Broner ranked #5 P4P by ring magazine WTF? - Page 4

Walt Liquor

Pfp lists are a joke anyway but this is pathetic.

Ring is now shi t. I hate all their writers except duggie. Time to write the mailbag.

Phenom

don't know how any one can say Ward cleaned out his division he beat Froch which is a great win but other then that he has fought any of top 5 bute or Dirrell brothers.
except for Kessler over 3 years ago I wouldnt call beating Bika and Green cleaning out a division

teddycanyon

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phenom

don't know how any one can say Ward cleaned out his division he beat Froch which is a great win but other then that he has fought any of top 5 bute or Dirrell brothers.
except for Kessler over 3 years ago I wouldnt call beating Bika and Green cleaning out a division

he holds wins over all of the current beltholders, if that's any indication of his dominance.

Reti

Who is Broner's promoter?

Who owns Ring Magazine?

mathed

Sure, why not? I mean DeMarco was like P4P #2 right?

Walt Liquor

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freedom.

I'm not going to place any faith in the Ring ratings any more. I've just deleted The Ring website from the favorites I look at every day.

Cliff Rold's boxingscene rankings are better.

Interestingly, there used to be about 30 people vote on the Ring rankings, now there's only Chuck Giampa and these 9 guys:

Mike Coppinger
Martin Mulcahey
Mark Ortega
Ryan Maquinana
Ryan Songalia
Harry Pratt
Anson Wainwright
Joe Koizumi
Corey Erdman

The only stsnd up person on there is Mulcahey IMO. He better resign his vote over this.

Optimistic

Amazing.

Reti

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phenom

don't know how any one can say Ward cleaned out his division he beat Froch which is a great win but other then that he has fought any of top 5 bute or Dirrell brothers.
except for Kessler over 3 years ago I wouldnt call beating Bika and Green cleaning out a division

Great sig. Who is the old man sticking his hand into the frame?

El Angel

I got Broner in my top 10 P4P, but not at five. He scrapes in at 10, I believe he's more P4P worthy than Orlando Salido for example. Guerrero should not be there. He hasn't shown skills worthy of P4P yet.

thuggery

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reti

Who is Broner's promoter?

Who owns Ring Magazine?

Ding ding ding..

View Poll Results: Does Broner deserve to be #5 on the top ten P4P
Yes, at age 23 he's already a two-division champion	11	11.70%
No, beating DeMarco is not sufficient to merit a spot above Pacquiao and Donaire	70	74.47%
Maybe Ring Magazine liked his grillz in his interview with Kellerman.	13	13.83%
Voters: 94. You may not vote on this poll

Walt Liquor the opposite of pure Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: East Broward Posts: 32,744 Rep Power: 95 Points: 10,482,500,134,801.88 Bank: 3,519,174,279,467.96 Total Points: 14,001,674,414,269.84 Donate	Pfp lists are a joke anyway but this is pathetic. Ring is now shi t. I hate all their writers except duggie. Time to write the mailbag.

Phenom Phenomatthyse Join Date: May 2010 Posts: 4,312 Rep Power: 11 Points: 4,704.58 Bank: 206,475,731,585.63 Total Points: 206,475,736,290.21 Donate	don't know how any one can say Ward cleaned out his division he beat Froch which is a great win but other then that he has fought any of top 5 bute or Dirrell brothers. except for Kessler over 3 years ago I wouldnt call beating Bika and Green cleaning out a division

Reti Amateur Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 18 Rep Power: 0 Points: 1,486.16 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,486.16 Donate	Who is Broner's promoter? Who owns Ring Magazine?

mathed Golovkin is the G.O.A.T! Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: The driver's seat Posts: 29,034 Rep Power: 75 Points: 740,437.87 Bank: 924,326,163,050.76 Total Points: 924,326,903,488.63 Donate	Sure, why not? I mean DeMarco was like P4P #2 right?

Optimistic So(ul) Amazin' Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: Fajardo, PR Posts: 1,983 Rep Power: 21 Points: 13,761.53 Bank: 67,161,595,480.72 Total Points: 67,161,609,242.25 Donate	Amazing.

El Angel Team Cotto Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 9,146 Rep Power: 33 Points: 735.46 Bank: 13,651,580,263,066.47 Total Points: 13,651,580,263,801.93 Donate	I got Broner in my top 10 P4P, but not at five. He scrapes in at 10, I believe he's more P4P worthy than Orlando Salido for example. Guerrero should not be there. He hasn't shown skills worthy of P4P yet.