Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Pinol Files Formal Complaint at Dapudong Fight Judge

by Ronnie Nathanielsz

Fiery former North Cotabato governor Manny Pinol who manages super flyweight Edrin “The Sting” Dapudong has filed a formal complaint with IBO president Ed Levine over the scoring of American judge Michael Pernick in the title fight between Dapudong and South Africa’s Gideon Buthelezi in Johannesburg, South Africa last November 10.

Pinol accused Pernick of “abusing his discretionary authority in scoring the fight, especially round 9 when Dapudong scored a knockdown which Pernick scored 10-9 while British judge Reg Thompson and even South African judge Tony Nyangiwe who was obviously biased in favor of Buthelezi scored it 10-8.”

Pinol said that when he confronted Pernick the morning after the fight over what he described as “ his questionable scoring not only of Round 9 but also of the first three rounds which were clearly won by Dapudong as reflected in the scorecards of Judge Thompson” the judge “arrogantly bragged that he had judged over 60 world championship fights, including the fight of Manny Pacquiao against Ricky Hatton, as if to insinuate that this gives him the license to score the fight as he wishes.”

For the record Pacquiao separated Hatton from his senses in two rounds and there was no need for scorecards.

Pinol quoted Pernick as telling him "That's how I saw the round" which he arrogantly declared in front of the IBO vice president for South Africa, Len Hunt, and Judge Thompson.

Pinol said that “many spectators of that 12-round fight at the Emperor's Palace in Johannesburg were convinced that the Filipino was the better fighter.”

The Manila Standard itself quoted South African media reports in its own letter to IBO president Levine as well as promoter Rodney Berman’s Golden Gloves website which made a scathing comment  over the results of the Dapudong-Buthelezi  fight.

The promoters said  “Bleeding from the nose and badly bruised around the left eye, Buthelezi took a beating. But he got lucky with the judges.” Golden Gloves said "It was rough justice on Dapudong, who was the sharper and busier of the two fighters. Little wonder he looked perplexed and distraught when the scorecards were announced.”

The boxing website added "Dapudong must have thought he had the fight in the bag when he delivered a flash nine-count knockdown on Buthelezi in the ninth round.”

In view of the facts mentioned Pinol sought formal action from the IBO:

1. An immediate review of the video recorded fight between Dapudong and Buthelezi to be conducted by an impartial panel of respected boxing judges. I believe that had Pernick correctly scored the first three rounds where he gave the second round to Buthelezi even while the South African fighter was flailing on the ropes and badly punished, and had he correctly scored the knockdown in the 9th, Dapudong would have won the fight in his scorecard 114-113 and he could won the title.

2. The immediate suspension of Mr. Pernick as an IBO sanctioned boxing judge pending the results of the review of the video recording of the fight.

3. Should the IBO review panel conclude that the judging in the Dapudong-Buthelezi fight was irregular, that an order for a rematch be issued by the boxing body which Pinol said he has considered “as one of the more respectable boxing organizations and an admirer of your computerized ranking program. I believe that your immediate action on this formal complaint would prove to us who work hard to help young boys achieve their dreams in the sport that the IBO represents what is right and what is just in the sport.”

Dapudong’s manager also commended Golden Gloves Boxing Promotions of South Africa “ for the kind attention that we were given during our stay and the excellent preparations they made for the world title fight. I also believe that the actions of Mr. Pernick do not necessarily mean that the promoters were a party to his act of injustice. I also would like to commend your Africa Vice President Len Hunt for his professionalism and for encouraging me to formally write to you to file this complaint.”

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by komandante on 11-13-2012

I totally agree with the act of Mr Piñol to clear boxing of corrupt officials. :boxing:"peeleft:

Comment by nycsmooth on 11-13-2012

Pernick is a florida judge who I understand was very good w/WBO and now prostitutes himself 2 any organization that will pay him, as IBO & IBF...10-8 in a knockdown rnd, must have been some control & domination by the…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (2)
Top Headlines Golovkin's Coach: Ward Fight Impossible - He Couldn't Make 168! Telemundo Weights: Hernandez 122, Dominguez 121 Parker Sees Benefits of Fighting in UK Prior To Joshua Showdown Mike Lee: We've Built Up To This, I'm Ready For It, I'm Excited Bradley: There Are Levels; Vargas Will Find Out Against Pacquiao Billy Joe Saunders vs. Artur Akavov Set For October 22 Adrien Broner vs. Ricky Burns Nearly Finalized For December Roach is Concerned: Pacquiao Looks Tired, Sluggish in Sparring WBC Warns Boxers About Dangers of Consuming Energy Drinks Orlando Cruz: I Won't Rest Until I'm First Gay World Champion! Sanchez: If GGG Breaks Hopkins' Record, Mayweather May Come Chocolatito Drops 112 WBC Belt, Hernandez-Nawaphon Ordered Orlando Salido vs. Takashi Miura Finalized, Dec. 17 on HBO Photos: Mike Lee, Chris Traietti - Ready For Chicago Showdown Jorge Linares Update on Hand Injury, Crolla Rematch Clause Petrov vs. Perez WBA Title Eliminator - Photos, Weights Juanma Lopez vs. Wilfredo Vazquez Pushed Back To Oct. 29 Erick De Leon vs. Aldimar Santos, Oct. 28 on UniMas Eddie Hearn Shakes His Head at Lee Selby's Inactivity Adam Lopez vs. Carlos Valcarcel on November 12 in Philadelphia Photo: Victor Ortiz Mugshot Released For DUI Arrest Callum Smith-Luke Blackledge British Title Clash In Play, Nov. 26 Pacquiao Admits Past Drug Use, Backs Prez's Tough Stance UK News: Kassem vs. Murray, Leather Twins, BoxNation Update Artur Beterbiev vs. Isidro Ranoni Prieto Set For December 23 Calzaghe Backing Cleverly To Unseat Braehmer For The Title Dimitrenko: Parker is Looking Past Me, He's Focused on Joshua Terry Flanagan - In-Depth on Crolla, Verdejo, Return, What's Next WBA Prez: We've Asked "Twice" For Tyson Fury's Medical Report! Mikey Garcia Eyes Dejan Zlaticanin Bout in November, December Frank Warren Reacts To Eddie Hearn: Tyson Fury is NOT Done! Hanzel Martinez Vows To Stop Ruiz Inside The Distance Johnny Nelson: Parker is at The Same Level as Anthony Joshua Golovkin's Coach: Jacobs Beat Cancer, He's Not Scared of GGG Eddie Hearn: Joshua-Klitschko Not Done, Negotiations Ongoing UK News: Skeete vs. Singleton, Liam Williams, Osman, More Cotto Could Be in Line For WBO Shot - When Canelo Goes To 160 Cleverly: Braehmer Fight Has Been Five Years in The Making Wladimir Klitschko vs. Anthony Joshua? Yes, Please. Photo: Canelo Alvarez, With Splint, is Back To Putting in Work
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement