Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Shawn Porter-Kell Brook: Pre-Fight Report Card

By Cliff Rold

This has been awhile in coming.

Kell Brook could have had a shot at a major belt before this weekend.  He bided his time.  A fight with Devon Alexander didn’t come to pass.  Will he wish it had?

It’s certainly looking like a fun question. 

And it’s at Stub Hub.

As fans in Southern California have learned, fights just tend to break out in that particular outdoor arena.  Even without the locale, this looks the part.  Brook and Porter have both been in crowd pleasers before.

Both in the flush of youth and prime, how can this miss?

Let’s go the report card.

The Ledgers

Shawn Porter
Age: 26
Title: IBF Welterweight (2013-Present, 1 Defense)
Previous Titles: None
Height: 5’7
Weight: 146.75 lbs.
Hails from: Akron, Ohio
Record: 24-0-1, 15 KO

Record in Major Title Fights: 2-0, 1 KO
Rankings: #4 (Shawn Porter), #5 (BoxingScene), #6 (TBRB, ESPN, BoxRec)
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Faced: 3 (Julio Diaz D10, UD10; Devon Alexander UD12; Paulie Malignaggi TKO4)

Vs.

Kell Brook
Age: 26
Title/ Previous Titles: None
Height: 5’9
Weight: 146.5 lbs.
Hails from: Sheffield, Yorkshire, UK
Record: 32-0, 22 KO

Record in Major Title Fights: 1st Major Title Fight
Rankings: #5 (Ring), #7 (BoxRec), #9 (BoxingScene, TBRB)
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Faced: 2 (Lovemore N’Dou UD12; Vyacheslav Senchenko TKO4)

Grades

Pre-Fight: Speed – Porter B+; Brook B+
Pre-Fight: Power – Porter B; Brook B
Pre-Fight: Defense – Porter B; Brook B
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Porter B+; Brook B+

One of the fun parts of this fight is how much more we still have to learn about both men.  They’ve been matched well so far to get to this point.  Porter’s best foes are better than Brook’s so far but it’s not an exponential difference.  They are evenly matched in terms of hand speed and power.  The delivery of those factors is in contrast.

Brook fights tall, sometimes leaving his chin too exposed.  He operates off a quick, long jab and moves his head well.  He’s been buzzed, hurt by Carson Jones in their first fight and stunned by Senchenko in the fourth round of their fight.

To Brook’s credit, he responded by stopping Senchenko before the round was out.  Against Jones, he went too war and scored the stop in the rematch.  Brook has shown ring character.  He’s also shown he’s in tough if he can’t keep the action at the pace he likes.

Porter is going to force a pace.  Showing improvement since the draw with the faded former Lightweight titlist Diaz, Porter beat Alexander and Malignaggi with a vicious pressure game.  He goes to the body and stays on top of foes.  He’s not shown himself a massive puncher, but what he lacks there he makes up in another facet of his game.

Porter is bull strong.  An amateur Middleweight, he’s a hard man to keep off lately at Welterweight.  Brook will likely be a sterner physical test than those men.  He’s not a longtime Jr. Welterweight and has fought as high as Middleweight.  As good as Porter has looked in his last two starts, he’s not that far removed from the Diaz struggle.  He’s not proven yet. 

Brook could be a bit of a proving ground.  If he can make Porter miss, and counter, his greater height (he looks even more than the listed two inches taller) is going to be a factor.  Can he make Porter rush and get sloppy? 

If Porter can take that jab away, Brook will be open on the inside.  Can Brook stay off the ropes where that will be most dangerous?

Could this be a night where both men get what they want just enough to trade rounds and make a memorable fight?        

The Pick

Bet yes on that last question and don’t be surprised if there is debate at the end.  A foreign-based fighter on US soil against a US fighter advised by Al Haymon?  Brook is a serious threat to Porter but it’s hard to shake the feeling that, on the road, he'll be hard pressed to get the decision no matter what happens in the ring.  That’s if it’s close.  It may not be.  Porter seems to have hit his stride as a pressing brawler/boxer, and it’s difficult to shake the image of Brook struggling with Carson Jones.  The physicality of Porter should be enough to get the decision in a fan friendly affair.

Report Card Picks 2014: 33-15

Cliff’s Notes…

More picks…Before Showtime comes to air, the action will be Cruiserweight in Germany…Former titlist Firat Arslan (34-7-2, 21 KO) had a nice last hurrah in his first fight with Marco Huck.  Many thought he deserved the nod.  That was in 2012 and he didn’t make it the distance in the return.  At 43, Arslan is in deep against IBF titlist Yoan Pablo Hernandez (28-1, 14 KO).  Look for Hernandez to score an emphatic decision if not a stoppage in the second half of the fight…On the Porter-Brook undercard, the possible fight of the night pits WBC Lightweight titlist Omar Figueroa (23-0-1, 17 KO) against veteran Daniel Estrada (32-2-1, 24 KO).  Figueroa’s style is already logging miles and he looked average against Jerry Belmontes, a fight he may have deserved to lose. Figueroa is defensively deficient and just feels like a loss waiting to happen.  Estrada seems like the sort of hard-nose, contender to take advantage.  The pick is Estrada by stoppage in the upset…In a rematch, Anthony Dirrell (26-0-1, 22 KO) had to have learned from his first crack against rugged WBC Super Middleweight titlist Sakio Bika (32-5-3, 21 KO).  There won’t be a draw this time around.  Dirrell by decision.

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene and a member of the Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by crold1 on 08-16-2014

[QUOTE=LacedUp;14859884]You wish to give a fighter with a 60% KO ratio more than B+? Wtf. Rold is being nice on Porter's power. I definintely feel Brook has the more power, but then again he's being nice on Brook in terms…

Comment by LacedUp on 08-16-2014

[QUOTE=teddycanyon;14859873]Wow Boxingscene has these guys matching up pretty evenly. I think they 're selling Porter short, he's going to prove he's more than a B+ in power. On a side note , why does my phone keep logging me off…

Comment by teddycanyon on 08-16-2014

Wow Boxingscene has these guys matching up pretty evenly. I think they 're selling Porter short, he's going to prove he's more than a B+ in power. On a side note , why does my phone keep logging me off…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (3)
Top Headlines Memo: Chavez Jr. Will Be Stronger, No Weight Issues For Canelo Thurman-Garcia: Narvaez vs. Rodriguez Clash is Eyed For Card Rob Brant Stops Alexis Hloros in First at Grand Casino in Hinckley Canelo vs. Chavez is a Fight Boxing Needed, Says De La Hoya David Haye: Chris Eubank Jr. is a Force, He Will Go All The Way Canelo vs. Chavez: Positive Talks Ongoing With MGM, Jerry Jones Conlan Hopes For 'Dream Fight' With Carl Frampton in The Future Top Rank Prez Eyes Deontay Wilder vs. Joseph Parker Unification Jacobs: Most Guys are Beaten Mentally When They Face Golovkin Frampton Expects Rematch With Leo Santa Cruz To Be Easier Tomoki Kameda Returns To Japan on March 10, Faces Tawatchai Carl Greaves Looks Back On 2016, Is Excited About 2017 Jermell Charlo, Gary Russell Mandatory Double Eyed For March 11 De La Hoya: Canelo Beating Chavez Jr. Will Not Satisfy The Critics Cedric Vitu Retains EBU Title, Decisions Isaac Real in Levallois Horn Warns Pacquiao, Top Rank Not To Look Beyond April Fight Angel Garcia, Mayweather Tarnished What Should've Been Good Week for Boxing WBA Champ Ortiz Wins Decision Over Ramos in Mexico City Robert Garcia: Canelo Has A lot More To Lose in Chavez Jr. Bout Hairon Socarras Training Hard in Miami For February 3 Return Zab Judah Returns, Blasts Out Munguia in Two Rounds Jose Pedraza Confident That He Will Return Strong at Lightweight Javier Fortuna Ready - Targets Sosa, Corrales, Lomachenko Alvarez vs. Chavez Rematch is Being Planned For March 11 Miguel Cotto: Juan Manuel Marquez Fight is Very Viable Bradley Pryce Announces Retirement After Defeat Robbie Davies Jr. Crushes Zoltan Szabo, Retains WBA Regional Patrick Nielsen, Dina Thorslund Win Decisions, Khattab Shocked Bellew: 'Ego Maniac' David Haye Better Hope He Ends Me in Four Beterbiev: Barrera Proved To Be a Real Fighter, He Agreed To Fight Luis Cruz Admits He Was Close To Retirement Before Easter Shot Mundine: When I Beat Danny Green - Call Me Black Houdini! Frank Warren: Liam Walsh Ready, He Can Beat Gervonta Davis! Frampton Expects Another Fan Friendly Fight Against Santa Cruz Curtis Stevens Sure Hand Injury Fully Healed for Lemieux Fight Garcia, 2-1 Underdog vs. Thurman: 'I Guess Vegas Don’t Like Me' Frank Warren on The James DeGale vs. Badou Jack Outcome Early Results Are In: BoxingScene Ratings Update Linares vs. Crolla II Card - Tomi Tatham To Face Liam Conroy Lewis Crocker To Make Pro Debut on February 18th in Belfast
Advertisement
Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement