Castillo v Floyd I "It's not the fight we saw"

Wiley Hyena

Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw."

I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see?

MVOLT

i saw the greatest LW since Whitaker get robbed

Imatroll

Floyd received a boxing lesson and was in survival mode

MANIAC310

Castillo won pretty clearly.....

this thread gets made every two weeks and it always ends with Castillo winning the poll

Floyd's die hard fans are going to come in spam and say

-Floyd had a shoulder injury
-It was a close fight that Floyd won
-Floyd beat him in the rematch which proved the beating Floyd took in the first fight didn't actually happen.

paulf

First time I watched it (live), I agreed that Castillo got robbed.

Watched it a year ago and scored it for Floyd.

Do we really need to have this thread every two weeks?

LA_2_Vegas · 01:08 AM

I just chalk it up to Castillo's own (translated) quote about the scoring during the post fight interview: "...it was a complicated fight.."

Imatroll

So what if Floyd lost, he's only human. Nobody can be perfect. Losing is a part of life.

iseah100

Listen, I love Castillo, and I really don't care for Floyd. But it was a close fight that could have gone either way. I scored it for Castillo but I could see Floyd winning.

damit305

Gotta agree with MVOLT on this one:

"Floyd's die hard fans are going to come in spam and say

-Floyd had a shoulder injury
-It was a close fight that Floyd won
-Floyd beat him in the rematch which proved the beating Floyd took in the first fight didn't actually happen."

Wiley Hyena

Quote:

Originally Posted by Imatroll

So what if Floyd lost, he's only human. Nobody can be perfect. Losing is a part of life.

Well ok. So Floyd lost a fight. Does that disqualify him from being the GOAT?

View Poll Results: Who won Castillo v Floyd I?
Floyd Mayweather	50	34.48%
Jose Luis Castillo	95	65.52%
Voters: 145. You may not vote on this poll

Wiley Hyena Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 4,060 Rep Power: 16 Points: 202,671.69 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 202,671.69 Donate	Castillo v Floyd I "It's not the fight we saw" Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw." I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see?

MVOLT Banned Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: haters Posts: 597 Rep Power: 0 Points: 58,596.14 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 58,596.14 Donate	i saw the greatest LW since Whitaker get robbed

Imatroll Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 2,145 Rep Power: 11 Points: 100,187,500.80 Bank: 209,928,205.81 Total Points: 310,115,706.61 Donate	Floyd received a boxing lesson and was in survival mode

MANIAC310 MAINYUCK3100 Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Los Angeles Posts: 20,929 Rep Power: 230 Points: 28,757,442,501.60 Bank: 629,109,791,013,740.75 Total Points: 629,138,548,456,242.38 Donate	Castillo won pretty clearly..... this thread gets made every two weeks and it always ends with Castillo winning the poll Floyd's die hard fans are going to come in spam and say -Floyd had a shoulder injury -It was a close fight that Floyd won -Floyd beat him in the rematch which proved the beating Floyd took in the first fight didn't actually happen.

paulf Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Back In The USA! (Oklahoma) Posts: 9,102 Rep Power: 26 Points: 6,080,577,622.75 Bank: 109.20 Total Points: 6,080,577,731.95 Donate	First time I watched it (live), I agreed that Castillo got robbed. Watched it a year ago and scored it for Floyd. Do we really need to have this thread every two weeks?

LA_2_Vegas Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Los Angeles Posts: 1,741 Rep Power: 9 Points: 501,335,736.15 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 501,335,736.15 Donate	I just chalk it up to Castillo's own (translated) quote about the scoring during the post fight interview: "...it was a complicated fight.." Last edited by LA_2_Vegas; 12-31-2012 at 01:08 AM.

iseah100 Interim Champion Join Date: Dec 2010 Age: 18 Posts: 836 Rep Power: 4 Points: 1,000,007,230.66 Bank: 2,164,891,128.26 Total Points: 3,164,898,358.92 Donate	Listen, I love Castillo, and I really don't care for Floyd. But it was a close fight that could have gone either way. I scored it for Castillo but I could see Floyd winning.

damit305 Undisputed Champion Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: At South Beach with Nacho Posts: 1,127 Rep Power: 11 Points: 51,595.37 Bank: 1,268,241.79 Total Points: 1,319,837.16 Donate	Gotta agree with MVOLT on this one: "Floyd's die hard fans are going to come in spam and say -Floyd had a shoulder injury -It was a close fight that Floyd won -Floyd beat him in the rematch which proved the beating Floyd took in the first fight didn't actually happen."