Advertisement
Advertisement

Viloria, Peterson Upset Specials: Review, Ratings Update

by Cliff Rold

The DMV brought it for big fight night.  The crowd was raucous and rewarded for their enthusiasm.  It was one of those nights where being there meant a ton.  The crowd was nuts for Anthony Peterson before the televised broadcast.  The ooh’s and ash’s when the replays were shown of Heavyweight Seth Mitchell’s knockout were deafening.

And then there was the main event.  Amir Khan made it his second December in a row with a Fight of the Year candidate, last year leaving fans breathless against Marcos Maidana.  This time, he didn’t escape with the win.  The referee had something to do with it.  So did the relentless body attack of Lamont Peterson.

A world away in the Philippines, Brian Viloria got himself in the conversation for Fighter, Comeback, and Upset of the Year with a career-redefining win.  It was a great weekend for fight fans.

Thank you boxing.

Let’s got to the report cards.

Grades
Pre-Fight: Speed – Khan A; Peterson B+/Post: A+; A-
Pre-Fight: Power – Khan B+; Peterson B-/Post: B+; B
Pre-Fight: Defense – Khan B; Peterson B/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Khan B+; Peterson B/Post: A+; A+

Grades
Pre-Fight: Speed – Viloria B+; Segura B/A-; B-
Pre-Fight: Power – Viloria B+; Segura A/Post: A-; B+
Pre-Fight: Defense – Viloria B-; Segura C-/Post: B+; D+
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Viloria B; Segura A/Post: A; A

Beginning with the little men, it’s hard not to see the result and wonder why Viloria (30-3, 17 KO), who won on an eight-round technical knockout, was not the favorite heading into the bout with Segura (28-2-1, 24 KO).  Short, hard shots usually beat wide.  Such was the strength of the run Segura had put together versus some of the ups and downs Viloria’s years in the ring.

He turned back the negatives Saturday.  Segura had some nice rallies in spots.  With charity he may have won the fifth round.  It’s probably truer to have had Viloria shutting him out.  Viloria was precise, landing between the wider swings of Segura and the hematoma around the right eye of Segura was gruesome.  His left hook and right hand ruled the night and the amateur pedigree he possesses, the skill base it provides, was evident.

Paired with his WBO 112 lb. title win over Julio Cesar Miranda, Viloria has rebuilt from the ashes of a bad loss to Carlos Tamara.  Fights with lineal champion Pongsaklek Wonjongkam or WBA titlist Tyson Marquez would be welcome and pick ‘em for the moment.

Segura is hardly done.  Still one of the most exciting fighters alive, he too could be paired with Marquez, or even bomber Luis Concepcion, for thrillers.  Flyweight has some new life this year and hopefully the division can parlay that into serious action in 2012.

Back to the States, and the question is: did Amir Khan (26-2, 18 KO) get the business from referee Joseph Cooper against Lamont Peterson (30-1-1, 15 KO) in losing his Jr. Welterweight belts?  The answer looked like a yes, but Peterson losing a point for a questionable knockdown was an element of the fight as well.  Khan was a victim of an overly strict interpretation of the rules on the road, deducted two critical points for something almost never penalized.  This scribe had it 113-112 for Peterson.  The deductions counted.

Khan has a right to be pissed.  It takes nothing away from what Peterson did.  Peterson looked like he would be overwhelmed early by the speed of Khan.  In the last minute of the second round he began to adjust and fans got a classic affair.  Peterson’s assault to the body had Khan on the run and holding like crazy for long stretches with perhaps a bit too much looking to the ref to complain.  Fact was, both men fouled a ton but not in a bad way.

It was a fight.  They fought their asses off. 

The rallies Khan came up with, the shot he hurt Peterson with in the ninth, and a strong close in the final two rounds (deduction or no) left reason to drool about a return engagement.

At the post-fight press conference, Khan requested, strongly, that Peterson shows the same courage he did in going on the road and brings the rematch to England.  It is more likely to head to Vegas but Peterson was up for it.  Peterson, asked what adjustments he made to the speed of Khan, said he stopped going straight back and committed to coming forward.

As a bonus, wearing their promoter hats for Golden Boy, Oscar De La Hoya and Bernard Hopkins were around to answer questions.  As the press conference MC, De La Hoya gave credit to both fighters but made sure to highlight the deductions and stressed that both men were ready for a rematch.

Asked afterwards, putting aside the deduction, how he felt about the turnout and enthusiasm of the D.C. fans as a promoter, De La Hoya said, “The outcome was amazing.  The turnout was incredible by the fans.  We were extremely proud about the promotion.  It goes to show you that if you take a fight to the fans, they will come out and support.  This is not going to the last time we go outside of Las Vegas or Los Angeles.  These are fun promotions and this is what it’s all about.”

Hopkins was asked to reflect on being back in the Washington, D.C. area.  His first title shot, against Roy Jones Jr., came at the old RFK stadium.  His first title win, against Segundo Mercado, came relatively down the street from the D.C. Convention Center in Landover, Maryland (current home of the Washington Redskins).  “I reflected on it as soon as I got in D.C. because I have a lot of fans here.  I have a lot of support here even though I’m from Philadelphia.  It’s been eighteen years.  When you come to this town, you go to come to this town ready because they are a real, real fight town.  Seriously, you seen the crowd.  You seen the press conference.  When you come to D.C. or Maryland, because Maryland is attached to D.; that’s where their identity is at.”

