Upon Further Review: Rotten D.C. Verdict Still Stinks

By Lyle Fitzsimmons

It’s getting close to 72 hours… and I still can’t decide how I feel.
Suffice to say, though, that the whole of Saturday’s show from Washington, D.C. has me conflicted.
First off, regardless of who actually won the fight-of-the-year-quality main event (Lamont Peterson) – and/or who actually deserved to (Amir Khan) – my forecast of a final showcase performance by Khan on the way to a super cash-out a division north was, shall we say, a bit off.

Had Michael Buffer spat "and still" rather than "and new" after what seemed an inordinate mathematical delay at the Walter E. Washington Convention Center, the handsome Brit with Pakistani tribal roots would still have had some serious image-reclamation work to do.

By any measure, his performance was disappointing.

And needless to say, even winning a chaotic scrap at 140 with a guy who’d gone 0-1-1 in his two biggest fights wouldn’t have been the most convincing evidence that Khan – even at 27-1 – was rightful heir to the P4P thrones now held by the Mayweathers and Pacquiaos at 147.

It was barely worthy, in fact, of court jesters Berto, Ortiz and Jones.

While he looked intermittently brilliant letting his hands go and befuddling Peterson with movement, there were far too many occasions when Khan was drawn into firefights and apparently flummoxed by his inability to render a less-skilled foe unconscious, or at least unwilling.

Those would have been pockmarks warranted for a full-throated Tuesday recap.

But unfortunately for Khan – or fortunately, maybe – those flaws aren’t nearly as relevant.

Rather, the most pungent post-fight stench still lingers from the efforts of one Joseph Cooper, whose on-again/off-again officiousness at the very least violated a cardinal rule of refereeing – to regulate, not participate – and at the very most changed the fiscal trajectory of a would-be superstar.

Though lauded by Buffer as a veteran of more than two dozen world title fights – none of which I’d ever seen, incidentally – the locally-groomed Virginia resident looked particularly overmatched in the throes of a bout with prolonged periods of grappling and jockeying for inside position.

The second of two pushing fouls on Khan has been rightly pilloried for its remarkably poor timing, though Cooper’s every bit as indictable for not simply applying in-fight context to supplement the skull-first, bore-in style that Peterson was given a pass on employing for 36 minutes.

Simply put, if you’re going to permit head and shoulders as grindstones over 12 rounds, OK.

But it’s only fair that some consistent counter-maneuvers be allowed to the guy whose torso is the target of the would-be roughhousing – in the holiday spirit of eye for an eye, or, if the New Testament is more your thing, a push for a shove.

Either way, in that simple measure of justice, Cooper was an epic fail.

And because the points taken tipped the scales from unanimous win to split loss, a Biblical one.

There was no harm on either my 113-112 or judge Nelson Vasquez’s 115-110 card for Khan, which would only have yielded wider margins had Cotton not intervened. But in the eyes of George Hill and Valerie Dorsett, each of whom scored it one point in Peterson’s favor, his foolishness loomed larger.  

“There was no explanation. (Cotton) did a terrible job," trainer Freddie Roach said. “Referees shouldn't decide fights. He's not a judge. He made himself a judge (Saturday). The thing is, he decided the fight, not the judges. He took two points away for nothing and didn't give warnings.”

While it’s true Khan did himself no PPV favors with an uneven performance, it’s no less true that – given an official with a firmer grasp on the goings-on – his biggest concern in the aftermath would have been paling by comparison to Tim Bradley’s one-sided defeat of Peterson two years earlier.

With only that as an obstacle, a promoter with the acumen of Richard Schaefer/Oscar De La Hoya could have moved Khan into the welterweight ranks while dismissing a near-fall against Peterson as the valiant big-stage swan song of a determined hometown hero.

Instead, a rumored May 5 date in Las Vegas has been scuttled for preparations for an immediate rematch, and Khan’s long-term viability will be questioned as severely as it had been after he fell in 54 seconds to brash Colombian slugger Breidis Prescott three years ago.

Incidentally, Khan was a world champion only 364 days after that loss and had won eight straight against higher-end foes – including stoppages of Dmitriy Salita (TKO 1), Paul Malignaggi (TKO 11) and Zab Judah (KO 5) – while gradually edging a sturdier but less spectacular Bradley off the pedestal at 140.

If nothing else, Saturday’s result provides a temporary street-cred jolt for the California-born WBO claimant, whose own brief foray at welterweight and subsequent junior welter defeats of Devon Alexander and Joel Casamayor – not to mention a very public rejection of a fight with Khan – were greeted with the consensus apathy usually saved for moonlighting in-ring football players.

Not exactly the frenzy needed to sell a $60 high-def broadcast.

Unless, of course, Arum’s got Tom Brady and his QB coach lined up for the undercard.

If that one gets signed… count me in.

Otherwise, I’ll wait for the movie.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

This week’s title-fight schedule:

WBA/WBC super middleweight titles – Atlantic City, N.J.
Andre Ward (WBA champion) vs. Carl Froch (WBC champion)      
Ward (24-0, 13 KO): Fourth title defense; Zero knockouts in title fights (4-0, 0 KO)
Froch (28-1, 20 KO): Second title defense; Fourth fight in United States (3-0, 2 KO)
Fitzbitz says: “Former Olympic champ climbs biggest mountain as a pro.” Ward by decision
WBO featherweight title – Ciudad Obregon, Mexico
Orlando Salido (champion) vs. Weng Haya (unranked)      
Salido (36-11-2, 24 KO): Second title defense; Unbeaten in Mexico since 2000 (13-0, 10 KO)
Haya (14-4, 8 KO): First title fight; Winless against plus-.500 fighters since 2007 (0-3, 0 KO)
Fitzbitz says: “Resurgent veteran continues title-level run at home.” Salido in 7
NOTE: Fights previewed are only those involving a sanctioning body's full- fledged title-holder – no interim, diamond, silver, etc. Fights for WBA “world championships” are only included if no “super champion” exists in the weight class.

Last week's picks: 0-2
Overall picks record: 273-91 (75.0 percent)

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Nonitard on 12-13-2011

[QUOTE=Johnwoo8686;11559010]You obviously don't know what affirmative action is. Don't be a butthurt Pactard, it's not a good look for you. :nonono:[/QUOTE] butthurt? Just calling it like it is, Lamont's not a real champion. Affirmative Action = giving people something they…

Comment by AlwaysOnTop on 12-13-2011

[QUOTE=Nonitard;11558845]Lamont "Affirmative Action Champion" Peterson[/QUOTE]Manny "The Pinoy Puppet" pacquiao is Arum's Slave. He didn't even get paid for the Cotto fight....and he STILL didn't leave his Master's side. Pac is loyal as a dog....ironically his favorite meal.

Comment by mrjoeblive on 12-13-2011

[QUOTE=voneric;11557610]Its Getting Close to 72 seconds since i read the article...and i still cant decide how i Feel...Oh wait i feel Fitzsimmons is an Idiot or trying to audition for HBO. But i will agree that the Ref was a…

Comment by mrjoeblive on 12-13-2011

[QUOTE=LAPete;11558196]Maybe this post is off topic from Fitz's ignorant and personal article but a good point gets raised from reading his crap..... A few MAJOR reasons why Boxing is so bad without blaming the ref's, judges and the fighters..... 1.…

Comment by Sanlucas77 on 12-13-2011

Strange how the author if this article see's Peterson's "skull and shoulder's " approach to Khan as grounds for the ref to step in and give warning. Did the author also think Miguel Cotto should have been warned for the…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (82)
Top Headlines David Lemieux: I'm Not 100% Satisfied With The Rios Win Klitschko Confirms Title Fight, Won't Confirm The Opponent Sergey Lipinets To Face Lenny Z on Charlo vs. Williams PBC Card Photos: David Lemieux Powers Past Cristian Fabian Rios Joseph Parker vs. Andy Ruiz Could Head To The United States Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. vs. Dominik Britsch on December 10 Erik Morales, Marco Antonio Barrera No Longer Rivals - Photo Roy Jones: If No Canelo, Golovkin Must Take a Risk and Move Up! Video: Buboy Fernandez Breaks Down Pacquiao vs. Vargas Bout Video: Manny Pacquiao Discusses Camp, Vargas Fight, More Roy Jones Jr: I'm Addicted To Boxing, No Retirement Right Now Frankie Gavin Rules Out Retirement, Wants Eggington Rematch Parker's Promoter Faces Resistance on Funding For Ruiz Event Frank Warren Details Thoughts on WBA/WBO Heavyweight Belts Jorge Linares Targets Mikey Garcia, Hopes To Face Him in 2017 Judah: Brook Showed Golovkin is Not Invincible, Canelo Can Win Photos: Sam Eggington Drills Frankie Gavin in Birmingham War Photos: Craig Cunningham Shocks Anthony Ogogo By TKO Pacquiao's Co-Trainer Expects Vargas To Fall in Later Rounds Chavez Sr: My Son Will Continue Relationship With Al Haymon De La Hoya: I Knew Pacquiao Would Beat Me Up, I Was a Dead Man Provodnikov, Pirog, Avanesyan, Troyanovsky Part of Reality Show Eduardo Hernandez Blasts Out Victor Terrazas in Two Rounds Luis Nery Closes in on Title Shot at Bantamweight David Lemieux Dominates Cristian Fabian Rios, Wins Decision Steven Butler Crushes Trotter in One, Maduma is Upset Photos: Manny Pacquiao Mobbed as He Arrives in Los Angeles Kevin Lerena Edges Micki Nielsen: Budler, Van Heerden Win Mikey Garcia Aims To Make a Statement With Dejan Zlaticanin Vazquez: I Took 'Worst Deal of My Career' To Get Juanma in There Marquez: I Beat Pacquiao Four Times, No Reason For Fifth Time! Jamie Cox Outpoints Rios in Foul-Fest, Wins WBO Regional Belt Sam Eggington Drops, Batters Frankie Gavin for Knockout in Eight Craig Cunningham Drops, Shocks Anthony Ogogo For TKO Win Kal Yafai Wins, Faces Luis Concepcion on 12/10 in Manchester Sean Davis Edges Paul Economides For WBC Regional Title Hisashi Amagasa Wins Ten Round Decision Over Carlo Demecilo David Price: I Can Knock Joshua Out, Dropped Him Bad in Sparring Lemieux's Manager Confident Canelo Fight Can Be Made For May Luis Nery Looks To Take His Career To Next Level in Tijuana

Latest Active Forum Threads