broner vs prime sugar shane mayweather and whitaker@135lbs

The Viper

Not saying he could beat them, cause in my opinions there the best lightweights in the last twenty years....but could he hold his own against them?

Mato o Muero

No they would dominate him.

Capaedia

Castillo is the best lightweight since Whitaker.

Not Mosley. Who did he beat to prove that against? I think he was a better welterweight than lightweight, his resume certainly backs that up.

And Broner has only had one fight at LW, how are we supposed to judge this?

nachorjj

Broner loss against this 3

gmc_rfc_06

Broner is looking a very good fighter with all the tools required.

He's not ****ing with any version of Mayweather, not a chance. Not sure how he takes a punch to survive being stopped by Mosley (I'd go Mosley though) and his skill level isn't proven against top guys to suggest he could deal with Whitaker.

dibzvincent143

Duran should be there. Duran is the best lightweight and would KO any of the three. Broner has a lot to prove and his on his way to greatness, Props to him and I hope he'll do it right what floyd didn't.

TX_BOXNG

i think they would beat him

Dr Rumack

Quote:

Originally Posted by dibzvincent143

Duran should be there. Duran is the best lightweight and would KO any of the three. Broner has a lot to prove and his on his way to greatness, Props to him and I hope he'll do it right what floyd didn't.

Duran last fought lightweight in 1978, but yeah, he starches just about anyone at 135lbs.

Ryn0

Mosley at LW is a different beast, Roger Mayweather (or Floyd Sr.) I can't remember who said it described the two versions the best.

Mosley at lightweight was like a machine gun, combinations movement, constant punching. When he moved up to Welterweight he was more like a shotgun, looking for that big overhand right or left hook. Mosley at Welter became a lot more predictable but was still a great fighter.

I'd pick both Mosley and Whittaker over Broner, Broner has had one fight at 135 and Demarco isn't anywhere near Whittaker or Mosleys class.

bojangles1987

Broner doesn't deserve to be mentioned on the same page as Whitaker, let alone the same paragraph or sentence.

I think him and Mosley would come down to Broner's chin. If he could take some bombs, that could be a really good fight. No way I'd pick Broner though, Mosley deserves more respect than that.

The Viper Up and Comer Join Date: Oct 2012 Posts: 75 Rep Power: 1 Points: 37,538.96 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 37,538.96 Donate	broner vs prime sugar shane mayweather and whitaker@135lbs Not saying he could beat them, cause in my opinions there the best lightweights in the last twenty years....but could he hold his own against them?

Mato o Muero Banned Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 754 Rep Power: 0 Points: 20,213.99 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 20,213.99 Donate	No they would dominate him.

Capaedia JMM Stan Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Auckland, New Zealand Posts: 2,660 Rep Power: 16 Points: 143,850,501,423.86 Bank: 1,522,464,202.26 Total Points: 145,372,965,626.12 Donate	Castillo is the best lightweight since Whitaker. Not Mosley. Who did he beat to prove that against? I think he was a better welterweight than lightweight, his resume certainly backs that up. And Broner has only had one fight at LW, how are we supposed to judge this?

nachorjj Undisputed Champion Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 1,964 Rep Power: 0 Points: 102,291,393.65 Bank: 1,309,561.49 Total Points: 103,600,955.14 Donate	Broner loss against this 3

gmc_rfc_06 Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: Glasgow Posts: 2,815 Rep Power: 11 Points: 1,005,026,123.22 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,005,026,123.22 Donate	Broner is looking a very good fighter with all the tools required. He's not ****ing with any version of Mayweather, not a chance. Not sure how he takes a punch to survive being stopped by Mosley (I'd go Mosley though) and his skill level isn't proven against top guys to suggest he could deal with Whitaker.

dibzvincent143 Undisputed Champion Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Iloilo City, Philippines Age: 21 Posts: 1,776 Rep Power: 10 Points: 104,080,238.70 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 104,080,238.70 Donate	Duran should be there. Duran is the best lightweight and would KO any of the three. Broner has a lot to prove and his on his way to greatness, Props to him and I hope he'll do it right what floyd didn't.

TX_BOXNG Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: TEJAZTLAN Posts: 2,450 Rep Power: 8 Points: 5,170,025,268.28 Bank: 14,292,374,169.01 Total Points: 19,462,399,437.29 Donate	i think they would beat him

bojangles1987 bojangles1897 Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Hudson, Fl Posts: 21,803 Rep Power: 68 Points: 257,000,122,567.03 Bank: 10,894,984,482.97 Total Points: 267,895,107,050.00 Donate	Broner doesn't deserve to be mentioned on the same page as Whitaker, let alone the same paragraph or sentence. I think him and Mosley would come down to Broner's chin. If he could take some bombs, that could be a really good fight. No way I'd pick Broner though, Mosley deserves more respect than that.