As a bonus, Hopkins was asked about his career past the age of 40.  Beginning with two bouts against Jermain Taylor in 2005, it can be argued Hopkins has faced the stiffest competition in the sport over the last six to seven years with bouts against Antonio Tarver, Winky Wright, Joe Calzaghe, Kelly Pavlik, Jean Pascal, and, ugly ending aside, Chad Dawson.  Asked explicitly why he appears to have bigger balls than fighters much younger than him who often don’t fight the same level of foe consistently, Hopkins gave a short replay.

“Because I have big balls.”

End quote.

It was a fantastic night at the fights. 
 
Report Card Picks 2011: 41-18

Ratings Update

Jr. Welterweight: Bradley’s hold on the number one spot is strengthened while Peterson gets a bump.  Khan remains right in the thick of things in this wonderful division.

Flyweight: Viloria gets a bump off the best win, in the best year, of his career.  Segura, despite the loss, enters the top ten low.

Jr. Flyweight: Giovanni Segura is removed as champion with his career to stay at Flyweight and above.   

These moves and more are reflected a page away.

>>>>>>Click Here To View BoxingScene's Full Divisional Ratings<<<<<<

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by boxycom on 12-12-2011

It would be nice to see a rematch of Brian Viloria and Carlos Tamara

Comment by balintawak on 12-12-2011

Viloria has always been fun to watch. He's got good fundamentals and power. Tha's how he received his moniker 'The Hawaiian Punch'. I've only seen the highlights and Segura really hits hard! After watching his power and solid chin, I…

Comment by crold1 on 12-12-2011

[QUOTE=hougigo;11552237]Yea... I know the ring has some zonky ratings sometimes. I seriously thought Segura would do that Viloria. Congrats to Viloria though, can't wait to see what's next[/QUOTE] I'd LOVE to see him with Wonjongkam or Marquez. Mthalane would be…

Comment by Hougigo on 12-12-2011

[QUOTE=crold1;11552213]Ring had him that high, though not many others went top 10. No need to feel silly. There were good reasons to favor Segura. Viloria fought his ass off Saturday. Great performance[/QUOTE] Yea... I know the ring has some zonky…

Comment by crold1 on 12-12-2011

[QUOTE=hougigo;11552209]I would agree that it was an upset.. plus the fact that people regarded him so highly (#9 P4P) added to that. Hell, even I thought he would fuk Viloria up....look how silly I feel now[/QUOTE] Ring had him that…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (12)
Top Headlines Daily Bread Mailbag: Danny Garcia, Lomachenko, Thurman, More Semajay Thomas Embraces How Boxing Changed His Life Yodmongkol Vor Saengthep Easily Stops Outmatched Opponent Parker: Soon Joshua's Confidence Will Be Tested Against Me Golovkin's Coach: We Never Asked Andre Ward For 164 Weight George Groves Entering Last-Chance Saloon Against Murray LaRon Mitchell Stops Epifanio Mendoza in Three Rounds Keith Thurman-Shawn Porter: Pre-Fight Report Card Ricardo Rodriguez Beats David Quijano in Boxeo Telemundo Canelo's Manager Taking Smith Serious, Expects Dangerous Fight Photos: Vargas Rubs Shoulders With Mayweather at BWAA Awards Canelo's Manager To Critics: We're Back To Our Natural Weight! Kenny Porter Not Concerned With Layoff as Thurman Shot Nears Arum: Thurman-Porter is Good Fight, Hope it Gets Good Rating Thurman Reflects on His Long Journey, Lessons Along The Way Video: Jessie Vargas Talks Kell Brook, Thurman vs. Porter Photos/Weights: PBC on NBCSN - Justin DeLoach-Junior Castillo Photos: Mike Alvarado vs. Josh Torres, Korobov-Vera Weighin DiBella Breaks Down Thurman-Porter, Isn't Sure Who Wins Povetkin, Ryabinsky To Hold Meeting With WBC Next Week Liam Smith: I Will Shake Up The World When I Beat Canelo Groves Explains His Version of Events in Golovkin Sparring Tale Photos: Keith Thurman, Shawn Porter Ready For Barclays War Weights from Brooklyn: Porter Strips to 147, Thurman at 146 Liam Smith vs. Canelo Alvarez - Fight Poster Revealed Canelo Alvarez vs. Liam Smith Finalized at 154, 9/17 on PPV Fury To Klitschko: I'm Hitler? You Stupid F***ing Ukrainian Pr*ck! Golden Boy VP Reacts To Arum, Insists Pacquiao vs. Broner is On! Video: Sky Sports Crew Discuss Klitschko vs. Fury Postponement Video: Joshua-Breazeale, Groves-Murray, Eubank-Doran Weighin Jason Sosa Drills Javier Fortuna in Eleventh, Grabs WBA Title Eubank Jr: I Didn't Want To Take Off Underwear, Scare Everyone Photos: Anthony Joshua, Dominic Breazeale Ready For Battle Felix Diaz-Levan Ghvamichava Tops PBC on FS1, July 12 Photo: Tyson Fury's Badly Bruised, Sprained Ankle Injury Felix Verdejo-Jose Felix Likely For October - If Pacquiao Returns Fury Rolls Ankle, July 9 Klitschko Rematch Postponed Thurman Warns: Stop Protecting Your Record Like Mayweather! Arum: Golovkin vs. Ramirez, We Have Deal in Principle For 2017 Groves Explains Boost With McGuigan as Murray Bout Nears
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement