Do You Agree With This? (From Bert Sugar Rankings)

[McGoorty]

Originally Posted by FenechJeff

I thought the same thing Mate. Wilde is an underatted fightyer.

Yeah, and I find it amazing, best Flyweight ever by far............ Maybe the easiest choice in any linear Division... Except LES DARCY.

[NChristo]

Disagree with all of them, have never understood Sugars reasoning / criteria for his ridiculous ratings.

I take this back, I agree with McLarnin over Leonard, only skimmed over the names.

Can't agree with Wilde over Monzon at all, Monzon's resume is so much deeper.

[NChristo]

Originally Posted by McGoorty

Yeah, I do to,... I overlooked that one........ Yeah Wilde is for sure in my book, #1. Flyweight is better than a guy at best #6 but I have him lower than that.. I know a few MW's that were better.

I will actually fight you to the death if you think Darcy is a greater MW then Monzon.

[McGoorty]

Originally Posted by NChristo

I will actually fight you to the death if you think Darcy is a greater MW then Monzon.

I think it's about them fighting each other,...... or at least I thought we were.

[McGoorty]

Originally Posted by NChristo

I will actually fight you to the death if you think Darcy is a greater MW then Monzon.

But,..... let's put it this way.... If Darcy had lived till he was 30, I think he would surpass them all...... and i won't make any apologies.... this is an open forum.

[McGoorty]

Originally Posted by NChristo

I will actually fight you to the death if you think Darcy is a greater MW then Monzon.

I just looked at the question again...... It's Wilde V Monzon.

[Sugarj]

Originally Posted by Perfect Plex

I don't want to debate his entire list. I just want to see your opinion of his ranking certain fighters over each other. Right.......

-George Foreman Over Pernell Whitaker?: Agree or Disagree?

-Jimmy McLarnin Over Sugar Ray Leonard: Agree or Disagree?

-Marcel Cerdan Over Marvin Hagler: Agree or Disagree?

-Jimmy Wilde Over Carlos Moznon: Agree or Disagree?

-Julio Cesar Chavez Over Ezzard Charles: Agree or Disagree?

I disagree with all of those except Chavez over Charles. That one for me is a close call.....

[NChristo]

Originally Posted by McGoorty

I just looked at the question again...... It's Wilde V Monzon.

Why would we put a small flyweight against a big middleweight, we're talking about achievements here not who would win in a fight.
Come on Sweet Pea vs Foreman ?....

Originally Posted by McGoorty

But,..... let's put it this way.... If Darcy had lived till he was 30, I think he would surpass them all...... and i won't make any apologies.... this is an open forum.

Except he didn't live till he was 30 so he doesn't and no one knows how his career would of gone had he lived on.

[RubenSonny]

Originally Posted by Sugarj

I disagree with all of those except Chavez over Charles. That one for me is a close call.....

It's really not, Charles ****s on Chavez in every way.

[Barnburner]

Originally Posted by NChristo

I take this back, I agree with McLarnin over Leonard, only skimmed over the names.

Yeah I did this at first as well got the names the wrong way round and stuff.

Can't agree with Wilde over Monzon at all, Monzon's resume is so much deeper.

I could see it but, I don't agree with it.

Originally Posted by NChristo

I will actually fight you to the death if you think Darcy is a greater MW then Monzon.

Originally Posted by McGoorty

But,..... let's put it this way.... If Darcy had lived till he was 30, I think he would surpass them all...... and i won't make any apologies.... this is an open forum.

Strongly disagree there my friend.

Originally Posted by RubenSonny

It's really not, Charles ****s on Chavez in every way.

You tell 'em Ruben!