares-Cano Winner vs. Hooker Warren Reacts To Hearn's Offer Claim For Joshua vs. Fury Loeffler Aims To Stage Several 'Hollywood Fight Nights' in 2019 Liam Smith Would Welcome a Showdown With Kell Brook Pacquiao: What Happened With Marquez Will Not Happen Again! Cameron Krael Fights on Mayweather Card at MGM Grand Video: Mike Reed on Preparing Adrien Broner For Pacquiao Video: Roy Jones Jr. Breaks Down Pacquiao vs. Broner Clash Video: Caleb Plant Discusses IBF Title Win Over Jose Uzcategui Video: Al Bernstein Reacts To Adrien Broner Going Off On Him Manny Pacquiao - Is This the One? Amir Khan: I'll Beat Crawford, Take His Place in P4P Rankings! Muhammad Ali's Hometown Renames Airport in His Honor Broner Tells Pacquiao's Group He Has Cat, Dog For Them To Eat Video: Pacquiao vs. Broner - All Access Daily - Part 1 Broner Calls Showtime's Al Bernstein Biased, 'B*tch-Ass N*gga' Photos: Pacquiao, Broner - Face To Face at Final Presser Photos: Jorge Linares, Pable Cesar Cano - Go Face To Face Photos: Chris Algieri, Danny Gonzalez - Go Face To Face Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Artur Akavov - Go Face To Face Broner: Pacquiao, Roach Underestimating A Lot Of What I Can Do

Latest Active Forum Threads