Paulie Malignaggi-Adrien Broner: Pre-Fight Report Card

by Cliff Rold

The cultivation of a star can develop many different ways.  Supporting casts play a big part.  To date, Adrien Broner has built nicely in a down period for both the Jr. Lightweight and Lightweight classes.  A decade ago, those were the domains of Joel Casamayor, Acelino Freitas, Diego Corrales, Jose Luis Castillo, and a young Floyd Mayweather.

Broner won belts against Vicente Rodriguez and Antonio DeMarco. 

While Rodriguez was the sort of anonymous pick-a-foe that often gets matched with developing names for vacant straps, DeMarco was regarded as possibly the tops of the Lightweight class.  Broner can’t fight ghosts of yesteryear and, given his youth and number of fights, he’s actually been developed fairly well, and wisely, to the point he’s at today. 

Much like Canelo Alvarez a year ago, Broner is on the cusp of facing the opponents who can begin to define him.  140 lbs. is absurdly loaded.  147 lbs. is top heavy, but the ceiling is strong and there is room to absorb the best of the class below.  Broner has a good solid veteran on tap this weekend to get his feet wet in one of history’s great classes. 

Can the veteran prove the ingénue is still wet behind the ears? 

Let’s go to the report cards.

The Ledgers

Paulie Malignaggi

Title: WBA Welterweight (2012-Present, 1 Defense)
Previous Titles: IBF Light Welterweight (2007-08, 2 Defenses)
Height: 5’8 ½
Weight: 146.4 lbs.

Average Weight – Last Five Fights: 147.05 lbs.

Hails from: Brooklyn, New York
Record: 32-4, 7 KO, 2 KOBY
Rankings: #4 (Ring), #5 (ESPN), #8 (BoxingScene), #10 (TBRB)
Record in Major Title Fights: 5-3, 1 KO, 2 KOBY
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Defeated: 6 (Miguel Cotto L12; Lovemore N’Dou UD12, SD12; Ricky Hatton TKO by 11; Juan Diaz L12, UD12; Amir Khan TKO by 11; Vyacheslav Senchenko TKO9)


Adrien Broner

Age: 23
Title: WBC Lightweight (2012-Present, 1 Defense)
Previous Titles: WBO Super Featherweight (2011-Present, 1 Defense)
Height: 5’7
Weight: 146.8 lbs.

Average Weight – Last Five Fights: 132.1 lbs.
Hails from: Cincinnati, Ohio
Record: 26-0, 22 KO
Rankings (at 135): #1 (TBRB, Boxingscene, ESPN, BoxRec, Ring)
Record in Major Title Fights: 4-0, 4 KO
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Defeated: 3 (Daniel Ponce De Leon UD10; Antonio DeMarco TKO8; Gavin Rees RTD5)

Pre-Fight: Speed – Malignaggi B+; Broner A
Pre-Fight: Power – Malignaggi C-; Broner A
Pre-Fight: Defense – Malignaggi B; Broner B
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Malignaggi B+; Broner A

To his credit, Malignaggi’s two finest performances came in title winning efforts.  Defeating N’Dou for his first strap at 140 and Senchenko at 147, Malignaggi showed off why he has been so hard on all but the elite.  He’s also shown tremendous heart in his three real losses (his loss in the first fight with Juan Diaz is largely held in disregard), battling through tremendous punishment and never really quitting. 

Both of his stoppage losses were about saving him from himself.

Broner is coming up two weight divisions for this fight.  Does that mean Malignaggi, who often appears to bring knives to gunfights, finally has the heavy artillery?

Let’s not get carried away.  Anyone who saw the weigh-in Friday saw a Broner who looks like what he’s been inside the ring for a while now.  Sure, he’s been making lower weights on Friday, but he’s been a Welterweight on Saturday’s for a minute.  In that sense, Broner is finally where his body more naturally belongs and at a point where his game seems to have sharpened.

While his defense is still a work in progress, and probably his most overrated asset, Broner showed against DeMarco and Gavin Rees just how potent his offense can be.  Unlike both those foes, Malignaggi won’t be the sort of compliant, stationary pocket targets those two were.

That could make this fight a stinker in spots.  Malignaggi does everything off the jab and he’s willing to use his legs.  He’s not going to lead so Broner will have to hunt.  Broner has no problems coming forward but it may take a few rounds to line a moving target up.   

If he can, Broner is the quicker man, he’ll be the heavier handed man, and it would be no shock if he were the bigger man in the ring either.

The Picks

This fight is some of the best proof available of just how little merit there really is in so many of boxing's belts.  Malignaggi’s win over Senchenko was nice, but Senchenko was regarded as being middle of the pack, at best, at Welterweight and Malignaggi is about the same.  He’s arguably the best fighter Broner has been in the ring with, an example of why many are still reluctant to embrace the Cincinnati native.  Malignaggi has always been a solid pro and he will be again.  If he has the majority of the world with egg on their faces Sunday morning, good for him. 

The feeling though is this is not his show and he is not the better fighter.  Broner, who has shown great potential in two terribly shallow divisions, is taking a very careful step up here against a guy who has never shown power and this has the look of a walk.  Broner’s possible big tests are out there.  They have names like Matthysse, Garcia, and maybe even Mayweather.

Malignaggi is a step in that direction.  The pick is Broner by stoppage sometime before the 11th round.  

Report Card Picks 2013: 26-15

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene and a member of the Transanational Boxing Ratings Board, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by mistermartin on 06-23-2013

[QUOTE=turnedup;13495071]Bullshhhhhhhhhhhhtttttttttttt... GT F OH...118 - 111..Come on son..gtf o was selling us the win by broner from minute one..anyone notice bernards bullshhh score card and how somehow he tightened it up at the end?[/QUOTE] The rds may have been…

Comment by mistermartin on 06-23-2013

Stoppage?? From what I saw Broner didn't carry a great deal of pwr up w/ him. Paulie's faced hardly looked marked after eating 50% of AB's pwr the job done tho. Would like to see him against a formidable…

Comment by turnedup on 06-23-2013

Bullshhhhhhhhhhhhtttttttttttt... GT F OH...118 - 111..Come on son..gtf o was selling us the win by broner from minute one..anyone notice bernards bullshhh score card and how somehow he tightened it up at the end?

Comment by Unknown Champ on 06-22-2013

Broner does not stop the very durable Pauli.

Comment by crold1 on 06-22-2013

[QUOTE=ironalex;13492832]i dont bother penning predictions, i take my predictions to the betting shop :) 21-16 isnt exactly fountain of knowledge material didnt u pick dawson over stevenson also? - guess you didnt get the memo chad was shot i noticed…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (26)
Top Headlines Tim Bradley: I Need To Retire A Winner, Capture One More Title Eric Molina: I'll Fight Anthony Joshua or David Price on Dec. 10 Canelo: It Would Be an Honor To Rematch Miguel Cotto Kevin Lerena Confident of Knocking Micki Nielsen Out Dejan Zlaticanin: I'm Fighting Mikey Garcia on January 28 Custio Clayton Stops Ramses Agaton in Eight Rounds in Montreal WBO Prez To Canelo Critics: Why Did Golovkin Reject Andre Ward! Terence Crawford Seeks Foe For 12/10, Antonio Orozco Next? Chavez Sr. Expects His Son To Return Stronger, Better Than Ever Jessie Magdaleno, Oscar Valdez Discuss Their PPV Fights Golovkin, Sanchez Frown at Golden Boy's Offer To Face Canelo Charlo-Williams, Cuellar-Mares, Promoted By Schaefer, on Dec. 10 Photos: LaRon Mitchell, Scott Alexander Ready For Battle Photos: Valdez, Magdaleno Putting in Work For PPV Fights Golovkin's Promoter Willing To Make Concessions To Get Canelo David Price: If I Land Joshua, I'm Going in There To Do Damage WBO Prez: No Doubt Canelo Knocks Mayweather Out in Rematch! Orlando Salido's Adviser Provides Update on Back Injury Abel Sanchez Has High Expectations For Alex Saucedo Photos: Gennady Golovkin is a Big Hit in Mexico City Parker-Ruiz Approved For WBO Belt, Winner Must Face David Haye Sam Soliman Over The Moon With Court Victory in Germany Coyle-Hibbert, Scarpa-Davies, Bellotti Set For Nov 26 at Wembley Hearn Frustrated: Klitschko-Browne is Huge Letdown For Fans! Carl Frampton Says Rematch Deal Finalized With Leo Santa Cruz Chilemba Training With Roy Jones Jr. For Oleksandr Gvozdyk Alberto Palmetta, Olympian, Inks With Sampson, Maravilla Photos: Frankie Gavin, Sam Eggington Square Up at FInal Presser Abel Sanchez: Golovkin Can Be Nice, Gassiev Wants To Hurt You! Tony Thompson: That ‘Fool’ Dillian Whyte Is C-Level, Easy Work Roberto Duran: Canelo Alvarez Will Beat Gennady Golovkin! Magdaleno: I Want To Send Nonito Donaire Into Retirement Hooker: 140 is a Tough Division, Terence Crawford is Top Dog David Price Willing To Replace Klitschko, Fight Anthony Joshua Hearn: I Think Klitschko Might Be Looking For Easier Fight Micki Nielsen-Kevin Lerena: Muller Breaks Down The Fight Jeff Horn, Rico Mueller on Weight - Both Promise To Win Big Canelo Says Saunders, Golovkin Both on The Agenda for 2017 Robert Helenius, Sauerland Settle Dispute - Will Work Together HBO and The Good Ol' Days Mythology

Latest Active Forum Threads