Advertisement
Advertisement

Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara Judges Remain Suspended

by Keith Idec

The scorecards submitted by judges John Stewart and Craig Metcalfe weren’t reflective of how easily Andre Ward won his fight against Carl Froch on Dec. 17 in Atlantic City.

New Jersey’s Stewart and Canada’s Metcalfe credited Ward with a 115-113 win in a fight the WBA/WBC super middleweight champion seemingly won at least 117-111 at Boardwalk Hall. John Keane, a British judge, actually had Ward ahead by the largest margin, 118-110, at the conclusion of a 12-round fight that also was the championship match of Showtime’s “Super Six World Boxing Classic.”

Of course, the judging performances of Stewart and Metcalfe were far from the worst in Atlantic City this year.

Scoring of the Paul Williams-Erislandy Lara fight was so bad, the three judges remain suspended by New Jersey’s State Athletic Control Board. SACB commissioner Aaron Davis suspended Al Bennett, Don Givens and Hilton Whitaker indefinitely July 13 for their inexplicable scoring four days earlier at Boardwalk Hall’s Adrian Phillips Ballroom. Bennett scored the 12-round junior middleweight match even (114-114), while Givens (116-114) and Whitaker (115-114) credited Williams with winning a fight he clearly lost.

“They are still suspended,” Davis said. “They’ve been to several training seminars. They all came to the  seminar that I had for all of my officials [in October in Trenton]. And I believe some of them came down to the ABC convention in August that we had down in D.C. They went through some training there, but they’re still in the training process.”

Davis hasn’t decided when he’ll remove Bennett, Givens and Whitaker from the suspended list. He’ll continue to monitor the progress of those three New Jersey residents, but he’ll assign them carefully once he feels they’re ready to work fights again.

“It’s going to be case-by-case,” Davis said. “It’s not like all of them are going to come off suspension at the same time. It’s just whoever I feel is capable of getting back on a card. Of course, we’re going to work them back slowly, with undercard fights and stuff like that. Because I realize that they’re swagger may not be there, and I’ve got to get their confidence back up. They all look like they’re on their way back, so we’ll just see.”

New Jersey’s boxing commissioner hopes his contemporaries aren’t afraid to follow the lead of his unprecedented disciplinary action, especially when it’s so obvious a judge has failed to score a fight appropriately.

“I hope that commissions in other jurisdictions take note that you are in charge of what goes on in boxing,” Davis said. “And somebody has to be accountable. If my people mess up or my people are unprepared, I’ve got to make sure that I reprimand them.

“And I can make them better. It’s not all about ruining a guy’s career and it’s not about making somebody look bad. It’s about people in the sport of boxing knowing that somebody is accountable. And I was accountable for that. This is my way of rectifying it. I hope it won’t happen again.”

Keith Idec covers boxing for The Record and Herald News, of Woodland Park, N.J., and BoxingScene.com.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by jtiger777 on 12-29-2011

paul williams is finished!

Comment by DannYankee on 12-29-2011

This FIght made me Sad Lara Clearly Won and to get the air taken out of him after winning the bigest fight of hes career like that is just rough i wouldnt trust judges ever again o.O

Comment by CubanGuyNYC on 12-29-2011

[QUOTE=`STEELHEAD;11613152]"three judges remain suspended by New Jersey’s State Athletic Control Board. SACB commissioner Aaron Davis suspended Al Bennett, Don Givens and Hilton Whitaker indefinitely July 13. i agree with you yuppie. butt [B][U]consider [U]commissioner Aaron Davis almost a hero[/U] in…

Comment by CubanGuyNYC on 12-29-2011

[QUOTE=hhascup;11610574]I personally know all 3 of the judges, in fact one of them stopped over my house just days after the fight and I asked him about it. He said, that is the way he saw it and the other…

Comment by STEELHEAD on 12-29-2011

[quote=yuppie;11609191]I love all this retraining ish they are going through, when we all know that those judges can score any fight correctly..them mf's got paid to score it to Paul Williams. They should be investigating the promoters and Pauls team.…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (19)
Top Headlines Jorge Linares Decisions Anthony Crolla, Wins Lightweight Crown Arnfield Shocks Ryder - Wins WBA Regional, Targets British Belt Anthony Crolla vs. Jorge Linares - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Callum Johnson Stops Shihepo, Wins Commonwealth Belt Deontay Wilder: Tyson Fury No Longer Cares About Boxing Klitschko Waits on Word From The Sanctioning Bodies on Fury Crolla vs. Linares - LIVE Fight Results Nihito Arakawa Retains Title, Stops Yusuke Tsukada in Six Rounds Malignaggi Will Not Go For The EBU Title, Withdraws From Spot Anthony Joshua Ready To Replace Tyson Fury, Fight Klitschko! Crolla Plans To Be Calculating, Take The Fight To Linares Early Warren: Won't Take Long For Liam Smith To Get in World Title Mix Parker: Dimitrenko's Height Will Prepare Me For Champions Curtis Stevens: Me And Lemieux Should Fight For Shot at Canelo Teddy Atlas: Golovkin Looked HORRIBLE Against Brook Anthony Crolla Pumped: This is My Kostya Tsyzu Moment! Donnie Nietes Ready To Make Impressive Debut at Flyweight Anthony Crolla vs. Jorge Linares - Tale of The Tape Jarrell Miller: I'd Break Joshua's Face in Half, I'd Run Him Over! Canelo-Golovkin: Promoters Agree To Sit Down in Two Weeks Tommy Morrison's Son: I Opened Some Eyes, Roach Improved Me Anthony Crolla-Jorge Linares: Pre-Fight Report Card Carlos Carlson Gets Off The Deck To Win By Knockout Christopher Diaz, Julian Rodriguez Win: Toka Kahn Clary KO'd Canelo-Smith PPV: Golden Boy Pleased With 300K Buys Radivoje Kalajdzic Drops, Stops Travis Peterkin in Five Rounds Ivan Baranchyk Goes The Distance, Decisions Wang Zhimin Tommy Morrison's Son Demolishes Ed Latimore in One Round Ivan Golub Blasts Out James Stevenson in Three Rounds Rico Ramos vs. Prosper Ankrah at Los Angeles Badminton Club Photos: Donnie Nietes, Edgar Sosa on Weight, Ready For War Gilberto Ramirez To Return in 2017, Says Bob Arum Golovkin vs. Jacobs: Barclays Center Placed on Hold For Dec. 10 Ivan Baranchyk Plans To Put on a Show, Entertain on ShoBox Crawford Pushed Back To 2017, Lomachenko Back on Nov. 26 Tyson Fury is Medically Unfit To Fight, Says His Team in Statement Photos: Jhonny Gonzalez, Hirotsugu Yamamoto Ready For Battle Canelo's Promoter Dares Golovkin: Call Our Bluff, Make The Deal! LaRon Mitchell vs. Scott Alexander Set For October 21 Custio Clayton vs. Ramses Agaton - October 20th in Montreal
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement