When is a Loss Not a Loss?


By Tris Dixon

WHAT does a loss mean for a fighter? What should a loss mean?

Too often, in today’s era of padded records and multi-weight division titleholders who do not have a defining win to their name, a loss marks the end.

A rebuilding job has to be undertaken but you will never be allowed to shake an off night or a defeat.

Unlike other sports, where you can pick yourself up and dust yourself off, you can’t simply win and all be right in the world again.

You will always have, “Well he lost to ‘so and so.” “He’s already been beaten.”

Repeatedly, the stick with the ‘L’ on it will be used to beat them over the head with. It goes with you everywhere

Of course, some losses are more damning than others. Guillermo Rigondeuax had far from dazzled on some of his biggest nights – certainly if you listen to Bob Arum – but his loss on Saturday night to Vasyl Lomachenko would have been hard for even his biggest fans to justify or explain.

That kind of defeat does, and arguably should, stay with you. However, it does not mean the rest of his record or his incredible achievements evaporate to dust.

It does not mean he was overrated all along, or that he was on the slide (maybe he was) or that he was not as good as we had been lead to believe. It meant he lost a fight. It meant there was a now an L in the right hand column of his stats, the first he has taken in the pros yet one that will both probably define and haunt him.

Will he make it into the International Boxing Hall of Fame? There will be many who won’t be able to forgive the way he pulled the pin on last night’s hotly-anticipated contest.

miguel-cotto (4)_4

And it is the Hall of Fame where the greats should head. This year, Ricky Hatton failed to make the grade at the first time of asking. “He lost each time he stepped up,” said critics who referred to the Floyd Mayweather and Manny Pacquiao fights when looking at the top of his resume. Kostya Tszyu did not matter. Nor was it factored in how he was the first British fighter built into a brand on ‘satellite’ TV in the UK or how he took those incredible record numbers of fans on multiple trips across the Atlantic. Of course, they are not defining factors but contributing reasons as to why he will get in one day.

And while those pointed to Hatton’s famous defeats, Vitali Klitschko did make it in, and some looked to his thrilling, heroic and bloody loss to Lennox Lewis as a reason why he should be inducted.

So when is an L not an L?

Another case in point is Puerto Rican sensation Miguel Cotto.

Again, he is in a bracket where he lost his biggest fights, aside from the personal grudge match against Antonio Margarito. There were, like Hatton, defeats to Paquiao and Mayweather as well as Saul Alvarez and Austin Trout. Finally, earlier this month, there was the farewell Sadam Ali defeat, which will be wiped from our selective memories before long. He was a four-weight world champion who was past his best when he let the door hit him on the way out.

But in his defeat to Pacquiao he showed an unflinching heart, staring down a devastating machine at his peak that was, as a course of habit, devouring everything before him.

Against Mayweather, he was merely supposed to be fodder, a shopworn former 140-pounder who’d already been mauled by ‘Pacman’ and pushed to the wire by Joshua Clottey.

Instead, he gave Mayweather possibly the most bruising fight of his career and, in defeat, added to his Puerto Rican legend. Yes, he lost, but it did no harm to his legacy even if it dropped a further L in that column.

Of course, there are some who will not look beyond the loss.

But circumstances alter cases.

The modern pressures from TV networks and governing bodies who reward fighters with glossy records has harmed the sport, perhaps irreversibly. Occasionally you may see a battle of unbeaten prospects, but even then often it is the case of one cashing in and one cashing out before they are found out.

And again, that much anticipated fight where you have one perfect record against another with all of the belts on the line is the rarest of unicorns. In fact, boxing politics makes it virtually impossible, which is why we are watching the heavyweight negotiations between Deontay Wilder, Anthony Joshua and Joseph Parker with baited breath.

But let’s not be quite so hasty to trash a fighter for a loss or one bad night. In any sport, an unbeaten record is nigh on sacred and virtually unachievable. In boxing, losses can be badges of honour, lessons learned or they can be particularly unsightly. Regardless of what they are and how they occur it might not be best to judge a fighter on his worst night just as it may not be right to judge them on their best. But when the cheers or the jeers stop, their whole body of work and the mark they have left will be there for all to see.

Tags: boxing image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Dramacyde on 12-11-2017

Bullsh*t. Mothaf*cka got his ass whooped by Ali & got gifts against Clottey & Mosley!

Comment by AdonisCreed on 12-11-2017

[QUOTE=Japanese Boxing;18325452]Blame the promoters. If guys actually fought each other we wouldn't view singular losses so poorly. Guys get away with it in MMA because it's a more volatile sport but if a top guy loses to another top guy…

Comment by IronDanHamza on 12-11-2017

So Lomachenk is going to be the first fighter who loses and people pretend it didn't happen.

Comment by sterling on 12-11-2017

I think this was quite sad to see. Loma was excellent on the night and put on a great display, he is truley in his prime and showed it. I am sorry to say it but i think Rigondeaux has…

Comment by aboutfkntime on 12-11-2017

[QUOTE=Shadoww702;18325897]??? Was that the Joshua fight??? Man the doctors checked Wyhte out and he CLEARLY was fighting back and not even getting hit! Or how about with 10 seconds left you rock the sht out of the fighter but the…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (25)
Top Headlines Miguel Berchelt Holds Presser, Still Unsure of Next Opponent Lipinets Trained With One Hand, 'Begged' to Stay in Garcia Fight Parker's Promoter: Joshua's 'More Than Human' Talk is Just Silly Brook-Rabchenko: Kid Galahad, Appleyard vs. Shafiq Added Frampton: I May Need Career Best Performance To Beat Donaire Lipinets Suffers Hand Injury, Fight Against Garcia Postponed Photos: Carl Frampton, Nonito Donaire - Go Face To Face Anthony Mundine Places Full Focus on Jeff Horn After Big KO Win David Price Agrees to Fight Povetkin on Joshua-Parker Undercard Easter: I Must Fight Tall; I Made the Shafikov Fight Too Hard Bivol: Barrera Made a Mistake Choosing to Fight Me, Not Kovalev Spence: Crawford Needs To Worry About Beating Horn Before Me Joshua: It'll Take More Than a Human to Stop Me From Destiny Trainer: Parker Knows His Place in History at Stake With Joshua Dubois Ready To Rise: I Want To Get To The Top of The Division! Joshua Embraces Idea of Tyson Fury Walking Parker To The Ring Pacquiao Says He is Targeting a Lomachenko Showdown Anthony Joshua Nominated For Laureus World Sports Award Marcus Browne: I'm Settled and Coming into My Own Sanchez: Canelo Knew if He Stopped - Golovkin Would KO Him! Jeff Horn Shakes Head at Mundine's "White Boy" Comments Roman Now Mandatory To Miguel Berchelt, Who Hunts For Foe Anthony Joshua: The Rumors About My Chin - It's All Fake News Manny Pacquiao Return Being Lined Up For Crawford-Horn Card Golovkin's Promoter Breaks Down Latest on Canelo Rematch Video: Anthony Joshua Very Eager To Get Parker in The Ring Photos: Estrada, Cuadras vs. Arroyo, Viloria - Superfly 2 Presser Video: Joseph Parker Discusses Anthony Joshua Showdown Terry Flanagan vs. Maurice Hooker To Land at O2 Arena Hearn: Jacobs-O'Sullivan Less Likely; Jacobs-Andy Lee Possible Joshua on Parker's Steroid Jabs: I'm Clean, I'd Never Do That Skoglund Update, Castano-Vitu News, Badou Jack, Wallin, More Joseph Parker: Joshua Has Rematch Clause, But I Don't Need One Hearn Offers Alexander Povetkin Slot On Joshua vs. Parker Card Mundine: Horn is a White Boy, Gets Coverage Because He's White! Video: Anthony Joshua Reacts To Steroid Comments From Parker Lenroy Thomas vs. David Allen II Added To Brook-Rabchenko Card News: Kovalev-Mikhalkin, Spence-Peterson, WBSS, More Valdez, Quigg Promise To Stage Action-Packed War at StubHub Photos: Anthony Joshua, Joseph Parker - Tense Face To Face

Latest Active Forum Threads