Other than Pac,FMJ, JMM, Donaire's RESUME is SUPERIOR than ALL OTHER TOP 10 P4P - Page 2

DTMB

Quote:

Originally Posted by DempseyRollin

u made the thread. how about u explain how donaires is better? his best wins are darchinyan, and montiel.

thats comparable to froch and kessler but imo, the edge goes to ward.

sydorenko is comparable to abaraham as well, id say abraham is better tho.

then u have wins like marquez, maldonaldo, and mthalane which are comparable to bika, allan green and miranda. the edge there might go to donaire. either way, its close, but i do think ward has went thru the tougher schedule and hes fought at a weight much more natural for him.

Yes i made a thread and i explained it in my OP & no wards resume is not better than donaire.

Much props to your avi:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=443150

DTMB

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russian Crushin

In B4 wards better cuz he's undefeated

we all know why some posters think ward is better but im not gonna go there rc.

but its quite obvious.

puga · 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DempseyRollin

u made the thread. how about u explain how donaires is better? his best wins are darchinyan, and montiel.

thats comparable to froch and kessler but imo, the edge goes to ward.

sydorenko is comparable to abaraham as well, id say abraham is better tho.

then u have wins like marquez, maldonaldo, and mthalane which are comparable to bika, allan green and miranda. the edge there might go to donaire. either way, its close, but i do think ward has went thru the tougher schedule and hes fought at a weight much more natural for him.

none of ward's wins is better than nonito's wins over montile and dachinyan imo...on the bolded, tyson marquez and mthlane are current champions right now where none of bika , miranda, or green have ever been champions...

i say bika is nonito's maldonado, green is his raul martinez and im pretty sure vasuqez is a better win than a miranda...

but both ward and nonito have the better resume than sergio, no doubt...

bojangles1987

Quote:

Originally Posted by DempseyRollin

i think wards resume is better.

Meh, I'd go Donaire. Dude has some wins that go unnoticed.

SoggyLungs

one thing is for sure is that donaire has some pretty good wins on his resume so far...if donaire beats rigondeaux, and then beats nishioka and moves up to 126 to beat a good champion there and thus winning his 4th belt in a 4th division...then he deserves to be hof'er as far as i'm concerned.

C.Y.

I like both donaire and ward. They both rep the bay area and seem like good people. I think their resumes are comparable, maybe slight edge to the flash, but I think ward is a better fighter. Donaire may be more exciting and he does have some slickness in him, but he needs to work on his defense he was getting tagged his last fight by a guy who had no business hitting him like that

AdamantiumPI

Quote:

Originally Posted by SoggyLungs

one thing is for sure is that donaire has some pretty good wins on his resume so far...if donaire beats rigondeaux, and then beats nishioka and moves up to 126 to beat a good champion there and thus winning his 4th belt in a 4th division...then he deserves to be hof'er as far as i'm concerned.

I know Donaire won an interim belt at 115 but 126 would be his 5th division. I agree if Donaire would be able to beat a top guy at 122 like Nishioka or Rigondeaux and beat a champion at 126 like the Salido/Juanma Lopez winner then he should be a hof'er. Those fights would be tough for Donaire and I'm not so sure if he could pull it off.

I rank Ward ahead of Donaire because he has dominated his opponents and has a comparable resume to Donaire.

loui_ludwig

Ward and Martinez are better.

andrtaker

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTMB

Just look at the top 10 p4p list in all of boxing according to Ring Magazine:

1 - Pac
2 - Floyd
3 - Sergio
4- Donaire
5 -Ward
6 - JMM
7 - Wlad K
8 - Pong**** Wong**** (gtfo with that name and gtfo of thailand to fight)
9 - Bradley
10 - Vit K

Other than Pac, JMM, Floyd, Donaire's resume is superior than the rest:

-4 division champion (112,115,118,122)
- 2 spectacular KOs of two top 10 p4p fighters in two different divisions ( Montiel 118, Darchinyan 112)

Those two facts alone along with his slick american blackness boxing style coupled with his supreme athleticism, no one in the top 10 can say they have a better resume than donaire other than the aforementioned fighters and maybe sergio.

You cannot deny this man. Last but not least STFU about Rigondeaux. The guy has 9 wins his best coming against ricardo cordoba. Dont let your obvious Pacquiao hate racially seep over to this obviously talented, young, and already decorated fighter.

I know what your trying to do, but I aint falling for it. Your trying to make another band of nuthuggers. Nice try Mr. white boy but you failed.

TheMelvern

Hes actually a 3 division champion and Darchynian was not on the top 10 p4p list when they fought.

SoggyLungs Faceless Man Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 5,163 Rep Power: 13 Points: 100,061,428.73 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 100,061,428.73 Donate	one thing is for sure is that donaire has some pretty good wins on his resume so far...if donaire beats rigondeaux, and then beats nishioka and moves up to 126 to beat a good champion there and thus winning his 4th belt in a 4th division...then he deserves to be hof'er as far as i'm concerned.

C.Y. Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: The Bay Area, California Posts: 2,192 Rep Power: 10 Points: 111,518.23 Bank: 672,028.79 Total Points: 783,547.02 Donate	I like both donaire and ward. They both rep the bay area and seem like good people. I think their resumes are comparable, maybe slight edge to the flash, but I think ward is a better fighter. Donaire may be more exciting and he does have some slickness in him, but he needs to work on his defense he was getting tagged his last fight by a guy who had no business hitting him like that

loui_ludwig Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2005 Age: 26 Posts: 7,603 Rep Power: 28 Points: 291,085.17 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 291,085.17 Donate	Ward and Martinez are better.

TheMelvern Contender Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: KS Posts: 296 Rep Power: 5 Points: 11,064,566.90 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 11,064,566.90 Donate	Hes actually a 3 division champion and Darchynian was not on the top 10 p4p list when they fought.