Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[crold1]

Originally Posted by UglyPug

Only one of those really comparable is Homicide Hank. . . Lol it's still funny that just about every fight he had was contested at a catchweight.

But to the TS's question, Pac has the better resume. . . Pac is the best southpaw of all time. . . .

Morales TWICE, Mab TWICE, Marquez TWICE? Cotto? Hatton (at his natural weight). . . CLottey (who everybody seems to underrated for some reason - but seeing how Pac is the ONLY BOXER to EVER beat him so one-sidedly). . .

Not to mention his slew of other wins against world champs, and fringe world class guys.

yeah, but Hank came down for smaller guys. His catches favored foes (not that it mattered considering how small he was). when he went up, it was at the bigger man's limit.

Hank ruled.

[UglyPug]

Originally Posted by crold1

yeah, but Hank came down for smaller guys. His catches favored foes (not that it mattered considering how small he was). when he went up, it was at the bigger man's limit.

Hank ruled.

Agree. . . It's hard not to have him in the top 5 best fighters of all time.

[Since 1985]

Originally Posted by UglyPug

Im not saying Pac would beat Whitaker. . . I honestly don't know. . . Whitaker had a better all around skillset. . But Pac has a better resume, and is thereby deserving to be ranked higher than Pea. .

Whitaker would make Pacquiao look like a silly amateur. I can't believe how highly some people think about Manny.

[Check_hooks]

People overrate Whitaker and his jukeing and jiving style horrendously.

He wouldn't have the power to hurt Pac and he himself has a glass jaw which we saw from the Trinidad fight. And Trinidad doesn't have the combination of power and speed like Pac

Pac would beat him down badly and eventually get tired of chaseing him around the ring like Cotto and Mosley

Theres also a 50-50 chance he gets hattoned

[crold1]

Originally Posted by Check_hooks

People overrate Whitaker and his jukeing and jiving style horrendously.

He wouldn't have the power to hurt Pac and he himself has a glass jaw which we saw from the Trinidad fight. And Trinidad doesn't have the combination of power and speed like Pac

Pac would beat him down badly and eventually get tired of chaseing him around the ring like Cotto and Mosley

Theres also a 50-50 chance he gets hattoned

Glass jaw? He went 12 way past his prime with a fractured jaw in that fight.

[Roman Moreno]

IMO Whitaker has the greatest resume than any fighter in the last 25 years. I don't think there has been a greater fighter than Whitaker in the last 25 years.

[djtmal]

Originally Posted by Check_hooks

People overrate Whitaker and his jukeing and jiving style horrendously.

He wouldn't have the power to hurt Pac and he himself has a glass jaw which we saw from the Trinidad fight. And Trinidad doesn't have the combination of power and speed like Pac

Pac would beat him down badly and eventually get tired of chaseing him around the ring like Cotto and Mosley

Theres also a 50-50 chance he gets hattoned

lmmfao....if trinidad, who absolutely flattened natural welters, jr. welters, and at least one good middleweight, couldn't put away a half coked out, past prime juking and jiving pea, whats make you think pacquaio could do anything with a prime whitaker, who NOBODY could hit in his prime...

[Kuyukut]

Originally Posted by Bombs

Pacquiao would have embarrassed Whitaker and knocked him out cold in less than 4 rounds. Don't compare a God to a mere mortal human. Pacquiao is on another level.

Amen.....................................

[SCtrojansbaby]

Pacquiao and its not even close

Top 5 wins

Barrera x2(Barrera was a little past his prime for the second fight)
Saskul
Marquez
Hatton

vs

Vasquez
Nelson(worse than any catchweight Manny ever had)
Ramirez(who was past his prime)
McGirt
Roger Mayweather

[SCtrojansbaby]

Originally Posted by Roman Moreno

IMO Whitaker has the greatest resume than any fighter in the last 25 years. I don't think there has been a greater fighter than Whitaker in the last 25 years.

lol yeah those wins against Julio Cesar Vasquez and Nelson Axumah at lightweight really stand out. Whitaker's resume sucks and is probable the bare minimum for an ATG