Who ranks higher P4P. Roberto Duran or Joe Gans?

Barnburner

Think I'm gonna give it to Duran here by a shade. Could be different tomorrow though.

NChristo

Used to think Gans but now imo it's Duran although it's kinda close I think he's definitely ahead too me.

Barnburner

Quote:

Originally Posted by NChristo

Used to think Gans but now imo it's Duran although it's kinda close I think he's definitely ahead too me.

I would get a better idea if I got off my lazy arse and done my Duran thread.

In all seriousness though, doing MacBeth at school so gotta do a ****load for that. I should have my Duran thread done during the weekend in case anyone was wondering if I had abandoned it.

Obama

Gans is in my top 5. Duran may not even be in my top 20.

Barnburner

Quote:

Originally Posted by Obama

Gans is in my top 5. Duran may not even be in my top 20.

Do you feel a win on Gans resume is better than Duran's over Sugar Ray?

I know this hasn't got a great deal to do with the ranking.

BennyST · 08:49 AM

This is one of those weird which I could change on a daily basis. I normally put Duran a little higher P4P based on his higher weight wins, but have Gans ahead at 135. He was amazing and has great wins at 135 and 147, but I just can't take away from the Duran wins at 147 up to 160 along with his wins from 118 to 140.

Barnburner TheTartanSoldier Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Scotland Posts: 8,256 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 37 Points: 416,101,766,540.46 Bank: 9,180,030,840,105.33 Total Points: 9,596,132,606,645.79 Donate	Who ranks higher P4P. Roberto Duran or Joe Gans? Think I'm gonna give it to Duran here by a shade. Could be different tomorrow though.

NChristo Morning Glory Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Blackpool Posts: 4,882 Rep Power: 15 Points: 1,000,016,042.59 Bank: 471,651,983,135.21 Total Points: 472,651,999,177.80 Donate	Used to think Gans but now imo it's Duran although it's kinda close I think he's definitely ahead too me.

Obama Undisputed Champion Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Philadelphia, PA Posts: 4,170 Rep Power: 104 Points: 338,903.06 Bank: 3,585,881,619,724.36 Total Points: 3,585,881,958,627.42 Donate	Gans is in my top 5. Duran may not even be in my top 20.

BennyST Shhhh... Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Australia Posts: 8,528 Rep Power: 52 Points: 20,233,056,903.54 Bank: 64,247,554,061.65 Total Points: 84,480,610,965.19 Donate	This is one of those weird which I could change on a daily basis. I normally put Duran a little higher P4P based on his higher weight wins, but have Gans ahead at 135. He was amazing and has great wins at 135 and 147, but I just can't take away from the Duran wins at 147 up to 160 along with his wins from 118 to 140. Last edited by BennyST; 02-02-2012 at 08:49 AM.