Abraham-Smith: Protest in Hands of Independent Panel

By Jake Donovan

A lot has happened in the boxing world since the September 27 clash between super middleweight titlist Arthur Abraham and Paul Smith, but the controversy that stemmed from that evening remains a fresh wound for the challenger.

Smith offered one of the strongest performances of his career, pushing Abraham to the brink in a tooth-and-nail affair in Germany. His effort proved for naught, as the three judges had the defending champ winning by a comfortable margin, including a 119-109 scorecard turned in by Spanish judge Fernando Laguna that warrants – and is currently undergoing – an investigation.

An official protest was submitted to the World Boxing Organization (WBO) by Matchroom Boxing head Eddie Hearn, Smith’s promoter as their side refuses to accept the hand dealt to them.

“We received the protest from Matchroom Boxing,” confirmed Francisco ‘Paco’ Valcarcel, WBO president. “From there, we requested all evidence of (wrongdoing) to the fighter, and assign five officials to independently review and score the fight. They are anonymous judges. The only one who knows their identity is me.

“A spreadsheet is prepared with all of the scores. The round is then scored based on (majority scoring). From there we can determine who was the real winner.”

A similar case study was performed in the wake of Tim Bradley’s highly controversial split decision win over Manny Pacquiao in their first fight in June ’12. The panel’s final determination was in line with that of public opinion, that Pacquiao deserved to win the fight and with room to spare.

Of course, the decision remained as-is, with the rematch coming two years later – not due to a mandate, but because it was the most sensible business decision for both fighters.

That said, Smith (35-4, 20KOs) doesn’t carry the same type of leverage as Pacquiao, to where he can just demand a title fight at his leisure. While the Brit won’t see a reversal in the decision, it stands to reason that the right outcome from the independent panel could result in an ordered rematch.

At the very least, he has the sympathy of the sanctioning body’s top dog.

“My position is that the judge from Spain (Fernando Laguna) was far off with that score of 119-109,” Valcarcel stated, echoing his comments recently made through social media. “In my opinion, it was a close fight. We will see what the five judges have to say and will reveal to the (boxing) world their results once they have time to review and score the fight.”

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Post a Comment - View More User Comments (0)
Top Headlines Hearn: Wilder's Win Impressive, Joshua Fight Must Happen Next Video: Gary Russell Jr. Discusses TKO of Martinez, The Future Video: Andre Rozier Reacts To Deontay Wilder's KO of Breazeale Video: Deontay Wilder's Trainer Reacts To KO of Breazeale Video: Deontay Wilder Reacts To Vicious KO of Breazeale Deontay Wilder: I Told Breazeale I Love Him, We Shook Hands Deontay Wilder Could Be Ringside For Joshua vs. Ruiz at MSG Breazeale: I Think The Referee Stopped it a Little Early! Deontay Wilder vs. Dominic Breazeale - CompuBox Punch Stats Jose Zepeda vs. Eleazar Valenzuela Ends in a No-Contest Deontay Wilder Demolishes Breazeale in One Round Wilder vs. Breazeale - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Gary Russell Stops Kiko Martinez in Five Due To Cut Gary Russell vs. Kiko Martinez - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Juan Heraldez, Argenis Mendez Battle To Majority Draw Photos: Serhii Bohachuk, Freddy Hernandez - Ready For Battle Wilder: They've Said That I Only Have Right Hand For 10 Years Gary Antuanne Russell Stops Marcos Mojica In Fourth Round Kiko Martinez: Since a Young Boy I've Dreamt of The WBC Belt Wilder-Breazeale - LIVE Results From Barlcays Center Lolenga Mock Edges Veron, Shakhobidin Zoirov Wins Big Billy Joe Saunders Easily Boxes Past Shefat Isufi To Win WBO Title Josh Taylor Drops, Decisions Ivan Baranchyk For IBF Title Joe Joyce Knocks Out Alexander Ustinov in Third Josh Taylor vs. Ivan Baranchyk - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Naoya Inoue Destroys Emmanuel Rodriguez in Two Rounds Inoue vs. Rodriguez - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Paul Butler Breaks Down, Stops Salvador Hernandez in Six Zach Parker, Reece McFadden Secure Wins in Glasgow Alantez Fox Continues His Middleweight Run in Washington, DC Lee McGregor Decisions Brett Fidoe on Taylor-Baranchyk Card Evgeny Chuprakov Stops Alexander Munoz in The Ninth Heavyweights and The WBSS: Stats & Stakes Gary Russell: I'll Move Up For 'Personal' Lomachenko Rematch Roach: Winner of Baranchyk vs. Taylor Will Win WBSS Tourney Breazeale: Once NFL Doors Closed, Boxing Was Only Thing I Had Saunders: Hard Not To Look Past Isufi, But Better Than He Looks Figueroa-Ugas Added To Pacquiao-Thurman Undercard July 20 Breazeale: Wilder Had 40 Bogus-Ass Fights; Fought 2 Credible Guys Inoue: Rodriguez Is A Great Fighter But I Plan To Knock Him Out

Latest Active Forum Threads