Mosley’s winning return doesn’t silence the legacy thieves

By Lyle Fitzsimmons

It’s a good thing I’m a little thin on accomplishments.

I was MVP of a Cinderella hockey run as a Niagara Falls pre-teen, and I’ve managed to outrun about 10 percent of the field while completing a dozen 10-plus mile road races since… but no one’s been ringing the cell phone lately asking for up-front tickets to my Hall of Fame inductions.

It’s just as well, I guess, because I don’t particularly like being a bull’s-eye.

These days, no matter the acclaim earned over a career in an endeavor of choice, it seems a righteously indignant wannabe is rarely far away with a sheaf of reasons why even one more split-second in the spotlight – win, lose, draw or otherwise – will immediately reduce all legacies to rubble.

This past weekend, it was Shane Mosley’s turn in the crosshairs.


Nearly every day since last May – when a wide decision against Canelo Alvarez was the third straight loss in a career that three years earlier had him opposite Floyd Mayweather Jr. in a PPV extravaganza – some soothsayer from some outlet has written that “Sugar” ought to retire in order to save his resume.

Or just as accurately, the writer's warped view of it.

As if those three losses – or the five more he’d had in his previous 13 fights – would cancel out titles in three weight classes, two dramatic wins over a sure-fire Hall of Famer and more plentiful highlight-reel fodder than any 100 pugs whose careers dissolved long before anyone noticed.

It’s been nonsense at every stop from greatness to mediocrity.

But it’s not the first time Mosley’s been the target.

Shane heard the same “he’s done” chatter during a 1-4 stretch from 2002 through 2004, in which he was handily beaten twice apiece by Vernon Forrest at 147 and Winky Wright at 154. Incidentally, all he did in response was win seven of eight, including a vicious beating of supposed “most feared fighter in the world” Antonio Margarito.

This time, the naysayers pounced when Mayweather outpointed him in 2010, when Manny Pacquiao outworked him in 2011 and when Alvarez outslugged him across another 12 inglorious rounds.

What the chatterboxes don’t realize, though, is that frequency does not equal feasibility.

Of course, no one of sound mind is contending that the version of Pablo Cesar Cano that Mosley beat to end the streak is anyone's idea of Ray Robinson. Or even Ray Romano, for that matter.

And no, his Saturday effort in Cancun against Cano – a top 50 welter best known for losing close to bigger names – wasn’t a keeper, regardless of which scorecard you endorsed.

(Incidentally, all the official ones had Mosley winning seven of 12 rounds.)

Win or no win, everyone knows Shane’s not what he was.

Everyone knows he won’t be again.

But what his efforts do prove is that a surely faded and perhaps cash-strapped Mosley, even at 41, can still handle himself well enough for Ws against 99 percent of the active pros out there – and at least briefly competitive distance losses against the other 1 percent.

And if that’s good enough for him, then why shouldn’t it be for us?

Make no mistake, I’m a fan. I’d have loved to have seen him win them all. And I’d have been fine had he chosen to walk away at 39 years old or before, with many of these conversations preempted.

But as long as he's physically able to keep going – and grown man enough to decide to do so – I can't for the life of me understand why it's as bad, sad and tragic as the teary-eyed, quick-to-eulogize Twitter set would have had you believe over the weekend.

Or how it takes anything away from what they’d all thought of him when he was 38-0.

Short of him reliving O.J. Simpson’s or Pete Rose’s foibles, it all makes zero difference.

Those legacies are indeed tarnished by off-the-field failings.

But Mosley's in-ring history is forever safe, and one need look no further than Canastota for proof.

Muhammad Ali lost to Trevor Berbick, but his plaque still says “The Greatest.” Ray Leonard lost to Hector Camacho, but he's still called “Sugar Ray.” Julio Cesar Chavez lost to Grover Wiley, but he'll always be “El Gran Campeon.”

And regardless of what happens to Mosley from here on out, he's still “Sugar Shane.”

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

This week’s title-fight schedule:


IBF super middleweight title – Greenwich, United Kingdom
Carl Froch (champion) vs. Mikkel Kessler (unranked)

Froch (30-2, 22 KO): Second title defense; Lost to Kessler (UD 12) in 2010
Kessler (46-2, 35 KO): Thirteenth title fight (10-2); Fifth fight outside Denmark (2-2)
Fitzbitz says: “Though Kessler hasn’t lost in three fights since defeating Froch, it nonetheless feels like the Englishman is the one with the momentum. He’ll even the score at home.” Froch by decision

WBO junior bantamweight title – Buenos Aires, Argentina
Omar Narvaez (champion) vs. Felipe Orucuta (No. 1 contender) 
Narvaez (38-1-2, 20 KO): Seventh title fight; Held WBO title at 112 (2002-09, 16 defenses)
Orucuta (27-1, 23 KO): First title fight; Ten straight wins by stoppage (32 total rounds)
Fitzbitz says: “The Mexican is 10 years younger and has a string of KO victories, but he’s not had a win against someone on Narvaez’s level. Home experience beats traveling brawn.” Narvaez by decision

NOTE: Fights previewed are only those involving a sanctioning body's full- fledged title-holder -- no interim, diamond, silver, etc. Fights for WBA "world championships" are only included if no "super champion" exists in the weight class.

Last week’s picks: 2-1
2013 picks record: 28-19 (59.6 percent)
Overall picks record: 491-171 (74.2 percent)

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

Tags: Shane Mosley image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by shenmue on 05-23-2013

So Mosley has been linked with fights with Broner, winner of Maidana/Lopez, winner of Thurman/Chavez or winner of Berto/Karras. How does he get on with those fighters?.

Comment by - Ram Raid - on 05-23-2013

[QUOTE=fitzbitz;13401257]People are free to have any opinion they choose. As am I. My opinion is that the one person who ought to decide if Shane Mosley should fight on, is, well... Shane Mosley. Just because some people think he's not…

Comment by GOD-FR33 on 05-22-2013

[B][FONT="Verdana"][SIZE="3"][COLOR="Blue"]Mabe so. We are talking about Shane here though. However, if you are in your prime and you lose to the same fighter twice, you are not a legend. The term is used too loosely nowadays. They word is for…

Comment by fishscale on 05-22-2013

[QUOTE=GOD-FR33;13400085][B][FONT="Verdana"][SIZE="3"][COLOR="Blue"]Shane is a mere hall of famer in my eyes. He's no legend. You can't lose to the same fighter twice in your prime and be a legend.[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT][/B][/QUOTE] You've just disqualified a ton of great boxers if we take your…

Comment by GOD-FR33 on 05-22-2013

[B][FONT="Verdana"][SIZE="3"][COLOR="Blue"]Hey man. Was that an accident? Copying and pasting my entire post? Just asking. As for Tito vs. Mosley never happening; Mosley had a chance to fight Tito before he signed to fight Wright and turned the fight down. His…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (25)
Top Headlines Parker's Promoter Still Pushing To Keep Ruiz Fight in Auckland Manny Pacquiao: I Need a Convincing Win To Prove I'm Still Here Scott Quigg Makes Featherweight Debut on Anthony Joshua Card Pacquiao vs. Vargas Lands on BoxNation Katie Taylor Inks Promotional With Eddie Hearn, Pro Debut Set Oscar De La Hoya: 2016 is Maybe The Worst Year For Boxing Roach: I Don't Think Andre Ward is The Fighter He Used To Be Video: Freddie Roach Talks Golovkin, Kovalev vs. Ward, More Manny Pacquiao, Freddie Roach Have Retirement Pact in Place Video: Justin Fortune Discusses The Heavyweight Division Juan Manuel Lopez vs. Wilfredo Vazquez Jr: Sure, Why Not Video: Bob Arum Talks Schaefer, Trump, King, UFC, More Arum: I Would NEVER Do Pacquiao vs. Golovkin - It Was a Joke! Video: Manny Pacquiao Putting in Work For Vargas Title Clash Video: Freddie Roach on Thurman-Garcia, Lebedev-Gassiev, More Mason Menard's Fight Now Off Due To Bookkeeping Issue Molina Still Wants Danny Garcia Fight: He Has Holes in His Armor Video: Manny Pacquiao Talks Camp, Retirement, Vargas, More Demetrius Andrade Very Motivated as Jack Culcay Clash Nears Photos: Manny Pacquiao Putting in Work at Wild Card Gym Canelo Says The Ball is in Golovkin's Court: Accept The Offer! Ricardo Mayorga Crashes Into Taxi, Pursued For 200K in Damages Canelo Eager To Prove WBO Prez's Prediction of Mayweather KO Vences: A Win Over Casey Ramos Will Open A lot of Doors For Me Photos: Juanma, Vazquez Explode in Very Tense Final Presser Ustinov's Manager Expects WBA To Order Klitschko Title Fight Premier Boxing Champions Reveal Season 3 Schedule Helenius Faces Basile on 12/17, Chisora Rematch Eyed For March Arthur Abraham Shelved For Three Weeks Due To Elbow Injury SHO's Espinoza: Mayweather Won't Even Joke About Ring Return Curtis Stevens-De La Rosa Added To PPV Portion of Kovalev-Ward Briggs Claims Haye Used His Name: He Backed Out of Our Deal Cuellar Vows To Take Mares Out - Targets Frampton, Santa Cruz Klitschko: No Retirement, Joshua Fight Will Be Biggest in Years Wilfredo Vazquez Jr: Juanma Repulses Me, I Will Knock Him Out! Jarrett Hurd vs. Jo Jo Dan Set, Jorge Cota is Now Out Badou Jack Thinks Ward-Kovalev is 50-50, Leans Ward With Pick De La Hoya Not Concerned With The Return of Richard Schaefer Andre Ward: Kovalev Won't Bully Me - He Tires, He Gets Frustrated Arum: Trump Thought of Andy Ruiz When He Said 'Bad Hombre'

Latest Active Forum Threads