Roy Jones versus Ray Robinson at 160 who wins and why - Page 4

res

Quote:

Originally Posted by Easy-E

Robinson had a suspect chin as well. He was knocked down many times by sub par opposition.

LOL@ SRR has a suspect chin

It's not knock downs that define a suspect chin, it's knockouts. a man that takes 15 rounds of shots from a Middleweight when he's a Welter, and 14 rounds of shots from a light heavy when he's a Middleweight does not have a suspect chin.

SeivUrBref · 07:51 PM

Sugar ray Robinson for the fact that even though his best was welterweight. At middleweight he was still a legend killer and still had one punch knockout power with either hand and still threw punches in bunches and had an excellent sense of bout progression and yes Roy would do well too but I would consider rays ring iq superior and he WOULD land on Roy and how long could roy s chin hold up. Ray Robinson isn't no Monte barret chin guy. He would eat whatever speed /power shot came and time counters.....offensive smart combination punches..not pacquiao flailing punches.

FaustoGeraci

More votes for Roy Jones, his glass jaw and lack of heart...than the greatest of all time. This forum is officially hot garbage.

FaustoGeraci

Quote:

Originally Posted by res

LOL@ SRR has a suspect chin

It's not knock downs that define a suspect chin, it's knockouts. a man that takes 15 rounds of shots from a Middleweight when he's a Welter, and 14 rounds of shots from a light heavy when he's a Middleweight does not have a suspect chin.

Don't even bother with these clowns. This place is a mess now.

BennyST

Whoops. I accidentally chose Robinson when I meant to choose Roy. Roy was a natural 175 pound guy, Robinson a natural 147.

Alx.

roy jones for obvious reasons at 160

Rome-By-Ko

RR wins,no matter what Roy's chin was not tested because nobody he fought at the time was able to test it...Ray Robinson would test it all night long and put Roy to sleep in the mid rds..Roy was one of the most talented fighters I've ever seen..But he fought at a time when other fighters were not as physically gifted...Ray had the ability to fight any kinda fight you wanted to fight..I just can't see Roy winning this fight at all..

Optimistic

SRR tbh....

Capaedia

I think Robinson catches up to Roy and knocks him out late, behind on the scorecards.

View Poll Results: Who takes it?
SRR	27	42.86%
Roy Jones Jr	36	57.14%
Voters: 63. You may not vote on this poll

FaustoGeraci Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2008 Age: 26 Posts: 1,453 Rep Power: 7 Points: 5,867,085.68 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 5,867,085.68 Donate	More votes for Roy Jones, his glass jaw and lack of heart...than the greatest of all time. This forum is officially hot garbage.

BennyST Shhhh... Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Australia Posts: 8,627 Rep Power: 52 Points: 20,233,060,122.92 Bank: 79,883,758,097.45 Total Points: 100,116,818,220.37 Donate	Whoops. I accidentally chose Robinson when I meant to choose Roy. Roy was a natural 175 pound guy, Robinson a natural 147.

Alx. U mirin? Join Date: May 2011 Location: Bucharest Posts: 4,238 Rep Power: 14 Points: 5,200,235,935.35 Bank: 783,283,717,199.77 Total Points: 788,483,953,135.12 Donate	roy jones for obvious reasons at 160

Optimistic So(ul) Amazin' Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: Fajardo, PR Posts: 1,983 Rep Power: 21 Points: 14,241.53 Bank: 68,504,827,390.34 Total Points: 68,504,841,631.87 Donate	SRR tbh....

Capaedia JMM Stan Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Auckland, New Zealand Posts: 2,715 Rep Power: 16 Points: 143,850,502,926.65 Bank: 1,930,852,732.03 Total Points: 145,781,355,658.68 Donate	I think Robinson catches up to Roy and knocks him out late, behind on the scorecards.