was micheal spinks underated?

rightsideup

He was undisputed lw champ and the linial hw champ until he ran into the tyson tornado.? I personally thought he did not win both holmes fights but he was right there.

poet682006

Well, since it seems like 90% of posters around here only seem to think he's just the dude that got flattened in 81 seconds, I'd say yes he's underrated. The posters who know boxing DON'T underrate him though and acknowledge he was an ATG Light-Heavy.

Poet

Mintcar923

Quote:

Originally Posted by rightsideup

He was undisputed lw champ and the linial hw champ until he ran into the tyson tornado.? I personally thought he did not win both holmes fights but he was right there.

He was known as one of the greatest light heavyweights ever. Looking back, he was a very original boxer. He had a very awkward style that had frustrated many of his opponents including Larry Holmes. I suppose Larry wasn't quite at his best during those fights. But, even to beat an older version of him you gotta be damn good!

It appeared as though Tyson totally had his number and he knew it. That was perhaps the reason he left the sport. He was supposed to make a comeback a couple of years after his loss to Mike but it never happened. However, he may have been pretty successful being Tyson was away in jail. Holyfield-Spinks would have been very interesting...

NChristo

One of the best boxers I've ever seen, period, the man was incredible.

Massively under rated by the average boxing fan who only remembers him for the Tyson fight, rated accordingly by those that know him for clearing out one of the strongest Light Heavy eras ever.

Cloud

Easily an the ATG Light Heavyweight.

Sadly, he's only remembered by the casuals as the guy Tyson mopped up in 1 round.

TBear · 06:49 AM

I ran into Michael Spinks at a fight when I was a young fan when he got on an elevator I was on.

I remember reading that he was considering a move to heavyweight and I wanted to tell him so bad that it was a dangerous move and maybe he should consider fighting at cruiserweight first. I wanted to tell him I didn't want to see him being beaten like Bob Foster was all those years before.

But being awestruck the only thing that could come out of my mouth was "Hey Michael". Spinks smiled at me and said "Hey" Back.

A couple years later he suprised many by winning the heavyweight title. Perhaps Spinks is underrated by a few but I think most true boxing fans hold him in very high regard.

jabsRstiff

Absolutely underrated.

He was truly a great 175lber....and when there he was one of the hardest punchers I have ever seen since I started following boxing in '81.

Despite the Tyson performance, which is what really has lead to his being underrated, he was pretty damn good at heavyweight. Very impressive for a naturally smaller man to have accomplished.

One of my all-time "dream fights" would to have had him at Cruiserweight in 1987 and taking on Holyfield, who was just so awesome at the time.

SBleeder

Top 5 all time LHW in my book, which makes him a legend any way you slice it.

The Tyson debacle has no bearing on his legacy... or at least it shouldn't.

Ray Corso · 12:48 PM

Mike was a very good Lt. Heavy and NOT a very good Heavy!! He was a terrific Middle in the amatuers and he and Leon cleaned up in the Olympics at Middle and Lt. Heavy (Leon)!!!
He lost to Holmes that was clear and the pay back from the Vegas boys for Holmes's big mouth about Marciano was evident!!! Thats what happened!!!
Spinks at 175 against a young 175 Holyfield would be interesting but at Cruiser Holyfield was too strong for Spinks. A very good fighter that to me is a HoF boxer but NOT an all time great. Theres alot of LtHeavies that fit right into his level and I'd guess he's a top 20 guy without giving it to much thought.
Yaqui Lopez
Bob Foster
Bob Montgomery
Saad Mohamed
Dwight Quawi
Eddie Mustafa
Victor Galandez
Evander Holyfield
Archie Moore
Duvale'
R.J.Jones
........................theres ALOT of very good LtHeavies................Ray.

NChristo · 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ray Corso

Mike was a very good Lt. Heavy and NOT a very good Heavy!! He was a terrific Middle in the amatuers and he and Leon cleaned up in the Olympics at Middle and Lt. Heavy (Leon)!!!
He lost to Holmes that was clear and the pay back from the Vegas boys for Holmes's big mouth about Marciano was evident!!! Thats what happened!!!
Spinks at 175 against a young 175 Holyfield would be interesting but at Cruiser Holyfield was too strong for Spinks. A very good fighter that to me is a HoF boxer but NOT an all time great. Theres alot of LtHeavies that fit right into his level and I'd guess he's a top 20 guy without giving it to much thought.
Yaqui Lopez
Bob Foster
Bob Montgomery
Saad Mohamed
Dwight Quawi
Eddie Mustafa
Victor Galandez
Evander Holyfield
Archie Moore
Duvale'
R.J.Jones
........................theres ALOT of very good LtHeavies................Ray.

Qawi, Lopez and EMM are on the same level as Spinks ?.

Bob Montgomery was a lightweight.

Galindez and Duvale are not on Spinks' level, neither is Holyfield at Light Heavy.

rightsideup Interim Champion Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 748 Rep Power: 6 Points: 5,200,174,038.71 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 5,200,174,038.71 Donate	was micheal spinks underated? He was undisputed lw champ and the linial hw champ until he ran into the tyson tornado.? I personally thought he did not win both holmes fights but he was right there.

poet682006 All-Time Great Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Tacoma, Washington USA Age: 45 Posts: 16,303 Rep Power: 50 Points: 2,378.79 Bank: 636,211,202,404.35 Total Points: 636,211,204,783.14 Donate	Well, since it seems like 90% of posters around here only seem to think he's just the dude that got flattened in 81 seconds, I'd say yes he's underrated. The posters who know boxing DON'T underrate him though and acknowledge he was an ATG Light-Heavy. Poet

NChristo Morning Glory Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Blackpool Posts: 4,882 Rep Power: 15 Points: 1,000,015,941.59 Bank: 471,651,983,135.21 Total Points: 472,651,999,076.80 Donate	One of the best boxers I've ever seen, period, the man was incredible. Massively under rated by the average boxing fan who only remembers him for the Tyson fight, rated accordingly by those that know him for clearing out one of the strongest Light Heavy eras ever.

Cloud Banned Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Leeds, UK Age: 20 Posts: 1,715 Rep Power: 0 Points: 5,036,923.01 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 5,036,923.01 Donate	Easily an the ATG Light Heavyweight. Sadly, he's only remembered by the casuals as the guy Tyson mopped up in 1 round.

SBleeder Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2010 Location: Indiana Age: 32 Posts: 1,807 Rep Power: 7 Points: 5,211,555.50 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 5,211,555.50 Donate	Top 5 all time LHW in my book, which makes him a legend any way you slice it. The Tyson debacle has no bearing on his legacy... or at least it shouldn't.