A New Number One: BoxingScene Pound-for-Pound Update

By Cliff Rold

A lot can happen in just a couple of months. 

At the last update, Andre Ward was coming off his best win in years, Roman Gonzalez was coming off a controversial first defeat. They stood atop the list with longtime bantamweight titlist Shinsuke Yamanaka crashing the top ten on the eve of his defense against Luis Nery.

Since then, Ward has retired, Gonzalez was knocked out for the first clear loss of his career, and Yamanaka was stopped in his first defeat only for Nery to test positive for PEDs after the fight.


That leaves a possible three openings to be filled. The man right behind Ward and Gonzalez in the last list, Terence Crawford, made himself a rare four-belted undisputed champion at Jr. welterweight in violent, sudden fashion. Gonzalez’s loss came on a card with a case in this top ten for multiple fighters. Despite the loss, should Gonzalez remain considering most thought he won his first fight with Srisaket Sor Rungvisai? What about the victor? Does his win force a place for him considering Gonzalez started the year at number one? 

And what about Naoya Inoue and Juan Francisco Estrada? Estrada picked up a solid win over Carlos Cuadras while Inoue, a two-division titlist, passed the eye test in his US debut?

A week later, Gennady Golovkin, previously 6th, was left with a draw many thought a competitive win, retaining his claims to the middleweight crown in his biggest fight to date? Does Golovkin move up? What about Canelo Alvarez?

Are there really any right answers? One thing is certain: with the retirement of Ward, there is no absolute choice for the top spot. Let the debate begin by clicking on the latest:

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by j.razor on 12-26-2017

[QUOTE=aboutfkntime;18124295]this happens every single time Cliff updates his P4P list I do agree that the criteria should be advertized in short, P4P has nothing to do with resume Crawford is a better fighter than Thurman, and would beat him if…

Comment by j.razor on 12-26-2017

[QUOTE=kafkod;18124277]:bottle:You still mad Danny lost ... LMMFAO![/QUOTE] Not really, I just jump on the Bullsh*t & lil g getting the nod on Jacobs was B.S.

Comment by Kuyukut on 10-12-2017

where's freakin' hand of stone paulie malaggnagi?

Comment by aboutfkntime on 10-12-2017

[QUOTE=theface07;18131272]Funny thing to say for someone who has criticized Golovkin incessantly and repeatedly on unrelated threads for his lack of top level opponents. [B]Resume has a lot to do with P4P[/B]. Otherwise, you could fight nobody, remain undefeated and be…

Comment by theface07 on 10-12-2017

[QUOTE=aboutfkntime;18126631]to answer ALL of those questions..... P4P has nothing to do with resume' this happens every single month, without fail[/QUOTE] Funny thing to say for someone who has criticized Golovkin incessantly and repeatedly on unrelated threads for his lack of…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (105)
Top Headlines Donnie Nietes vs. Juan Carlos Reveco Added To Superfly 2 NSAC Suspends Ogawa for Failed PED Test, Farmer Result in Doubt Yordenis Ugas vs. Ray Robinson Moves To Garcia-Rios Card Photos: Robert Easter, Javier Fortuna - Face To Face at Presser Photos: Spence, Peterson - Face To Face at Final Presser Spence: I Want To Clean Out 147, Be The Last Man Standing! Price Details How He Badly Drilled Anthony Joshua in Sparring Whyte: Getting Wilder's WBC Belt Makes Joshua Rematch Bigger! Tyson Fury Offers To Be Parker's Sparring Partner For Joshua Fight Frank Buglioni vs. Callum Johnson Added To Whyte vs. Browne News: Beltran-Moses Update, Eddie Ortiz, LaManna-Bracero Photos: Dillian Whyte, Lucas Browne - Heated Face To Face Josh Taylor vs. Humberto Soto Set For March 3, Glasgow Whyte: Browne Old & Slow; He Has No Way of Stopping Me DiBella: There's No Way Easter-Fortuna Will Be a Boring Fight Jamal James is Open To Facing Amir Khan in Comeback Fight DiBella: If Spence Dominates Peterson, There With Crawford, Loma Frampton: Warren Wants Donaire Fight To Be a WBO Eliminator Cheeseman: Carson Jones Getting Older, I'll Stop Him Late Knockout CP Freshmart vs. Landero in WBA Title Clash, March 6 Hearn: Joshua-Povetkin Happens in UK, We Won't Go To Russia Arum: Pacquiao, Crawford-Horn Double Would Be ESPN PPV Joshua Promoter: We Want Wilder By Year's End - Even in U.S. Evander Holyfield Enters The World of Cryptocurrency The Road to Keith Thurman-Errol Spence Begins (! Or ?) Angulo Very Angry With Chavez Jr. For Delaying Their Fight Jorge Linares Very Willing To Face Lomachenko or Garcia Next Arum Reacts To The Chatter of a Pacquiao vs. Lomachenko Bout Terence Crawford vs. Jeff Horn Heading To MSG on April 14? Photos: Gilberto Ramirez Training in Beast Mode For Ahmed Lomachenko's Manager: Pacquiao is Old, No Gain in Beating Him Photos: Lamont Peterson, Robert Easter, Browne Workouts David Kaminsky, 17-Year-Old Israeli Prospect, Joins Top Rank Photos: Errol Spence Looking Very Sharp During Workout Lamont Peterson Feels He's in 'Perfect Place' For Spence Clash Miguel Berchelt Holds Presser, Still Unsure of Next Opponent Lipinets Trained With One Hand, 'Begged' to Stay in Garcia Fight Parker's Promoter: Joshua's 'More Than Human' Talk is Just Silly Brook-Rabchenko: Kid Galahad, Appleyard vs. Shafiq Added Frampton: I May Need Career Best Performance To Beat Donaire

Latest Active Forum Threads