Advertisement
Advertisement

No Reward for Robbery: BScene Pound-for-Pound Update

By Cliff Rold

The reviews are in and judges Duane Ford and CJ Ross get two thumbs down from most of the boxing community.  Given consideration of the quality of opponent he had in front of him, Manny Pacquiao gave arguably his best showing since the Miguel Cotto fight in 2009.  Faced with a Timothy Bradley determined not to fall, Pacquiao boxed more than he has in any fight since the Marco Antonio Barrera rematch.

Pacquiao won, bare minimum, at least eight rounds to anyone with vision the right side of none.

Going into the Bradley fight, Pacquiao remained in the top slot of the pound-for-pound ratings.  Should a universally blasted verdict affect that?

Regular readers can guess the answer.  If this scribe strongly disagrees with a decision, his eyes come first.  Screw bad judges.

In this first update since March, Pacquiao-Bradley isn’t the only verdict to consider.  Timothy Bradley, previously rated tenth, was game and gritty but outclassed versus Pacquiao.  A rematch may answer whether foot and ankle injuries played a role.  For now, he exits.

The great Bernard Hopkins joins him outside.  Hopkins finally succumbed to the challenge of Chad Dawson.  Hopkins, nearing 50, doesn’t look the part of one of the worlds very best at the moment but, if he has another big upset in him, it would be no surprise. 

And what of Carl Froch, rated before a loss to Andre Ward and emphatically triumphant against Lucian Bute?  Does he return?

You know the drill.

>>>>>>Click Here To View BoxingScene's Full Pound-for-Pound Ratings<<<<<<

 

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Primera on 06-16-2012

[QUOTE=whirlwind;12246039]lmao at these butthurts floydiots. Floyd weight cheated a lightweight Marquez, sucker punched Ortiz and faked retirement to avoid prime Cotto won't make him ahead of Pacquiao in p4p list. Deal with it.:booty: Pac just destroyed a young prime p4p…

Comment by slackblick on 06-16-2012

POS list.....any list that has pac as #1 isn't taken seriously. floyd beat the crap outta of a the same marquez that pac robbed. nov 2011 should of left no doubt in anyone's mind who is #1.

Comment by $coinblatt$ on 06-16-2012

[QUOTE=AnimalisticMeth;12243936]Marquez at 3 is too high considering his opposition. This is my current Top 10: 1) Floyd Mayweather Jr 2) Manny Pacquiao 3) Andre Ward 4) Sergio Martinez 5) Juan Manuel Marquez 6) Wladimir Klitschko 7) Nonito Donaire 8) Vitali…

Comment by mathed on 06-15-2012

Results are trash...you have Ward above Martinez? Come on now......that's a joke, Bradley outside the top 10.I can live with it, you will be forced to change that in his next fight.....make room for Robert Guerrero too.

Comment by betmen on 06-14-2012

[QUOTE=BIGPOPPAPUMP;12242919]The reviews are in and judges Duane Ford and CJ Ross get two thumbs down from most of the boxing community. Given consideration of the quality of opponent he had in front of him, Manny Pacquiao gave arguably his best…

Post a Comment/View More User Comments (174)
Top Headlines Photos: James DeGale Taken To His Limit By Porky Medina Ricky Burns Enjoying Low-Profile Approach Video: Jack-Bute, DeGale-Medina Post Presser Highlights Part 2 Video: Jack-Bute, DeGale-Medina Post Presser Highlights Part 1 Bellew-Makabu: Burton vs. Dodson For British Title Added Video: Victor Ortiz on His Boxing Future Following KO Defeat Video: Andre Berto on KO of Ortiz, Danny Garcia Shot, More Video: Ellerbe Reacts To Floyd Mayweather vs. Conor McGregor Fury: Klitschko Fight is My Last, I Have No Motivation To Carry On! Medina: James DeGale Said He Would Stop Me, He Ran All Night! WBC Prez Vows Investigation of Two Judges in Jack-Bute DeGale Disappointed With His Performance Against Medina Moreno Outclasses Sor Rungvisai To Set Up Yamanaka Rematch Floyd Mayweather Hints at Comeback, Reveals Talks With CBS/SHO Jack, Bute Ends in Draw - Jack Sets Up DeGale Unification Pedro Campa Extends Win Streak With Stoppage Win Over Alfaro Video: Victor Ortiz Attacked By Crazy Fan Following KO Defeat Badou Jack-Lucian Bute - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard James DeGale Digs Deep To Overcome, Decision Rogelio Medina Washington Decisions Eddie Chambers: Benavidez, Gausha Win Badou Jack-Lucian Bute - CompuBox Historical Review James DeGale-Rogelio Medina: LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Andre Berto Gets Revenge, Knocks Victor Ortiz Out in Four Jack-Bute, DeGale-Medina LIVE Results: Sharif Bogere Wins Victor Ortiz-Andre Berto II - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Thomas Williams Blasts Out Edwin Rodriguez in Two Rounds Edwin Rodriguez-Thomas Williams - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jorge Lara Demolishes Montiel With Brutal First Round Knockout Jorge Lara vs. Fernando Montiel - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Anthony Joshua to Have U.S. Network Deal Announced Next Week Victor Ortiz vs. Andre Berto II - CompuBox Historical Review Liam Walsh Retains British and Commonwealth Titles With TKO Photos: Hughie Fury's Severe Cut Above His Left Eye Hughie Fury Suffers Bad Cut, Gets Technical Nod Over Fred Kassi Amir Khan Eyes MMA: I Fancy My Chances With Conor McGregor! Jamie Conlan Wins FOTY War To Get Title: Walsh Retains His Belt Andy Lee Sets Record Straight on Rumors of Daniel Jacobs Bout Video: Eddie Hearn Discusses Tony Bellew's Big Title Card Video: Theophane on Mayweather-Broner, Jack-DeGale, More Video: Eddie Hearn Talks Anthony Joshua, Kell Brook, Tyson Fury
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement