Create a fighter P4P that would take Sugar Ray Robinsons place as GOAT - Page 2

therealpugilist

sad thing is no one will get over SRR..who was great...but wasnt flawless......there are guys if you look at the whole package could be ranked higher....boxing guys like old folks are stuck in their ways, you hear it being said enough then its a fact, look at history/ HIS STORY....In my eyes Henry Armstrong was the GOAT...just my view

B Phontain

Ali's foot work, hearns power, tysons head movement, Mayweathers timing and Defence. Hopkins or Mayweathers ring smarts, Margarito's chin (lol), Gatti's heart. RJJ hand speed. Dempsy's roll (entertainment value lol) and klitz jab.......Is that good enough?

I chose to add intangibles on top of skill set, because i think sometimes its the intangibles that decide fights, not just boxing ability......i might have just created a monster.....

JAB5239

No need to create a fighter, both Sam Langford and Harry Greb are greater than Robinson in my opinion.

B Phontain

My bad, i just read where u said using only 3 fighters in history.....Ok

Mayweather with Olivares punching power is all you'll need.....

Travdog · 12:52 PM

Floyd's Boxing IQ, Defense, Timing, Chin
Jones' Speed and Reflexes
Pacquaio's Power, Tenacity and Fighting Spirit

ab4life

Quote:

Originally Posted by B Phontain

My bad, i just read where u said using only 3 fighters in history.....Ok

Mayweather with Olivares punching power is all you'll need.....

You think that's enough to take the greatest of all time spot though?

4Corners

3 fighters, my bad.

Mayweather's D.
Ali's hand and foot speed.
Chuvalo's chin.

That could beat him to a decision.

915angel

Quote:

Originally Posted by MANIAC310

Marquez's boxing skills,
Marquez's combinations ,
Marquez's Heart ,
Margarito's chin,
RJJ's reflexes
Whitaker's defense
Julian Jackson's power,
Meldrick Taylor's speed

gamboas combos

gatti's heart

gatti's chin

prime mayweather reflexes

russle jr's speed

winky wright defense

kirklands power

therealpugilist

Quote:

Originally Posted by JAB5239

No need to create a fighter, both Sam Langford and Harry Greb are greater than Robinson in my opinion.

i have to agree,,,Sam was a natural welter beating heavies....people have short memories.....Greb was a beast to...Robinson was great but his comp wasnt **** outside Gavilan till moving to 160 and past prime...tommy bell hmmmmm

lx!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by MalikKnucklez

floyd's shoulders, tyson's teeth, margarito's gloves and peterson's testosterone.

LOL!!! Hahahaha!!! This $h!+ made me crack up!!! Thanks I needed that.

therealpugilist Interim Champion Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 613 Rep Power: 3 Points: 80,899.84 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 80,899.84 Donate	sad thing is no one will get over SRR..who was great...but wasnt flawless......there are guys if you look at the whole package could be ranked higher....boxing guys like old folks are stuck in their ways, you hear it being said enough then its a fact, look at history/ HIS STORY....In my eyes Henry Armstrong was the GOAT...just my view

JAB5239 Banned Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Statesville, NC Posts: 18,898 Rep Power: 0 Points: 7,503.10 Bank: 4,382,134,577,859.27 Total Points: 4,382,134,585,362.37 Donate	No need to create a fighter, both Sam Langford and Harry Greb are greater than Robinson in my opinion.

B Phontain Contender Join Date: Dec 2011 Age: 26 Posts: 315 Rep Power: 2 Points: 3,514,180.10 Bank: 230,302,233.27 Total Points: 233,816,413.37 Donate	My bad, i just read where u said using only 3 fighters in history.....Ok Mayweather with Olivares punching power is all you'll need.....

Travdog Contender Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 375 Rep Power: 0 Points: 34,852.65 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 34,852.65 Donate	Floyd's Boxing IQ, Defense, Timing, Chin Jones' Speed and Reflexes Pacquaio's Power, Tenacity and Fighting Spirit Last edited by Travdog; 05-11-2012 at 12:52 PM. Reason: You said three my bad

4Corners Desert Eagle Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Colorado Posts: 10,960 Rep Power: 31 Points: 200,105,553,642.16 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 200,105,553,642.16 Donate	3 fighters, my bad. Mayweather's D. Ali's hand and foot speed. Chuvalo's chin. That could beat him to a decision.