Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Is Lomachenko The Best Pound-for-Pound Fighter in Boxing?

image

By Andreas Hale

Once again, Vasyl Lomachenko made his opponent look like a novice in the ring. And, once again, the talk about Lomachenko being the best pound for pound fighter in all of boxing has bubbled to the surface.

But is this talk premature given the lack of fights on Lomachenko’s resume and the fact that he does have a loss on his record?

What Lomachenko did against Jason Sosa was nothing short of the highest degree of outclassing an opponent that one can imagine. At least Sosa fought for as long as he could. Nicholas Walters, who was unbeaten heading into his fight with Lomachenko, was thoroughly embarrassed before quitting on the stool.

Lomachenko certainly looks like he is the most skilled boxer on the face of the planet. But are we giving him too much credit? Aside from Walters, the only high-level opponent he has defeated is Gary Russell Jr.

For as much grief that Gennady Golovkin has received, he has proven himself by remaining unbeaten and thoroughly dismantling his opposition. And when he was put in with a tough opponent, he prevailed. Andre Ward won a hotly contested decision against Sergey Kovalev, but it was against another top five pound for pound fighter.

But because of both the Ward-Kovalev and GGG-Jacobs fights being so close and the loss by Roman “Chocolatito” Gonzalez, the top spot on the pound for pound lists is up for grabs. And, for many, Lomachenko’s scintillating performance against Jason Sosa sealed the deal. Bernard Hopkins was on commentary and quickly launched into how he thought Hi-Tech had hurdled the competition to the number one spot.

Not too many disagreed with him.

Bob Arum will tell anyone within an earshot that Lomachenko is the most skilled fighter the sport has seen since Muhammad Ali. Other boxing pundits shower him with praise and are bewildered by his talent. Everything from his punch placement to his footwork are deemed as otherworldly.

vasyl-lomachenko_2

Vasyl Lomachenko doesn’t just beat his opponents, he ruins them. He’s fast, sharp and has a high boxing IQ. Since the Salido loss in his second professional fight, he’s figured out this pro boxing thing and has shed any and every remnant of amateur point fighting (unlike Guillermo Rigondeaux, who continues to bore fans no matter how good he is). He isn’t just good, he’s great. Perhaps he is on course to become one of the greatest boxers in recent history.

But this anointment as the best pound for pound fighter in boxing right now is, in fact, premature. Yes, he’s arguably the greatest amateur boxer of all-time. But that doesn’t mean much when considering whom the best pound for pound professional boxer is. He certainly passes the eye test as he completely picks apart his competition. But he did lose to Orlando Salido, despite all of the shortcuts Salido took to get the decision. That can’t be taken too lightly when you weigh Lomachenko’s resume against Andre Ward’s. Ward has yet to lose and has a pretty solid portfolio. Not to mention that he’s faced a pound for pound guy recently. Lomachenko hasn’t quite made it to that point yet.

It doesn’t mean that he won’t get there, but we should probably slow down.

With a possible Lomachenko vs. Mikey Garcia fight looming, we could get the perfect opponent that could launch Lomachenko right to the top of the P4P list should he defeat him as he’s done his last seven opponents. If he is willing to jump up another weight class, a fight with Terence Crawford could settle who is the best fighter in the world.

But those fights haven’t happened yet.

No matter what you thought of Ward and GGG’s performances, they both have more extensive resumes than Lomachenko. And Ward certainly has faced stiffer competition with his Super Six run, utter domination of Chad Dawson and come from behind victory over Kovalev. It would be very difficult to place Lomachenko above both Ward and Kovalev. For that matter, a leapfrog over Golovkin should be met with pause considering that GGG has a ridiculously high knockout percentage and has rampaged through the middleweight division in a fashion we haven’t seen in quite some time. Even Terence Crawford gets a slight nod over Lomachenko considering that he thoroughly outclassed Viktor Postol and wiped out Yuriorkis Gamboa, who was once considered a potential P4P fighter.

This isn’t a knock on Lomachenko. Instead, this is more of us wanting to see more so we can be comfortable with the decision to name him as the best fighter in the world. We’ve seen his ability and have been blown away. But the talent alone needs to be met with elite opposition.

Most of the boxing world believes that it is only a matter of time before he sits on the throne. But we should be a little more patient with the crowning of a new king.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by therealpugilist on 04-25-2017

anybody with his level of talent will look sensational vs B class level opposition as of today he has shown the talent but has not faced the competition necessary for him to attain that lofty status a rematch win over…

Comment by JASON SHAW on 04-25-2017

[quote=snixsnipe;17618305]uhhh. Lomachenko made like $825,000 vs martinez. $1,000,000? Vs. Walters, and idk about sosa. :lol1: He might not make as much as guerrero vs floyd, but i guarantre you he will make a lot more in his career overall than…

Comment by JASON SHAW on 04-25-2017

[quote=snixsnipe;17618305]uhhh. Lomachenko made like $825,000 vs martinez. $1,000,000? Vs. Walters, and idk about sosa. :lol1: He might not make as much as guerrero vs floyd, but i guarantre you he will make a lot more in his career overall than…

Comment by Suavecito80 on 04-25-2017

He very well may be eventually but no way is he #1 right now.

Comment by SniXSniPe on 04-25-2017

[QUOTE=JASON SHAW;17597217]and im telling you even in 10 years lomachenko wont be making bigger paydays than guerrero lmfaooooooo....[/QUOTE] Uhhh. Lomachenko made like $825,000 vs Martinez. $1,000,000? vs. Walters, and IDK about Sosa. :lol1: He might not make as much as…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (125)
Top Headlines Felix Verdejo Ring Return Targeted For January, Says Manager Promoter: I Want To Match Andrade Against Elite at 160 - ASAP! Schaefer: If U.S. Networks Aren't Interested in WBSS, So Be It Dorticos: All Gassiev Did Was Beat 'Old' Opponent in Wlodarczyk Photos: Ryota Murata Gets Revenge, Stops Hassan N'Dam Denis Lebedev: I Think Yunier Dorticos Will Beat Murat Gassiev Maliek, Mikhail and Michael Jr. Montgomery Get KO Wins Juho Haapoja Loses EU Title, Announces His Retirement Jezreel Corrales: I Was Winning on All 3 Cards, I Want a Rematch! Demetrius Andrade Vacates WBA Belt - Focused on Murata, GGG Ryota Murata: I'll Try My Best To Beat Gennady Golovkin! Photos: Alberto Machado Bombs Jezreel Corrales For WBA Title Dorticos: I Want To Destroy Gassiev, He Will Face a Real Man! Photos: Murat Gassiev, Yunier Dorticos - Go Face To Face! Schaefer: I Learned From The Mistakes of The Super Six Tourney Anthony Joshua: I Asked For Dillian Whyte After Pulev Withdrew Murata Dominant in Rematch, Makes N’Dam Quit After 7th Round Photos: Murat Gassiev Blasts Out Krzysztof Wlodarczyk in Three Photos: Ryan Burnett Beats Zhakiyanov To Unify WBA, IBF Belts Photos: Josh Warrington Takes Out Ceylan, Earns Lee Selby Shot Sakio Bika, Tim Tszyu Pick Up Solid Wins in Sydney Bouts Mock vs. Chudinov Deal in Place For November 25 Andrade: I Did Very Well in 160 Debut, I'll Fight Anybody! Karim Mayfield Decisons Miguel Dumas in San Francisco Gassiev Sees Joshua, Wilder in His Future: I'll Unify, Then Move Up! N'Dam vs. Murata - CompuBox Reflects on First Fight Stats Why Malignaggi Should Quiet Down. And Why He Won't. Machado: He Hurt Me a Few Times, But I Got The Punch I Needed Hassan N'Dam vs. Ryota Murata II: Pre-Fight Report Card Maciej Sulecki: I Want Jermell Charlo Next, I Want The Title Shot Alberto Machado Gets Off The Floor, Knocks Jezreel Corrales Out Jezreel Corrales-Alberto Machado - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Demetrius Andrade Makes 160 Debut, Dominates Alantez Fox Carlos Jimenez Knocks Out Pedro Campa in Shocker Sharif Bogere Decisions Rodriguez Over Ten Rounds in Las Vegas Gassiev Crushes Wlodarczyk in Three, Will Face Dorticos Next Gassiev vs. Wlodarczyk - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Culcay Hurts Resilient Sulecki, But Loses Unanimous Decision Hearn is Firm: I Want Wilder-Whyte Next, Never 50-50 For Joshua! Jason Moloney, Andrew Moloney Win Big in Melbourne
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement