Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Lederman Reflects on The Scoring of Williams-Lara

By Mike Coppinger

The boxing world has been buzzing over the highly-controversial decision rendered in the HBO main event between Paul Williams and Erislandy Lara on July 15th, a bout in which Lara seemed to dominate yet was deemed the loser by majority decision by judges Donald Givens, Hilton Whitaker III and Al Bennett.

Subsequently, New Jersey Athletic Commissioner Aaron Davis took action, suspending all three judges indefinitely.

BoxingScene.com caught up with HBO’s unofficial judge Harold Lederman to discuss one of the most criticized boxing decisions in recent memory and how can judging can be reformed in the sport.

BoxingScene.com: What is your take on the suspension of the judges from the Williams-Lara fight?

Harold Lederman: Unless [Davis] was going to put these guys back into another high-profile fight, it doesn’t mean much. He’s showing the public that he’s cognizant of the fact that the decision wasn’t right and he’s making an effort to change a bad situation. These guys obviously blew the call and he’s holding them out for a little while. There’s a lot of high-profile fights coming up in Jersey, so now I think he’s gonna be a lot more careful when he appoints the judges. There’s at least three HBO shows and one Showtime show that are scheduled to come off in Jersey. At least he’ s showing the public that he’s aware of what’s going on and that’s important.

BoxingScene: Is it odd that the trio of judges worked so many fights in concert on the undercard?

HL: I don’t think it affected the decision one way or the other. I think they would have scored it the same even if they didn’t judge the other fights.

BoxingScene: It seems that judges often score rounds based on one fighter being more busy in a round, even if he’s not being more effective. How can this be rectified going forward?

HL: There’s no question in my mind that the judges were looking at Paul Williams’ work rate, he throws a lot more punches than everybody. But at the end of the round, you gotta say to yourself ‘who did more damage?’ the guy throwing a million jabs or the guy that landed that sensational hard left hand? I thought Erislandy Lara certainly, in nine rounds, did more damage than Paul Williams did, without doubt.

You correct it by having seminars for judges, looking at tapes and going over the way you score and what you’re looking for. In my mind, the most important thing is, at the end of the round you’ve gotta decide who did more damage? Who hurt the other guy more than the other guy hurt him? That’s the guy you give 10 points to.

BoxingScene: Where do you think this ranks in the worst decisions of the past decade or so?

HL: It has to rank up in the top 10, no doubt about it, because Erislandy Lara clearly won that fight. I think Lara really is not going to lose anything from that decision, I think everybody in the world knows he won. I think his career is going to take a step up, he’ll fight somebody good real soon in another real high-profile fight. I think he did himself a lot of good by putting on a great performance like he did.

Mike Coppinger is a regular boxing freelancer for USA TODAY and Ring Magazine. He’s a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America, the Ring Ratings Advisory Panel and the Yahoo! Sports Boxing Panel. Follow him on Twitter: @MikeCoppinger.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by truushot on 07-27-2011

[QUOTE=delpilar;10906051]Those 3 boxing judges should be banned for life, suspension means nothing.[/QUOTE] Where in the boxing rules does it say, fights are judged on who did more damage?

Comment by delpilar on 07-27-2011

Those 3 boxing judges should be banned for life, suspension means nothing.

Comment by chiguy91 on 07-27-2011

even though lederman has a bad rep, it's good to see him siding against pwill's gift decision. the decision should be changed though, temporarily suspending the 3 judges isn't enough imo. either way, hopefully lara gets more big fights.

Comment by adp023 on 07-27-2011

Harold Lederman is well-respected and knows what he's talking about! [IMG]http://i599.photobucket.com/albums/tt71/adp823/Castillo-MayweatherScorecard.jpg?t=1311778871[/IMG]

Comment by Medved on 07-27-2011

Lederman usually is spot on with his scoring, but only when those fights dont involve AA fighters. Just watch the Kotelnik-Alexander fight, dude was sloberring over air punches and even the biased Kellerman was like uhmm dude wtf you scoring?

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (10)
Top Headlines Frampton Expects Another Fan Friendly Fight Against Santa Cruz Curtis Stevens Sure Hand Injury Fully Healed for Lemieux Fight Garcia, 2-1 Underdog vs. Thurman: 'I Guess Vegas Don’t Like Me' Frank Warren on The James DeGale vs. Badou Jack Outcome Early Results Are In: BoxingScene Ratings Update Linares vs. Crolla II Card - Tomi Tatham To Face Liam Conroy Lewis Crocker To Make Pro Debut on February 18th in Belfast Horn: Pacquiao Has Been Knocked Out Before, I Have The Power! Brook Frustrated By Khan, Admits a Lack of Motivation for Spence Conlan Expects Army of Irish Fans To Hit NY For Pro Debut Card Ricardo Mayorga Was Motivated By His Family To Resume Career De La Hoya: Chavez Will Not Be Easy For Canelo, It's a Big Concern Danny Roman Stops Adam Lopez in Ninth To Win WBA Eliminator De La Hoya: Donald Trump Refused To Come To Canelo's Fight Wilder Hopes The WBC Comes Down on Alexander Povetkin Stevenson Wants to Face Smith in NY; 4/29 Negotiations Ongoing Errol Spence Stays Ready in The Gym as IBF Scenario Plays Out WBC Reacts To Behavior, Controversial Comments By Angel Garcia Sullivan Barrera Accepts Artur Beterbiev IBF Eliminator WBA President Gives Status on Heavyweights, PED Testing, More Luis Ortiz vs. Jarrell Miller Could Top First Matchroom Card in U.S. Video: Michael Conlan Discusses His Pro Debut in March Joshua Coming To America, as Hearn Begins Build To Wilder Fight Felix Diaz Dares Crawford: Fight a Real Challenge, I'll Go To Omaha! Cotto vs. Kirkland, Lemieux vs. Stevens Land on BoxNation Photos: Anthony Mundine, Tim Tszyu Putting in Work Photos: Haye, Schaefer Hold Presser To Announce Their UK Deal Erislandy Lara-Yuri Foreman Card Generates 547,000 Viewers Photos/Weights: Patrick Nielsen, Dina Thorslund Ready For Bouts David Haye, Richard Schaefer Team Up, Launch Hayemaker Ringstar Froch: Smith is Not Ready For DeGale, Should Face Dirrell First Pedro Diaz on N'Dam's Big KO Win, Golovkin vs. Jacobs, Gamboa Luis Ortiz: Miller Will Have To Back Up The Crap He's Talking Adonis Stevenson: Unfair Haters Call All of My Opponents 'Bums' Danny Garcia: Not Worried About Critics Who Won't Say it to My Face Eubank Jr: In a Rematch I Would Annihilate Saunders in Four! Pacquiao: In The Eyes of The People - I Beat Floyd Mayweather Andrew Selby Faces Diale For WBC Regional on Eubank-Quinlan Wilkins, Karkardi To Appeal BBBofC Bans Over Nick Blackwell Manny Pacquiao: I Would Fight Conor McGregor - Only in Boxing
Advertisement
Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement