|View Poll Results: Which of these fighters deserve to be in the HOF one day???|
|Jose Luis Castillo||13||30.23%|
|Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 43. You may not vote on this poll|
|03-06-2012, 04:26 PM||#11|
Join Date: Nov 2009
Quoted: 1 Post(s)Rep Power: 35
Total Points: 36,778,535,564.95
Winky and Cotto for sure.
Genaro Hernandez, yes
The HOF should NOT reward known cheaters Shane Mosley (otherwise would have said yes) and Antonio Margarito
I'm on the fence about Hatton. I think his losses to Manny and Floyd overshadow his body of work as a fighter. Still had some decent wins to his credit.
The rest of the guys, you can probably make a decent arguement either way
|03-06-2012, 05:21 PM||#12|
Join Date: Oct 2010
Quoted: 2798 Post(s)Rep Power: 135
Total Points: 10,140,962,316,078,882,816.00
the two easiest decisions are wright and mosley. at their best they were two terrific fighters with some damn good wins.
they are getting in to the hall of fame. and i'd vote for them to get in on a pretty early ballot in all likelihood (depending of course on who else is going to be on the ballot. you can only vote ten times i believe, and i'm certain only three fighters get in each year.)
next two who will get in pretty easily are cotto and hatton
both had huge followings, were in very big fights, had been p4p for long periods.
i think they'll get a bit more credit than they deserve and get in pretty quickly
and of course cotto has the whole margarito thing to blame. he was never the same after that fight and it will certainly weigh on the decision.
i think hamed is eventually getting in as well
everybody else is borderline
sympathy votes for corales and hernandez
i wouldn't probably vote for anybody other than shane and winky early on, especially if there are other good candidates.
and margarito will never even sniff the hall.
|03-06-2012, 05:23 PM||#14|
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Lost Souls
Quoted: 0 Post(s)Rep Power: 0
Total Points: 94,888,893.87
|03-06-2012, 05:31 PM||#16|
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: land of no sweet tea
Quoted: 0 Post(s)Rep Power: 0
Total Points: 112,631,432,782.41
|03-06-2012, 06:03 PM||#17|
Join Date: Oct 2008
Quoted: 150 Post(s)Rep Power: 14
Total Points: 1,417,276,111,359,962.75
i say corrales and castillo get in just because of their first fight. what an epic classic, and probably my favorite fight. best fight i've ever seen. the 2 best lightweights in an all-out, back and forth, dramatic war. otherwise they would be borderline. they both had some nice wins (including each other), not first-ballot kind of guys though. i also thought castillo beat mayweather so extra bonus for him.
mosley, wright, and cotto for sure.
johnston and margarito, no.
hatton....maybe. again, not a first-ballot kind of guy. tszyu win was real good, collazo is an ok win but controversial. i think that WBA welterweight title helps his case a lot so he probably gets in. i personally wouldn't vote him.
i dont know enough about hernandez and wasn't really there for his prime years. i'm not familiar with the guys on his resume outside of mayweather, DLH, azumah nelson, jorge paez, and hernandez. but looking at his resume i kinda lean towards no. although prime hernandez is a very good win as i consider him to be underrated and had some losses that easily could have gone the other way.
hamed had 15 defenses of the WBO title and a 3x featherweight champion with good wins over kelley, mccullough, vazquez, sanchez...yes.
if it was me personally voting on the ballots: mosley, cotto, wright, corrales, castillo, and hamed.
|03-06-2012, 06:11 PM||#18|
Nothing But Sunshine
Join Date: Jul 2011
Quoted: 636 Post(s)Rep Power: 51
Total Points: 1,000,200,106,252,161.50
If I had to say at some point who I would pick to get in: I'd say Cotto, Mosley, Corrales, Hatton, G. Hernandez, and Castillo.
|03-06-2012, 06:13 PM||#19|
Join Date: Apr 2009
Quoted: 1 Post(s)Rep Power: 22
Total Points: 55,362,178,463,059.38
i dont think any of them will get in. mosley would be the most deserving in my opinion. but hes got the whole drugs thing.
im not sure cotto should get in. vacant title after vacant title might hinder his chances.
hatton shouldnt get in. he didnt really beat collazo. and his best win is against an aged tszyu even if he was p4p number 2 at the time. just the same way people are slating calzaghes win over hopkins who was rated top 5 p4p at the time.
|Share This With Friends|
|deserve, fame???, fighters, hall|