Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara Judges Remain Suspended

by Keith Idec

The scorecards submitted by judges John Stewart and Craig Metcalfe weren’t reflective of how easily Andre Ward won his fight against Carl Froch on Dec. 17 in Atlantic City.

New Jersey’s Stewart and Canada’s Metcalfe credited Ward with a 115-113 win in a fight the WBA/WBC super middleweight champion seemingly won at least 117-111 at Boardwalk Hall. John Keane, a British judge, actually had Ward ahead by the largest margin, 118-110, at the conclusion of a 12-round fight that also was the championship match of Showtime’s “Super Six World Boxing Classic.”

Of course, the judging performances of Stewart and Metcalfe were far from the worst in Atlantic City this year.

Scoring of the Paul Williams-Erislandy Lara fight was so bad, the three judges remain suspended by New Jersey’s State Athletic Control Board. SACB commissioner Aaron Davis suspended Al Bennett, Don Givens and Hilton Whitaker indefinitely July 13 for their inexplicable scoring four days earlier at Boardwalk Hall’s Adrian Phillips Ballroom. Bennett scored the 12-round junior middleweight match even (114-114), while Givens (116-114) and Whitaker (115-114) credited Williams with winning a fight he clearly lost.

“They are still suspended,” Davis said. “They’ve been to several training seminars. They all came to the  seminar that I had for all of my officials [in October in Trenton]. And I believe some of them came down to the ABC convention in August that we had down in D.C. They went through some training there, but they’re still in the training process.”

Davis hasn’t decided when he’ll remove Bennett, Givens and Whitaker from the suspended list. He’ll continue to monitor the progress of those three New Jersey residents, but he’ll assign them carefully once he feels they’re ready to work fights again.

“It’s going to be case-by-case,” Davis said. “It’s not like all of them are going to come off suspension at the same time. It’s just whoever I feel is capable of getting back on a card. Of course, we’re going to work them back slowly, with undercard fights and stuff like that. Because I realize that they’re swagger may not be there, and I’ve got to get their confidence back up. They all look like they’re on their way back, so we’ll just see.”

New Jersey’s boxing commissioner hopes his contemporaries aren’t afraid to follow the lead of his unprecedented disciplinary action, especially when it’s so obvious a judge has failed to score a fight appropriately.

“I hope that commissions in other jurisdictions take note that you are in charge of what goes on in boxing,” Davis said. “And somebody has to be accountable. If my people mess up or my people are unprepared, I’ve got to make sure that I reprimand them.

“And I can make them better. It’s not all about ruining a guy’s career and it’s not about making somebody look bad. It’s about people in the sport of boxing knowing that somebody is accountable. And I was accountable for that. This is my way of rectifying it. I hope it won’t happen again.”

Keith Idec covers boxing for The Record and Herald News, of Woodland Park, N.J., and BoxingScene.com.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by jtiger777 on 12-29-2011

paul williams is finished!

Comment by DannYankee on 12-29-2011

This FIght made me Sad Lara Clearly Won and to get the air taken out of him after winning the bigest fight of hes career like that is just rough i wouldnt trust judges ever again o.O

Comment by CubanGuyNYC on 12-29-2011

[QUOTE=`STEELHEAD;11613152]"three judges remain suspended by New Jersey’s State Athletic Control Board. SACB commissioner Aaron Davis suspended Al Bennett, Don Givens and Hilton Whitaker indefinitely July 13. i agree with you yuppie. butt [B][U]consider [U]commissioner Aaron Davis almost a hero[/U] in…

Comment by CubanGuyNYC on 12-29-2011

[QUOTE=hhascup;11610574]I personally know all 3 of the judges, in fact one of them stopped over my house just days after the fight and I asked him about it. He said, that is the way he saw it and the other…

Comment by STEELHEAD on 12-29-2011

[quote=yuppie;11609191]I love all this retraining ish they are going through, when we all know that those judges can score any fight correctly..them mf's got paid to score it to Paul Williams. They should be investigating the promoters and Pauls team.…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (19)
Top Headlines De La Hoya: Chavez Will Not Be Easy For Canelo, It's a Big Concern Danny Roman Stops Adam Lopez in Ninth To Win WBA Eliminator De La Hoya: Donald Trump Refused To Come To Canelo's Fight Wilder Hopes The WBC Comes Down on Alexander Povetkin Stevenson Wants to Face Smith in NY; 4/29 Negotiations Ongoing Errol Spence Stays Ready in The Gym as IBF Scenario Plays Out WBC Reacts To Behavior, Controversial Comments By Angel Garcia Sullivan Barrera Accepts Artur Beterbiev IBF Eliminator WBA President Gives Status on Heavyweights, PED Testing, More Luis Ortiz vs. Jarrell Miller Could Top First Matchroom Card in U.S. Video: Michael Conlan Discusses His Pro Debut in March Joshua Coming To America, as Hearn Begins Build To Wilder Fight Felix Diaz Dares Crawford: Fight a Real Challenge, I'll Go To Omaha! Cotto vs. Kirkland, Lemieux vs. Stevens Land on BoxNation Photos: Anthony Mundine, Tim Tszyu Putting in Work Photos: Haye, Schaefer Hold Presser To Announce Their UK Deal Erislandy Lara-Yuri Foreman Card Generates 547,000 Viewers Photos/Weights: Patrick Nielsen, Dina Thorslund Ready For Bouts David Haye, Richard Schaefer Team Up, Launch Hayemaker Ringstar Froch: Smith is Not Ready For DeGale, Should Face Dirrell First Pedro Diaz on N'Dam's Big KO Win, Golovkin vs. Jacobs, Gamboa Luis Ortiz: Miller Will Have To Back Up The Crap He's Talking Adonis Stevenson: Unfair Haters Call All of My Opponents 'Bums' Danny Garcia: Not Worried About Critics Who Won't Say it to My Face Eubank Jr: In a Rematch I Would Annihilate Saunders in Four! Pacquiao: In The Eyes of The People - I Beat Floyd Mayweather Andrew Selby Faces Diale For WBC Regional on Eubank-Quinlan Wilkins, Karkardi To Appeal BBBofC Bans Over Nick Blackwell Manny Pacquiao: I Would Fight Conor McGregor - Only in Boxing De La Hoya Worried: Chavez Jr. Could Derail Canelo-Golovkin Plan Danny Garcia on Father's Racial Jabs: I've Heard Trump Say Worse! The Return of Zab Judah Ricardo Mayorga Holds Press Conference, Reveals April 1 Return DeGale: Mayweather Came To My Room, I Doubt I'll Work With Him! Cuadras Sides With Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. To Take Down Canelo Canelo-Chavez: Big Promotional Tour on Tap, Big Undercard Plans Photos: David Lemieux, Curtis Stevens - Face To Face in Montreal Chris Eubank Jr: I Can Beat Gennady Golovkin, He's Not The Truth! Photos: Adam Lopez vs. Danny Roman - Official Weigh-in Leo Santa Cruz: I’ll Fight Different Than in First Frampton Bout
Advertisement
Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement