Advertisement
Advertisement

Robert Garcia Feels CJ Ross Should Be Investigated

By Ronnie Nathanielsz

2012 “Trainer of the Year” Robert Garcia wants judge CJ Ross investigated for her inexplicable 114-114 scorecard in the Floyd Mayweather Jr- Saul “Canelo” Alvarez title fight at the MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas last Saturday.

Garcia told BoxingScene.com/Manila Standard that he personally believes Mayweather “won every single round but some people said Canelo may have won one or two rounds at the most” which is a view shared by Manny Pacquiao’s adviser Michael Koncz who recalled that Ross was the same female judge who raised a howl of protest around the world after she scored the Timothy Bradley-Pacquiao fight for Bradley.

With reports indicating that a number of fight fans had bet on a unanimous decision win by Mayweather and bookmakers made a small killing because of the majority decision caused by Ross’ scorecard, there are growing demands for an investigation.

Garcia told us “they got to do something about it. They need to investigate.”

Top Rank promoter Bob Arum had also demanded an investigation after the Pacquiao loss to Bradley but Nevada State Athletic Commission executive director Keith Kizer not only stood by Ross but has since defended her ridiculous scorecard in the Mayweaher-Alvarez fight incurring the ire of some fight fans and media who want Kizer himself investigated.

The Las Vegas Review Journal has quoted NSAC chairman Bill Brady as saying he is willing to “accept the blame” for not fighting Ross’ nomination by Kizer.

Brady added he “let the public down” after Ross, only a year removed from joining judge Duane Ford in giving hobbled Timothy Bradley a victory by split-decision over Pacquiao.
Brady told the Las Vegas Review Journal “I can guarantee there will be some changes. We have to protect the fighters, the viewing public and the betting public. We’re going to look at our vetting process. It needs to be more thorough. We have to get this right.”

Respected Los Angeles Times columnist Bill Dwyre said “Fans swarmed to bet on the “draw” proposition, dropping the odds from 30 to 1 to 8 to 1 on the theory that judges would alter the outcome to ensure a highly profitable rematch between the then-unbeaten fighters.”

Ross defended her scoring and said she had no problems with it although Kizer took a dig at Arum and Pacquiao supporters before Saturday’s title fight claiming that complaints about Ross’ work in the Pacquiao fight from reporters was coming from Pacquiao loyalists and cracked that if those writers didn’t object they feared they wouldn’t be credentialed to the next fight promoted by Pacquiao’s promoter Bob Arum.

Pugmire said Cynthia Ross “not only has botched fights with Mayweather and Pacquiao, she has been alone in other fights, which a review of the record-keeping website boxrec.com shows.”

He listed some instances:

Nov. 12, 2011: Scores Juan Carlos Burgos-Luis Cruz, 95-95, when Ford has it 98-92 and Ricardo Ocasio scores it 97-93 for Burgos.

August 13, 2011: Scores Abner Mares-Joseph Agbeko, 113-113, when Adalaide Byrd and Oren Shellenberger have it 115-111 each for Mares.

Feb. 7, 2008: Has Kendall Holt-Ben Tackie a 95-95 draw when Paul Smith and Richard Houck score it 98-92 for Holt.

She also scored two other one-sided bouts in 2011 draws.

Tags: Robert Garcia image   boxing image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by TLC8 on 09-18-2013

You don't keep missing a fight as bad as these fights mentioned, in comparison to the other two judges... Either something is up, or she's just that bad and should be removed. Interesting how she needed a leave of absence…

Comment by cameltoe on 09-18-2013

[QUOTE=TheMexHurricane;13761607]F*ck if I know or care. The only thing I know or care about is that it's time for Mexicans to start taking steroids like Pacroid and Donaire and start bribing judges because we're being cheated in championship fights and…

Comment by Joe Grizzley on 09-18-2013

Nobody is talking about her Lara vs Molina score. Molina got robbed and the record should note it.

Comment by Luilun on 09-18-2013

[QUOTE=Gary Coleman;13761898]Reading is fundamental. At best [B][I]for Bradley[/I][/B]. The argument can be made that Bradley won rounds 1-2 and 9-12. Maybe you should re-watch the fight.[/QUOTE] Yea I watched and I gave Bradley 2 rounds and 3 at best. So…

Comment by littlemac on 09-18-2013

[QUOTE=LAPete;13761951]Mexicans don't need steroids...they are some of the TOUGHEST Fighters on the planet.[/QUOTE] Exactly. Let the pu$$ies like Manny rely on corrupt judges and peds. We all know Marquez schooled Manny all three times not including him putting the hype…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (34)
Top Headlines Frank Warren To Hearn: Joshua is Number 1? Let Him Prove It! Daily Bread Mailbag: Danny Garcia, Lomachenko, Thurman, More Semajay Thomas Embraces How Boxing Changed His Life Yodmongkol Vor Saengthep Easily Stops Outmatched Opponent Parker: Soon Joshua's Confidence Will Be Tested Against Me Golovkin's Coach: We Never Asked Andre Ward For 164 Weight George Groves Entering Last-Chance Saloon Against Murray LaRon Mitchell Stops Epifanio Mendoza in Three Rounds Keith Thurman-Shawn Porter: Pre-Fight Report Card Ricardo Rodriguez Beats David Quijano in Boxeo Telemundo Canelo's Manager Taking Smith Serious, Expects Dangerous Fight Photos: Vargas Rubs Shoulders With Mayweather at BWAA Awards Canelo's Manager To Critics: We're Back To Our Natural Weight! Kenny Porter Not Concerned With Layoff as Thurman Shot Nears Arum: Thurman-Porter is Good Fight, Hope it Gets Good Rating Thurman Reflects on His Long Journey, Lessons Along The Way Video: Jessie Vargas Talks Kell Brook, Thurman vs. Porter Photos/Weights: PBC on NBCSN - Justin DeLoach-Junior Castillo Photos: Mike Alvarado vs. Josh Torres, Korobov-Vera Weighin DiBella Breaks Down Thurman-Porter, Isn't Sure Who Wins Povetkin, Ryabinsky To Hold Meeting With WBC Next Week Liam Smith: I Will Shake Up The World When I Beat Canelo Groves Explains His Version of Events in Golovkin Sparring Tale Photos: Keith Thurman, Shawn Porter Ready For Barclays War Weights from Brooklyn: Porter Strips to 147, Thurman at 146 Liam Smith vs. Canelo Alvarez - Fight Poster Revealed Canelo Alvarez vs. Liam Smith Finalized at 154, 9/17 on PPV Fury To Klitschko: I'm Hitler? You Stupid F***ing Ukrainian Pr*ck! Golden Boy VP Reacts To Arum, Insists Pacquiao vs. Broner is On! Video: Sky Sports Crew Discuss Klitschko vs. Fury Postponement Video: Joshua-Breazeale, Groves-Murray, Eubank-Doran Weighin Jason Sosa Drills Javier Fortuna in Eleventh, Grabs WBA Title Eubank Jr: I Didn't Want To Take Off Underwear, Scare Everyone Photos: Anthony Joshua, Dominic Breazeale Ready For Battle Felix Diaz-Levan Ghvamichava Tops PBC on FS1, July 12 Photo: Tyson Fury's Badly Bruised, Sprained Ankle Injury Felix Verdejo-Jose Felix Likely For October - If Pacquiao Returns Fury Rolls Ankle, July 9 Klitschko Rematch Postponed Thurman Warns: Stop Protecting Your Record Like Mayweather! Arum: Golovkin vs. Ramirez, We Have Deal in Principle For 2017
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement