Advertisement
Advertisement

IBF Explain Why Jamie McDonnell Decision Was Upheld

By Terence Dooley

The IBF have explained to BoxingScene exactly why they have upheld their decision to strip Jamie McDonnell of his bantamweight title for failing to tie down his mandatory defence against Vusi Malinga by the organisation’s November 11 deadline.

An appeal against their decision was made on McDonnell’s behalf by Eddie Hearn of Matchroom last week, but the IBF decided that there aren't sufficient grounds for an appeal despite McDonnell releasing an emotive eleventh hour statement urging the governing body to reconsider his case.

The IBF, though, have stood by their decision.  ‘The grounds for an appeal are very specific,’ they stated.  ‘Based on the IBF rules, he has no grounds to appeal the IBF’s decision to vacate the Bantamweight title.  Rule 12.A of the IBF/USBA Rules Governing Championship Contests cites the grounds for appeal which are: 1. Miscalculation of the score where the correct score would change the outcome of the fight; 2. Inappropriate conduct by the referee which is alleged to have affected the outcome of the fight; 3. Misconduct on the part of the judges or referee which is alleged to have had a material effect on the outcome of the fight; 4. Imposition of penalties under Rule 14; and 5.  Any other alleged violation of the rules of the IBF/USBA that may have a detrimental effect on the rights of the complainant.

‘In a letter Jamie McDonnell outlined various disputes he has had with his promoter Dennis Hobson.  However, the IBF does not get involved in contractual disputes between promoters and boxers or boxers and managers. 

‘The IBF is upholding its decision to vacate the bantamweight title.  This is an unfortunate situation and we hope that he can resolve his issues and get his career back on track.  IBF President Daryl Peoples has recommended that the ratings committee take into consideration Jamie McDonnell's situation and the information he presented in his letter when compiling next month's ratings.’

It means that South Africa's Malinga and Darlington’s Stuart Hall, who is managed by Hobson and rated at number three, are likely to contest the vacant crown, either in December or possibly January.  It leaves McDonnell sweating on the IBF’s next ratings committee meeting.  The best-case scenario is that they install him as the mandatory challenger, which means that whoever wins the vacant title will have to defend against McDonnell within six months as per IBF rules.

McDonnell, though, will take little or no comfort from this.  The 27-year-old picked up the belt with a battling decision win over Julio Ceja at Doncaster’s Keepmoat Stadium in May.  However, that fight could pale into insignificance compared to the dual battle he faces against former handler Hobson — McDonnell claimed to have determined his contract with Hobson only for Dennis Hobson Promotions to issue a statement to the contrary — and the IBF, should the fighter opt to continue contesting their decision in the hope of having it overturned.

It means that, for the time being, McDonnell's next big fight will take place outside, rather than inside, the boxing ring.

McDonnell announces his decision to split with Hobson:

http://www.boxingscene.com/ibf-moves-strip-jamie-mcdonnell-hearn-appeal--70743

Dennis Hobson Promotions respond:

http://www.boxingscene.com/hobson-reacts-jamie-mcdonnells-termination-claim--70429

The original news story outlining the IBF’s decision:

http://www.boxingscene.com/ibf-moves-strip-jamie-mcdonnell-hearn-appeal--70743

Statement from Dennis Hobson Promotions about the IBF’s decision:

http://www.boxingscene.com/hobson-comments-on-mcdonnell-being-stripped-by-ibf--70747

Jamie McDonnell’s plea to the IBF:

http://www.boxingscene.com/jamie-mcdonnell-reacts-ibfs-decision-strip-him--70885

Please send news and views to [email protected] or Twitter @Terryboxing.

Tags: Jamie McDonnell image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by techliam on 10-23-2013

[QUOTE=sterling;13868104]wtf this sounds quite stupid lol[/QUOTE] It's not the IBF's fault McDonnell and co. are having hissy fits with eachother. The team need to get it sorted

Comment by sterling on 10-23-2013

wtf this sounds quite stupid lol

Post a Comment/View More User Comments (2)
Top Headlines Bellew vs. Makabu: Sean Dodd Looks To Enter The World Scene Viktor Postol Motivated By Underdog Role Against Crawford Arum: If Mayweather Wants Pacquiao, Let Him Come To Manila Haumono Saw Flaws, Believes He Will Chin Check Joseph Parker Glowacki Hopes To Get Usyk To Poland, Then Wants Lebedev Avanesyan Ends Shane Mosley, Secures Thurman-Porter Shot Vazquez Outpoints Bone, Eyes Future Clash With Adrien Broner Gabe Rosado Not Looking Past Gutierrez To Chavez Jr. Showdown Shane Mosley Jr. Edges Roberto Young With Majority Nod Bermane Stiverne Eager To Step in, Face Deontay Wilder Jonas Sultan Retains His RP Championship With KO in Five Rounds Photos: Verdejo, Diaz Open Workouts Before HUGE Bronx Crowd Roach: Floyd Mayweather Asked Me To Train Conor McGregor Krzysztof Wlodarczyk Beats Down Kai Kurzawa For TKO Win Ricky Burns Becomes Three Division Champion, Stops Di Rocco in 8 Nurse Pounds on Limond For TKO Win, Retains British Title WADA To Meet With AIBA, Shocking Allegations Over Drug Testing Conor Benn Wins In Glasgow, Returns on Joshua-Breazeale McCarthy Beats Jon-Lewis Dickinson, Must Face Askin Next Povetkin Questions Whether Wilder Actually Intended To Fight Him Burns-Di Rocco: Ogogo Wins On Return Mosley: They Said I Was Done, I'm Going To Annihilate Avanesyan! Ricky Burns: I Feel I Definitely Have Another Few Years in Me Donnie Nietes Drops, Punishes and Stops Raul Garcia Photos: Lucian Bute Holds Presser, Maintains His Innocence Cecilia Braekhus is Hoping To Stage Title Defense in Norway DiBella: Haye's Last Bout Hard To Watch, Not in Running For Wilder Avanesyan Tabs Thurman To Beat Porter, Ready For Mosley Weights From Liverpool: Bellew 199.1; Makabu 196.8 Golovkin's Coach: Canelo Would Drill Pacquiao Worse Than Khan! Lara's Trainer: Golovkin Should Want To Test Himself Against Lara Frank Warren: Kell Brook Wanted No Part of Liam Smith Hearn: Ricky Burns' Last Chance To Win Gold, a 50-50 Fight Tony Bellew Smiles: I Was Always a Rebellious Little F***er! Hearn Wants Parker To Get UK Exposure To Build Joshua Bout Video: Shane Mosley Shows Off His Power and Speed at Workout Marquez Injured, Stops Training - But Still Has Eye on Miguel Cotto Barthelemy: I Want To Fight The Likes of Crawford and Broner Dela Torre Injures Right Hand, Admits Improvement is Needed Photos: Orlando Salido Closes Camp For Francisco Vargas War
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement