Steve Smoger's take on Cotto-Margarito (Great Read) - Page 4

heat27 · 12:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Weebler II

First credit to the guy, he reffed a good fight and made the right call. It's cool that he talks about the officiating, but

I'm uncomfortable with refs talking about the actual fight and about boxers.

Who wants to be reffed by Smoger in their next fight with Cotto or Margarito now?

He called them warriors and give both fighters credit

What is wrong with that?

paulf

Smoger and Bayless are the only ones that should be allowed near big big fights. Dracula aint bad either, but I haven't seen him work a big fight since Diaz JMM II

ThePhantom5

Smoger should ref Maidana-Rios if it ever happens.

hayZ

Awesome ref, I hope he refs more high profile fights and Cortez needs to retire. He gets involved in the fight more than the fighters at times, Smoger realises that he has to make the fight as natural as it can be, allow in-fighting and only interfere when he absolutely has to. Cortez does not allow fighting on the inside and hes generally an annoying guy when reffing.

Smoger and Bayless are the best.

hkp30l

Smoger by far the best in the business. When you see Steve up there you know it's going to be fair.

The Weebler II · 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russian Crushin

Theres not such thing as a completely objective ref

I'm aware of that, but when referees are also fans of the fighter it can influence how they call a fight and making public statements to that effect can influence the perceptions of the spectator and are not in the interests of the sport.

They're there to officiate, that's it, nothing more. Not analyse a fight, say how much they like this fighter or that fighter etc.

Can you imagine if a tennis umpire came out and said how he really liked how one player played? or a NFL, EPL or NBA referee how he was a big fan of a certain team? It's digging a hole for themselves and raising suspicions.

Just ref. Leave the analysis and fanboyism to the paid analysts and fans.

ThePhantom5

..................bump

ThePunchingBag

ATG Ref right here.

If he's not in the HOF yet, he should be.

paulf Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Back In The USA! (Oklahoma) Posts: 9,117 Rep Power: 26 Points: 6,080,581,081.66 Bank: 130.51 Total Points: 6,080,581,212.17 Donate	Smoger and Bayless are the only ones that should be allowed near big big fights. Dracula aint bad either, but I haven't seen him work a big fight since Diaz JMM II

ThePhantom5 The Boss Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: State College, PA Posts: 21,662 Rep Power: 75 Points: 19,817,040,209.89 Bank: 1,140,690,790,893.23 Total Points: 1,160,507,831,103.12 Donate	Smoger should ref Maidana-Rios if it ever happens.

hkp30l Up and Comer Join Date: Dec 2011 Posts: 56 Rep Power: 2 Points: 1,452.70 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,452.70 Donate	Smoger by far the best in the business. When you see Steve up there you know it's going to be fair.

ThePunchingBag Rolling with the punches. Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 5,288 Rep Power: 15 Points: 281,276.97 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 281,276.97 Donate	ATG Ref right here. If he's not in the HOF yet, he should be.