Rank these recent greats - Page 2

SCtrojansbaby

Winky underrated as usual

Cardinal Buck

No, he's not. He never was that great pfp. At his best, he was struggling with guys like Vargas, Harry Simon, and others. His best wins were against Mosley who really wasn't very good at 154 and had already been figured out by Forrest. Trinidad was done by the time they fought. I don't think he'd ever beat P Williams to be honest. He'd cover up too much and lose a decision. There's no way in hell he's better than Tyson, DLH, Morales or Toney pfp.

SCtrojansbaby · 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardinal Buck

No, he's not. He never was that great pfp. At his best, he was struggling with guys like Vargas, Harry Simon, and others. His best wins were against Mosley who really wasn't very good at 154 and had already been figured out by Forrest. Trinidad was done by the time they fought. I don't think he'd ever beat P Williams to be honest. He'd cover up too much and lose a decision. There's no way in hell he's better than Tyson, DLH, Morales or Toney pfp.

Did you just start watching boxing 3 years ago, Winky was considered top 3 P4P. His fight with Vargas was a total robbery.

licari123

Quote:

Originally Posted by $ j-210 $

1. morales
2. tyson
3. DLH
4. wright
5. toney
6. mosley
7. tszyu

Dito.

10char

Scott9945

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCtrojansbaby

Did you just start watching boxing 3 years ago, Winky was considered top 3 P4P. His fight with Vargas was a total robbery.

When exactly was Winky ever in the top 3 P4P?

Cardinal Buck

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCtrojansbaby

Didyou just start watching boxing after Winky was considered top 2 P4P. He also gave Vargas a boxing lesson.

Compared to the others listed, he isn't special. His ranking was based on beating Mosley who wasn't that good at 154 and a sh itty Trinidad. The Vargas fight was a close fight, and he lost on the scorecards because he let Vargas throw more punches. He's close to Tsyzu at least, but no way on the top end of the list.

Cardinal Buck

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott9945

When exactly was Winky ever in the top 3 P4P?

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...r_Pound--2000s

Scott9945

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardinal Buck

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...r_Pound--2000s

Thanks. I guess that shows that I don't take P4P lists very seriously.

IronDanHamza

Winky Wright, overrated as usual.

BennyST

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCtrojansbaby

Winky underrated as usual

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCtrojansbaby

Did you just start watching boxing 3 years ago, Winky was considered top 3 P4P. His fight with Vargas was a total robbery.

Classic case of using what you want when it suits you ey? Hypocrite much?

You've always slagged Tzsyu as a terrible fighter, and yet he was in the top ten P4P for twice as long as Wright, also got to P4P 3rd but when it works in Wright's favour you use it as proof that he was great...For Tzsyu the whole P4P Ring ranking system is just BS and doesn't make sense though right?

SCtrojansbaby Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 5,509 Blog Entries: 2 Rep Power: 15 Points: 30,236,578.63 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 30,236,578.63 Donate	Winky underrated as usual

IronDanHamza All Time Great Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 17,625 Rep Power: 47 Points: 262,341,019.89 Bank: 1,656,055,610,217.15 Total Points: 1,656,317,951,237.04 Donate	Winky Wright, overrated as usual.