3 Steps to Identify Supplements that Lack Scientific Evidence

You read about a supplement that allegedly "Boosts your mood and motivation!" That sure sounds good so your surf over to the company's web site.

The web site looks official--it's even got footnotes citing scientific journals. You're ready to purchase the supplement online until you ask yourself, "What if this supplement doesn't really possess any scientific evidence for its efficacy? How can I tell the difference between supplements with solid evidence for their reported benefits versus those lacking any scientific support?"

Here are the 3 Steps to answer those questions:

Step 1: Go to

http://www.pubmed.org

which is a National Library of Medicine (United States) web site where you can search for articles published in peer-reviewed scientific journals.

Why check PubMed? Because the National Library of Medicine carefully selects only high-quality journals that offer value to medical scientists around the world. Selection criteria are detailed on this web page:

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/jsel.html

Step 2: Once on the PubMed web site, search for research articles using the generic (scientific) name of the supplement in question. Supplementmanufacturers must list the scientific name for their supplement's ingredients on thelabel and in advertisements. Supplements often contain many ingredients but usually only a few provide thepurported benefits. Those are the ingredients you want to evaluate--they are often the same ones the manufacturer highlights in advertisements.

Step 3: This is the step some supplementcompanies don't want you to know. Before you click on the "Search" button at PubMed.org, limit your search to studies that utilize the right research methodology with the right population.

The right research methodology is a randomized controlled trial (the double-blind, placebo control group design fits under this category) and the right population is human beings.

Specifying human subjects is important because you want to know if the ingredients in a supplement have been shown to produce the advertised benefits in real live human beings--not just in rats pressing levers for food pellets or in a "case study" with one person.

This is not to say that basic science research, which is often conducted initially with animals, is unimportant. On the contrary, such research usually serves as a crucial building block for subsequent clinicalresearch with humans. But basic science research does not provide scientific evidence for a supplement's beneficial health effects on human beings. Only research with human subjects, using randomized controlled trials, can offer such evidence.

On the PubMed.org search page, click on the "Limits" tab located under the "Search" box. You will see a number of drop-down menus. First click on the Publication Type menu and then select Randomized Controlled Trial. Next click on the drop-down menu labeled, Humans or Animals and click on Humans.

An Example
Morinda citrifolia is the scientific name for a popular ingredient in a nutritional supplement. First search on PubMed for Morinda citrifolia, without placing Limits on your search.

How many results did you receive?

The count was 69 at the time I wrote this article. Looks impressive, huh?

But now search for Morinda citrifolia after first placing Limits on the search as described above, so that you receive only those studies which provide more definitive scientific evidence for the positive effects ofMorinda citrifolia.

How many journal articles did you find searching with the specified limits? I found 1.

Thus, out of 69 articles found on PubMed.org, only one provides some evidence forMorinda citrifolia's beneficial effects.

It's great that this study exists because it could end up being one of several studies demonstrating that Morinda citrifolia provides health benefits. However, at the present time, the most one could say about Morinda citrifolia is something like, "One study has provided very preliminary evidence of Morinda citrifolia's health benefits with a narrowly defined patient group. Further controlled trials are needed to determine if this result will be replicated by other research groups working with different populations."

Conclusion
By using the "Limits" funtion on the PubMed.org search menu, consumers can identify supplements that lack scientific evidence for their efficacy.

Mark Worthen, Psy.D. is a Phi Betta Kappa graduate of the University of Maryland's Honors Psychology program. He was a Clinical Fellow, Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School and earned his Doctor of Psychology degree from Baylor University in 1990. In addition to his work as a psychologist, he earns extra income via Internet and network marketing.

Use the Contact page on Omega-3-Report.com to reach Dr. Worthen.

Dietary Supplement Maker Doctor's Best, Inc., Appoints Dr. Parris M. Kidd as ... EON: Enhanced Online News (press release) (EON: Enhanced Online News)--Doctor's Best, Inc., a leading manufacturer and distributor of clinically-formulated dietary supplements, announced that dietary supplement industry researcher, product developer and educator Parris M. Kidd, PhD. has been ... and more »

Choose your supplements with care Vancouver Sun Supplements are an excellent way to bolster our diets and provide hard-to-find nutrients that our bodies need. But as Peter Jones, director of the Richardson Centre for Functional Foods and Nutraceuticals at the University of Manitoba, explains, ... and more »

Baltimore Sun

Soy Isoflavone Supplementation Not Effective In Breast Cancer Protection Medical News Today A study published in Cancer Prevention Research, a journal of the American Association for Cancer Research, reveals that breast cancer cell proliferation was not lowered with soy isoflavone supplements in a randomized human trial. Soy pills not helpful for breast cancer prevention, study saysLos Angeles Times Soy supplements may not protect against breast cancerHealthJockey.com Soy Isoflavones Don't Reduce Breast Epithelial ProliferationDoctors Lounge all 9 news articles »

Rough Draft: Dietary Supplement Industry Arguments Against FDA's NDI Draft ... Nutritional Outlook By Jennifer Grebow February 8, 2012 0 Comments Saying that the dietary supplements industry is unsatisfied with FDA's new dietary ingredient (NDI) draft guidance is an understatement. "Atrium Innovations firmly believes in the intended principle ... and more »

Life Extension Rated Number One by Dietary Supplement Consumers in Four ... Sacramento Bee 8, 2012 -- /PRNewswire/ -- Life Extension, offering superior-quality dietary supplements to consumers and a pioneer in funding and reporting the latest anti-aging research and integrative health therapies, has been rated number one in four categories ... and more »

PR Web (press release)

The A-C of vitamins FemaleFirst.co.uk Nobody should take more than 1.5mg a day of vitamin A, and there is no group of adults who need supplements if they have a reasonable diet including eggs, dairy products or oily fish. In fact, taking too much is a more common risk than too little, ... Have a Question About Vitamins? Ask Your PharmacistMarketWatch (press release) All Natural Whole Food Vitamin Supplement Now Available From Nutrition Company ...PR Web (press release) What Vitamin Overdose Can Do To You?BoldSky all 7 news articles »

Fluoride Supplementation: The Ongoing Debate Medscape Berbel P, Obregón MJ, Bernal J, Escobar del Rey F, Morreale de Escobar G. Iodine supplementation during pregnancy: a public health challenge. Trends Endocrinol Metab.2007;18:338-343. Abstract Heindel JJ, Bates HK, Price CJ, Marr MC, Myers CB, ... and more »

TopNews United States

Diet supplements recalled on unlabeled drug worries Reuters WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Healthy People Co is recalling 15 lots of seven different dietary supplements because they contain appetite suppressants or a drug for male erectile dysfunction, the Long Beach, California, company said. Dietary Supplements Extensively Regulated, Say Authors of New ArticleSacramento Bee Dietary Supplement Recalled After Found to Contain Drug IngredientsThirdAge Are Supplements Safe?Ivanhoe TopNews United States all 33 news articles »

Daily Mail

Zinc supplements 'can reduce child pneumonia death rate' Nursing Times Young children with pneumonia should be prescribed zinc supplements to substantially reduce their risk of dying, a study suggests. Scientists in Uganda, where zinc deficiency is an acute problem, carried out a study on 352 children who had severe ... Zinc supplements 'can triple the survival chances of young children with ...Daily Mail Zinc supplements 'can aid survival from respiratory tract infection'Zenopa Zinc supplements 'may slash death risk among kids with pneumonia'TruthDive TIME -Huffington Post UK all 22 news articles »

Nutritional Outlook

Dietary Supplements and the Food Safety Modernization Act: Today and Tomorrow Nutritional Outlook It requires FDA to implement a sweeping array of new regulations and enforcement policies, intended to better ensure the safety of food products marketed in the United States, including dietary supplements. FSMA has far-reaching implications for ... and more »