Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Ogogo Win Over Khytro Upheld As Ukraine Appeal Denied

By Jake Donovan

An appeal filed by the Ukraine Olympic boxing team on behalf of top-seeded middleweight Ievgen Khytro was denied, the AIBA announced Thursday evening.

The scoring in Khytro’s controversial loss to Great Britain’s Anthony Ogogo was questioned after the hosting nation’s fighter was the recipient of a double-countback win in Round of 16 competition. The two fought to an 18-18 tie in a bout featuring greater ebb-and-flow than any other on the day. A countback was ordered, in which the announced score was even at 52-52.

A final tiebreaker came down to who each individual judge had winning the fight. Each member of the five-person panel was required to press either the “red” or “blue” button, to vote for the winning corner. Three of the five voted in favor of “blue,” which advanced Ogogo to the quarterfinals.

The verdict sent the London crowd into a deafening frenzy, but Khytro and Team Ukraine refused to accept the decision. Scoring posted on the official Olympics website suggested that the bout should have never come down to a second tie-breaker, as the way the scores were displayed lent the appearance of a 53-52 win for Khytro.

Clarification was offered by the AIBA. When scores go to countback, the highest and lowest overall judges’ total for each fighter are thrown out, with the remaining three scores tallied. The way the scores are displayed, viewers were lead to believe it was the highest and lowest scores per round which followed the aforementioned format.

“ In accordance to its full commitment for transparency, the International Boxing Association (AIBA) has decided to take the unusual step of revealing the individual scores of Bout #118 of the London 2012 Olympic Games between Ievgen Khytrov (Ukraine, Red) and Anthony Ogogo (Great Britain, Blue),” the organization announced in a statement.

The five judges’ scores are broken down as shown below, along with a detailed explanation offered from the AIBA.

Individual Score

RED : BLUE

RED : BLUE

RED : BLUE

RED : BLUE

RED : BLUE

ROUND 1

2 : 5

2 : 5

3 : 5

3 : 6

4 : 6

ROUND 2

8 : 6

7 : 5

6 : 4

5 : 6

7 : 8

ROUND 3

10 : 7

8 : 3

5 : 6

7 : 7

11 : 8

SUM

20 : 18

17 : 13

14 : 15

15 : 19

22 : 22

According to Appendix L of AIBA Technical & Competition Rules:

"2.1. Per round, each Individual Score is counted.

2.2. The scores in each round are the average of three Judges' score combination which are the closest together called as Similar Scores.

2.3. For each round, the results of the Individual Scores are calculated separately for the red Boxer and the blue Boxer.

2.4. If at the end of a round more than one Similar Score appears, the Trimmed Mean calculation will apply. The Trimmed Mean is when the highest and lowest Individual Scores are taken out and the average of the remaining three Individual Scores is counted."

 

Selected Scores

RED : BLUE

ROUND 1

3 : 5

ROUND 2

7 : 6

ROUND 3

8 : 7

SUM

18 : 18

According to Appendix L of AIBA Technical & Competition Rules:

"4.2 In case of a tie in the Final Scores:

- 4.2.1. First, delete the lowest and highest Judges' total scores in each red and blue corner. Then, the winner will be determined by the total scores of the remaining three Judges of each red and blue corner.

 

 

RED

BLUE

Judge 1

20

18

Judge 2

17

13

Judge 3

14

15

Judge 4

15

19

Judge 5

22

22

SUM

52

52

 

- 4.2.1. Second, in case of a tie after the above process, all five (5) Judges shall be asked to press the button once for the Boxer who has won. The decision is made by the majority of the panel of these five (5) Judges.

The majority of the five (5) Judges was then in favour of Great Britain Anthony Ogogo."

Agogo will now face Stefan Hardel of Germany in the Middleweight quarterfinals on Monday, August 6.

Khytrov was just the second Ukraine fighter eliminated from competition.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Boxingscene.com. Follow Jake on Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

Tags:
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by D-MiZe on 08-03-2012

Taylor got knocked out by Valentino. I hope the British boxers can come away with a couple of silvers and a couple of bronzes.

Comment by HughJass on 08-03-2012

[QUOTE=GatecrasherUA;12394778]Ukrainians doesn't need gift decisions, that's some overhyped gay brits prerogative, like Ololo.[/QUOTE] yeah your only hope is lomachenko hope he meets josh taylor nd what the **** you going on a bout overhyped gay british **** whats a matter…

Comment by FrankieBruno on 08-02-2012

Khytrov scored two KD's, however the second one was bull because the punch landed on Ogogo's glove and not face He deserved the win...

Comment by steven_z on 08-02-2012

They don't even explain how they got 52-52. You can slide and dice those scores any way you want - Khytrov would be on top. Besides those score are completly inconsistent with what's on the official site: [url]http://www.london2012.com/boxing/event/men-middle-75kg/match=bxm075401/index.html[/url]

Comment by edgarg on 08-02-2012

[QUOTE=JakeNDaBox;12394652]By Jake Donovan - An appeal filed by the Ukraine Olympic boxing team on behalf of top-seeded middleweight Ievgen Khytro was denied, the AIBA announced Thursday evening. The scoring in Khytro’s controversial loss to Great Britain’s Anthony Ogogo was questioned…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (9)
Top Headlines Frank Warren on Haye-Ringstar TV Deal, Signings in The UK Aloyan Gets WBC Belt in Second Pro Fight, Fedor Chudinov Wins Wilder's Manager Concerned That Stiverne Missed His Drug Test Mayweather: I Can't Move Like I Did Before, I'm Going Toe To Toe! Muhammad Ali and Mike Tyson: Roots of a Success Story Jhonny Gonzalez Blasts Rosales in Two, Wants Miguel Berchelt Deontay Wilder's Manager: It Makes Sense To Fight Luis Ortiz! Miguel Berchelt Wants To Fight Again in 2017, Not Rushing Return Jose Pedraza vs. Mickey Bey in Talks For August 22, Las Vegas Gilberto Ramirez: I Won't Let Jesse Hart Run, I Want Him To Fight Malignaggi: McGregor Can Exploit Things, Have His Moments David Allen Drops, Stops Tom Dallas in Three Rounds Gassiev Sees No Reason For Lebedev Rematch After WBSS Refusal Joe Cortez Helping Conor McGregor Prepare For Floyd Mayweather Mayweather: Believe I Can't Read and Spell? I Made $800 Million! Frank Warren: Mayweather, McGregor - Big Talk, Will They Deliver? Garcia: Non-Title Fight Vs. Broner Still Biggest of Our Careers Mairis Briedis vs. Mike Perez on September 30 in Latvia Top Rank VP: Pacquiao-Horn Was Close, 117-111 Created Issue Lomachenko: I'm Ready To Fight Guillermo Rigondeaux Next! Garcia Expects Broner to Be Biggest Puncher He Has Faced Yarde Would Love To Emulate Roy Jones, Win Title at Heavyweight Amanda Serrano-Edina Kiss: Still Worth a Look on Delay Nikki Adler Confident She'll Hand Claressa Shields Her First Loss Erol Ceylan Discusses The Past, Present and Future of EC Boxing Hatton: Pacquiao Got Old Overnight, When Horn Beats You... Malignaggi: McGregor Has Game Plan, It's Not What People Think Robert Guerrero and Knowing When To Say When Isaac Zarate Drops, Shocks Carlos Carlson To Win Decision Antonio Moran Stops Rosales To Win WBO Regional Title Amanda Serrano Stops Kiss: Cintron, Oquendo Win By KO White Smiles: Mayweather's Kink is Southpaws, McGregor is One Broner vs. Garcia Approved By WBC For The "Diamond Title" De La Hoya: McGregor Can Beat Floyd - With Flying Kick To Head! Manager: McGregor Will Be Best Fighter in History With Upset Win Jorge Linares vs. Luke Campbell Ordered By The WBA Duva: Barrera is One of Several Options For Kovalev's Return Ustinov vs. Oquendo For Vacant WBA Title in Play For October 2 Lomachenko: I Was Preparing For Salido, But Ready For Marriaga Muwendo, Esquivias Battle at M3 Anaheim Event Center
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement